The Immigrant

Plot

The Immigrant follows the journey of the Tramp (Charlie Chaplin) and a fellow immigrant woman (Edna Purviance) as they travel in steerage class aboard a steamship heading to America. During the turbulent voyage, the Tramp befriends the woman and her ailing mother, though the mother tragically passes away before reaching their destination. Upon arriving at Ellis Island, the immigrants face harsh treatment from authorities, and the Tramp gets into various comedic mishaps while trying to navigate the new world. After being separated during processing, the Tramp finds work as a waiter in a restaurant where he reunites with the woman. The film culminates with the Tramp using his wits to help the woman escape from the restaurant's predatory owner, leading to a hopeful ending as the two walk off together into their new American life, symbolizing the immigrant dream of freedom and opportunity.

Historical Background

The Immigrant was released in June 1917, just two months after the United States entered World War I, during a period of massive European immigration to America. Between 1880 and 1920, over 23 million immigrants came to the United States, with 1917 seeing approximately 295,000 arrivals despite the war. The film reflected both the American dream and the harsh realities faced by newcomers, including exploitative working conditions and bureaucratic indifference at immigration centers. This period also saw rising nativism and anti-immigrant sentiment, which would lead to the Immigration Act of 1918 and later the restrictive Immigration Act of 1924. Chaplin, himself a British immigrant who arrived in America in 1910, brought personal understanding to the subject. The film's sympathetic portrayal of immigrants was somewhat controversial given the political climate, but it resonated with the millions of first and second-generation Americans in the audience. The industrial setting of the restaurant also reflected America's rapid urbanization and the growth of service industry jobs that employed many new immigrants.

Making Of

The production of The Immigrant showcased Chaplin's meticulous attention to detail and his growing artistic control over his films. For the ship sequences, Chaplin had his crew construct a massive set that could be mechanically tilted to create realistic rolling motion, allowing for the famous scene where characters slide across the deck. The restaurant sequence required weeks of rehearsal to perfect the complex timing of the physical comedy, including the iconic moment where Chaplin skillfully balances multiple plates while being harassed by customers. Chaplin's relationship with Edna Purviance extended beyond the screen, and he carefully crafted her character to be more than just a love interest, giving her agency and emotional depth unusual for female characters in silent comedy. The film's production coincided with Chaplin's growing fame and his increasing conflicts with Mutual Film Corporation over creative control and financial compensation, leading to his eventual move to United Artists. The immigration scenes were filmed with actual immigrants as extras, adding authenticity to the portrayal of the Ellis Island experience.

Visual Style

The cinematography of The Immigrant, credited to Roland Totheroh and William C. Foster, demonstrates remarkable technical innovation for 1917. The ship sequences feature pioneering camera work, including the use of tilting platforms to simulate ocean motion and creative framing to convey the claustrophobic conditions of steerage class. The famous shot of the Statue of Liberty appearing through the ship's porthole became an iconic image in cinema, symbolizing both hope and the distant nature of the American dream. The restaurant scenes showcase sophisticated deep focus techniques, allowing multiple actions to occur simultaneously within the frame - a technical achievement that enhanced the complex physical comedy. The film's lighting evolved from the harsh, high-contrast style of the ship scenes to the warmer, more naturalistic lighting of the restaurant, reflecting the characters' journey from hardship to relative comfort. The camera movement in the final escape sequence, following the couple as they run from the restaurant, creates a sense of freedom and momentum that perfectly complements the emotional resolution.

Innovations

The Immigrant showcased several technical innovations that advanced the art of cinema. The most notable was the elaborate ship set built on mechanical tilting platforms, allowing for realistic simulation of ocean motion while maintaining camera stability - a significant engineering achievement for 1917. The film's use of deep focus photography in the restaurant scenes was ahead of its time, enabling multiple layers of action within a single shot. Chaplin's pioneering use of long takes, particularly in the restaurant sequence, demonstrated remarkable confidence in his performers and technical crew. The film's editing rhythm, especially in the montage sequence showing the ship's journey, influenced future documentary and narrative filmmaking techniques. The special effects used to create the illusion of the rolling sea involved innovative camera mounts and lighting techniques. The film's preservation and restoration in the late 20th century also contributed to advances in film restoration technology, particularly in dealing with nitrate film deterioration. The synchronization of physical comedy with musical cues in Chaplin's later composed score demonstrated sophisticated understanding of audio-visual relationships.

Music

As a silent film, The Immigrant originally featured live musical accompaniment that varied by theater. Chaplin himself composed a score for the film in the 1930s for re-release, which included the recurring theme 'The Vagabond' that he had composed earlier in his career. The original 1917 theatrical screenings typically featured a pianist or small orchestra playing popular songs of the era, classical pieces, and improvised music synchronized to the on-screen action. Modern restorations have used Chaplin's 1930s score as the basis, with some versions featuring newly recorded orchestrations. The music for the ship scenes traditionally used minor keys and dramatic tempos to emphasize the hardship of the journey, while the restaurant sequences featured lighter, more playful melodies. The final scene often incorporated uplifting, optimistic music to reinforce the film's hopeful conclusion. Chaplin's musical approach emphasized leitmotifs for characters, with the Tramp's theme appearing throughout to maintain emotional continuity.

Memorable Scenes

• The Tramp and other immigrants seasick on the tilting ship deck, sliding uncontrollably during rough weather
• The first glimpse of the Statue of Liberty through the ship's porthole, symbolizing arrival in America
• The chaotic restaurant scene where the Tramp struggles as a waiter, balancing plates while dealing with difficult customers
• The Tramp's clever method of paying his restaurant bill by finding money in a customer's pocket
• The final escape sequence where the Tramp helps the woman flee the predatory restaurant owner
• The emotional scene on Ellis Island where the Tramp comforts the grieving woman after her mother's death
• The iconic shot of the Tramp kicking the immigration officer who has been harassing him
• The tender moment when the Tramp shares his meager food with the hungry woman on the ship

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised The Immigrant as one of Chaplin's finest works, with Variety calling it 'a masterpiece of comedy and pathos' and The New York Times noting its 'perfect blend of humor and humanity'. Critics particularly admired the film's technical achievements in the ship sequences and the brilliant choreography of the restaurant scene. Modern critics continue to celebrate the film, with Roger Ebert including it in his 'Great Movies' collection, calling it 'Chaplin at his most profound and entertaining'. The film holds a rare 100% rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on critical reviews, with consensus highlighting its timeless relevance and artistic excellence. Film scholars have extensively analyzed the work for its social commentary, with many considering it Chaplin's most politically sophisticated film from his Mutual period. The film's reputation has only grown over time, with contemporary critics appreciating how it addresses immigration issues that remain relevant today while maintaining universal appeal through its humanistic approach to comedy.

What Audiences Thought

The Immigrant was enormously popular with audiences in 1917, becoming one of Chaplin's most successful Mutual releases. Contemporary theater owners reported packed houses and enthusiastic responses, particularly to the restaurant sequence which often drew applause and laughter. The film resonated strongly with immigrant audiences who saw their own experiences reflected on screen, while also appealing to native-born Americans through its universal themes of hope and perseverance. In the decades since its release, the film has maintained its popularity through revivals, film society screenings, and home video releases. Modern audiences continue to connect with the film's emotional core and physical comedy, with many considering it one of Chaplin's most accessible works. The film's availability on streaming platforms and DVD collections has introduced it to new generations, maintaining its status as a beloved classic. Audience polls consistently rank it among Chaplin's best short films, and it remains a favorite in film education programs for its perfect demonstration of silent comedy techniques and social commentary.

You Might Also Like