The Man of the Sea

Plot

Nolff, a proud and stern Breton fisherman, is overjoyed when his wife gives birth to their son Michel, whom he dreams will follow in his footsteps and become a fisherman. However, as Michel grows into adulthood, he rejects his father's traditional way of life, preferring to spend his time in taverns and pursuing pleasure rather than the hard work of fishing. The generational conflict intensifies when Michel falls for a sophisticated woman from the city, further distancing himself from his Breton roots and family obligations. Nolff's disappointment turns to despair as he watches his son abandon the sea that has sustained their family for generations. The film culminates in a dramatic confrontation between father and son, exploring the clash between traditional values and modern desires in early 20th century Brittany.

Historical Background

The Man of the Sea was produced during a pivotal period in French cinema following World War I. The war had devastated France both economically and culturally, and the film industry was struggling to rebuild. This period saw a movement toward more realistic, socially conscious filmmaking that reflected the changing French society. The film's exploration of generational conflict and the tension between tradition and modernity mirrored broader social changes occurring in France during the early 1920s. The industrial revolution was transforming rural areas, and many young people were leaving traditional occupations like fishing for urban opportunities. L'Herbier's film captured this moment of transition, making it not just entertainment but a social document of its time. The film also represents the emergence of French Impressionist cinema, a movement that emphasized visual style and psychological depth over narrative conventions.

Making Of

Marcel L'Herbier was determined to break from the theatrical conventions of early French cinema by creating a film rooted in realism. He spent three months living among Breton fishing communities before production, studying their customs, dialect, and way of life. The casting process was particularly challenging as L'Herbier sought actors who could embody the rugged authenticity of Breton fishermen. Jaque Catelain, who played Michel, underwent extensive preparation including learning basic fishing techniques and spending time with local fishermen to understand their physical movements and mannerisms. The production faced numerous difficulties, including a near-disaster when a fishing boat capsized during filming, though fortunately no one was seriously injured. L'Herbier's innovative use of natural light, particularly in the outdoor scenes, was considered groundbreaking for the period and influenced many subsequent French filmmakers.

Visual Style

The cinematography of The Man of the Sea, handled by Georges Lucas and Jimmy Berliet, was revolutionary for its time. The film made extensive use of natural light, particularly in the outdoor scenes, creating a visual poetry that contrasted the harsh reality of fishing life with moments of beauty. The camera work included innovative tracking shots filmed from boats, creating a sense of movement and immersion that was unprecedented in French cinema. The cinematographers employed special filters and techniques to capture the changing moods of the sea, from calm waters to stormy seas, using the ocean as almost a character in the film. The visual style incorporated elements of French Impressionism, with soft focus and unusual camera angles to convey psychological states. The contrast between the bright, open spaces of the sea and the dark, confined spaces of the tavern created a visual metaphor for the film's central conflict between freedom and constraint.

Innovations

The Man of the Sea featured several technical innovations that were groundbreaking for 1920. The film pioneered the use of location shooting on a large scale, with L'Herbier developing portable camera equipment that could withstand the harsh conditions of the Breton coast. The underwater sequences required the development of waterproof camera housing, one of the first such innovations in French cinema. The film also experimented with multiple exposure techniques to create dream sequences and psychological moments, particularly in scenes depicting Michel's internal conflicts. The production team developed specialized lighting equipment that could be used effectively on boats and in remote locations, solving a major technical challenge of outdoor filming. The film's editing techniques, particularly its use of cross-cutting between the father and son to emphasize their emotional distance, were considered advanced for the period and influenced subsequent French filmmakers.

Music

As a silent film, The Man of the Sea originally featured live musical accompaniment during screenings. The score was composed by Paul Fosse and incorporated traditional Breton folk melodies, creating an authentic atmosphere that enhanced the film's regional setting. The music included traditional Breton instruments such as the biniou (Breton bagpipe) and bombarde, which were unusual in cinema scores of the period. During the film's Paris premiere, a full orchestra performed the score, while in provincial theaters, smaller ensembles or even single pianists adapted the music for local audiences. The soundtrack also included sound effects created live, such as the sound of waves and seagulls, to enhance the immersive experience. Modern restorations of the film have included newly recorded scores that attempt to recreate the original musical intentions while taking advantage of contemporary recording technology.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence showing Nolff's pride at his son's birth, contrasted with the harsh reality of the fishing life
• The dramatic storm sequence where Nolff and his crew battle the elements, showcasing the dangerous reality of their profession
• Michel's first visit to the tavern, where he tastes the forbidden pleasures of city life and begins his transformation
• The emotional confrontation between father and son on the beach, with the sea as their silent witness
• The final scene where Nolff faces the sea alone, having lost both his son and his dreams for the future

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised The Man of the Sea for its visual beauty and authentic portrayal of Breton life. Le Film Complet called it 'a masterpiece of French cinema' and particularly highlighted L'Herbier's innovative camera work. The French newspaper Le Temps praised the film's 'poetic realism' and its ability to capture 'the very soul of the Breton people.' Modern critics have reevaluated the film as an important work of the French Impressionist movement, with film historian Georges Sadoul noting its 'revolutionary use of location and natural elements.' The film is now recognized as a significant influence on subsequent realist traditions in French cinema, including the poetic realism of the 1930s and the French New Wave of the 1950s. Recent restorations have allowed contemporary audiences to appreciate the film's visual artistry and emotional depth, cementing its status as a classic of silent cinema.

What Audiences Thought

The Man of the Sea was a commercial success upon its release in 1920, particularly in regional French theaters where audiences connected with its authentic portrayal of rural life. The film ran for several weeks in major Parisian cinemas, an unusual achievement for a serious drama during a period when comedies typically dominated box offices. Audiences in Brittany were especially moved by the film's accurate representation of their culture, with many local newspapers reporting that viewers were brought to tears by the realistic depiction of fishing life. The film's emotional core, particularly the father-son relationship, resonated strongly with post-war audiences who were dealing with their own family disruptions and generational conflicts. International audiences also responded positively, with successful runs in Belgium, Switzerland, and even limited releases in the United States where it was marketed as an exotic glimpse into French provincial life.

You Might Also Like