The Idle Rich

Plot

Millionaire William van Luyn, a wealthy bachelor accustomed to a life of luxury, falls deeply in love with his efficient and charming secretary Joan Thayer. Despite their class differences, he proposes marriage and Joan accepts, much to the excitement of her modest middle-class family. However, Joan's family members, particularly her proud father and her blowhard nephew Henry who constantly reminds everyone of their status as 'the great middle class,' are initially reluctant to accept William's generosity and financial assistance. In a surprising move, William abandons his mansion and moves into the Thayer family's modest home, insisting on living as one of them. The family continues to resist his help and maintains their independence until William finally takes drastic action to prove his love and demonstrate that wealth means nothing compared to family unity and genuine affection.

Historical Background

The Idle Rich was released in March 1929, during a period of immense social and economic transformation in America. The Roaring Twenties were drawing to a close, and the film's release came just seven months before the devastating stock market crash of October 1929 that would trigger the Great Depression. The movie's exploration of class differences and wealth disparity was particularly relevant to an American society that was increasingly questioning the morality of extreme wealth concentration. The film industry itself was undergoing its own revolution with the transition from silent films to talkies, a change that was reshaping Hollywood's business model and creative practices. The late 1920s also saw the rise of the consumer culture and the emergence of what would later be called the 'American Dream,' making the film's message about the value of middle-class virtues over inherited wealth resonate with audiences. Additionally, 1929 was a year when women's roles in society were evolving, with more women entering the workforce and challenging traditional gender roles, reflected in Bessie Love's character as a competent secretary who marries her wealthy employer.

Making Of

The production of The Idle Rich took place during a revolutionary period in Hollywood history as the industry was rapidly converting from silent to sound films. The cast and crew had to adapt to the cumbersome early sound recording equipment, which required actors to speak directly into hidden microphones and limited their movement. Conrad Nagel, having already appeared in several successful talkies, helped guide his co-stars through the technical challenges. Director William C. deMille, known for his patient and methodical approach, took extra time to ensure the dialogue scenes sounded natural despite the technical limitations. The film's middle-class family home sets were meticulously designed to contrast with the opulent mansion scenes, visually reinforcing the class divide at the story's core. Screenwriters Frances Marion and John Howard Lawson worked to craft dialogue that would sound authentic when recorded, avoiding the stilted, theatrical delivery that plagued many early talkies. The production team faced particular challenges with sound synchronization during the more comedic scenes, requiring multiple takes to achieve the proper timing for both visual gags and spoken punchlines.

Visual Style

The cinematography of The Idle Rich was handled by Ira H. Morgan, who had to adapt his techniques to the new demands of sound filming. The visual style contrasted the cold, formal compositions of the wealthy mansion scenes with warmer, more intimate framing in the middle-class home settings. Early sound recording equipment required cameras to be enclosed in soundproof booths, limiting their mobility and forcing Morgan to rely more on static compositions and careful actor blocking. The film used lighting to emphasize the emotional differences between the two worlds, with the mansion scenes featuring harsh, artificial lighting while the family home scenes utilized softer, more naturalistic illumination. Despite the technical limitations of early sound filming, Morgan managed to create visual interest through strategic use of depth and careful composition within the constrained camera movements. The cinematography successfully supported the film's themes by visually reinforcing the emotional and social distance between the worlds of wealth and middle-class values.

Innovations

The Idle Rich represented several technical achievements for its time, particularly in the realm of early sound recording. The film successfully employed the Vitaphone sound-on-disc system with relatively good synchronization between audio and visual elements. The production team developed innovative techniques for hiding microphones within the sets to allow for more natural actor movement, a significant improvement over the static recording methods used in many early talkies. The film also demonstrated advances in sound mixing, balancing dialogue, music, and sound effects in a way that was more sophisticated than many contemporary productions. The lighting techniques developed to accommodate sound recording without compromising visual quality were particularly noteworthy, as the crew found ways to work around the heat and noise generated by the sound equipment. Additionally, the film's editing showed improved understanding of pacing in sound films, avoiding the awkward pauses that plagued many early talkies.

Music

The Idle Rich featured a musical score composed by William Axt, one of MGM's staff composers who was prolific during the transition to sound. The film utilized the new Vitaphone sound-on-disc system, which was still being refined during this period. The soundtrack included both synchronized musical accompaniment and dialogue sequences, representing the hybrid approach common in early talkies. Axt's score emphasized the emotional contrast between the sterile world of wealth and the warm family environment, using leitmotifs to represent the different social worlds. The film also featured several popular songs of the period that were integrated into the narrative, a common practice in early musical comedies. The sound recording presented significant technical challenges, as the early microphones had limited range and were sensitive to extraneous noise. Despite these limitations, the film's audio quality was considered above average for its time, with dialogue that remained mostly clear and intelligible throughout.

Memorable Scenes

• The climactic dinner scene where William attempts to cook a meal for the family, resulting in comedic chaos but ultimately winning their respect through his willingness to try.
• The emotional confrontation in the family living room where William declares his love for Joan and his intention to abandon his wealth to be with her family.
• The opening sequence showing William's sterile, empty mansion contrasted with the warm, chaotic energy of the Thayer family home.
• The scene where Henry delivers his passionate speech about the dignity and pride of the middle class, becoming the film's social conscience.
• The wedding sequence that brings together both worlds, showing the awkward but ultimately touching blending of wealthy and middle-class traditions.

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception to The Idle Rich was generally positive, with reviewers praising the film's charming performances and timely social commentary. The New York Times noted that 'William C. deMille has directed with his customary light touch, and the result is an entertaining comedy that speaks to our times.' Variety particularly praised Conrad Nagel's performance, stating that 'Nagel proves once again that he is one of the few silent stars who has truly mastered the new medium of sound.' Critics appreciated the film's balanced approach to its social themes, avoiding heavy-handed moralizing while still delivering a message about the value of character over wealth. The trade papers also commended the film's technical achievements in sound recording, noting that the dialogue sounded more natural than in many other early talkies. Modern film historians view The Idle Rich as an interesting example of early sound comedy that successfully bridged the gap between silent and sound eras, though it is generally considered a minor work in the careers of its director and stars.

What Audiences Thought

Audiences in 1929 responded positively to The Idle Rich, finding its blend of romance and social commentary both entertaining and relevant to their concerns about class and economic inequality. The film's timing was particularly fortuitous, as it tapped into growing public sentiment about the excesses of the wealthy class while still providing the escapist entertainment that moviegoers craved. Theater reports indicated that the film performed well in both urban and rural markets, suggesting its themes resonated across different demographic groups. Conrad Nagel's popularity with female audiences helped drive ticket sales, while Bessie Love's relatable portrayal of a middle-class working woman struck a chord with the many women who had entered the workforce during the 1920s. The film's success at the box office demonstrated that audiences were ready for more sophisticated comedies that addressed real social issues, a trend that would continue throughout the 1930s. However, the film's popularity was somewhat overshadowed by the massive impact of the stock market crash later that year, which shifted public tastes toward even more escapist fare.

You Might Also Like