The Unknown

Plot

Alonzo, a fugitive on the run from the law, hides his identity by working as 'The Armless Wonder' in a traveling circus, performing incredible feats like throwing knives with his feet while secretly concealing his fully functional arms. He falls deeply in love with Nanon, the beautiful daughter of the circus ringmaster, who suffers from an intense phobia of being touched by men's hands - making Alonzo's supposed armlessness strangely appealing to her. However, Nanon is also pursued by the circus strongman Malabar, creating a dangerous love triangle that drives Alonzo to increasingly desperate measures. When Alonzo learns that Nanon's phobia is beginning to fade and she might overcome her fear of hands, he contemplates a shocking and permanent solution to ensure she will only ever be with him. The film culminates in a tragic exploration of obsessive love, identity, and the extreme lengths one man will go to possess the woman he desires, ultimately revealing that Alonzo's deception and desperation will lead to his complete downfall.

Historical Background

The Unknown was released in 1927, a pivotal year in cinema history that marked the peak of the silent era just before the transition to sound. The late 1920s saw American cinema reaching new heights of artistic sophistication, with filmmakers pushing boundaries in terms of psychological complexity and thematic depth. This period also coincided with the growing popularity of Freudian psychology in America, with concepts of obsession, neurosis, and psychological trauma entering mainstream consciousness. The film's exploration of physical disability and psychological transformation reflected contemporary societal fascinations with medical science and the boundaries of human physical capability. Additionally, 1927 was the year that the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences was founded, though the first Academy Awards ceremony would not occur until 1929. The circus setting also resonated with audiences of the time, as traveling circuses remained popular entertainment across America, though they were beginning their slow decline as newer forms of entertainment emerged. The film's dark themes and psychological horror elements were part of a broader trend in late silent cinema toward more mature and disturbing subject matter, as filmmakers tested the limits of what could be shown to audiences.

Making Of

The making of 'The Unknown' was marked by extreme dedication from its star, Lon Chaney, who underwent tremendous physical discomfort for his role as Alonzo. Chaney would arrive at the studio hours before call time to have his arms bound in the specially designed harness, and he would remain bound throughout the entire shooting day, often for 10-12 hours at a time. The knife-throwing sequences required months of preparation, with Chaney practicing extensively to develop the foot dexterity needed to convincingly perform the stunts. Director Tod Browning, drawing from his own circus background, insisted on authenticity in every aspect of the production, hiring real circus performers as extras and using genuine circus equipment. The relationship between Chaney and Joan Crawford was particularly notable on set - Crawford, then a relatively unknown actress, was in awe of Chaney's dedication and method approach to acting, and she later credited him with teaching her the importance of physical expression in film performance. The film's dark themes and psychological intensity created a tense atmosphere on set, with many crew members finding the subject matter disturbing, particularly the scenes dealing with Alonzo's obsession and the implied self-mutilation.

Visual Style

The cinematography of 'The Unknown,' credited to Merritt B. Gerstad, employed innovative techniques to enhance the film's psychological tension and atmospheric mood. The visual style made extensive use of dramatic lighting and shadow play, creating a chiaroscuro effect that emphasized the duality of Alonzo's character - the public performer versus the private obsessive. The camera work featured unusual angles and compositions, particularly in the circus sequences, where low angles emphasized the physical prowess of the performers and high angles created a sense of vulnerability and psychological unease. The knife-throwing sequences utilized innovative camera techniques to create tension and danger, including slow-motion effects and carefully choreographed tracking shots that followed the knives' trajectory. The cinematography also made effective use of focus and depth of field to isolate characters psychologically, with Nanon often appearing in soft focus when viewed through Alonzo's obsessive gaze. The circus tent interiors were lit to create dramatic contrasts between light and shadow, enhancing the film's expressionistic qualities. The visual style drew influences from German Expressionist cinema while maintaining a distinctly American approach to psychological horror. The camera work during Alonzo's private moments of obsession employed tighter framing and more claustrophobic compositions, visually representing his psychological confinement.

Innovations

'The Unknown' showcased several technical innovations for its time, particularly in the areas of makeup effects, physical performance, and special effects photography. Lon Chaney's makeup and prosthetic work represented a significant advancement in cinematic transformation, with his double-thumbed hands and arm-concealing harness requiring innovative design and application techniques. The film's special effects, particularly in the knife-throwing sequences, employed clever camera tricks and editing techniques to create the illusion of danger and skill. The production utilized matte photography and in-camera effects to enhance the circus atmosphere and create visual metaphors for psychological states. The film's editing, particularly in the sequences showing Alonzo's growing obsession, used innovative cross-cutting techniques to build psychological tension and suggest the character's deteriorating mental state. The lighting design employed sophisticated techniques to create dramatic shadows and highlights that enhanced the film's expressionistic qualities. The production design for the circus sequences demonstrated remarkable attention to detail, with authentic circus equipment and props contributing to the film's realism. The film's success in conveying complex psychological themes without dialogue represented an achievement in visual storytelling technique. The physical coordination required for Chaney's performance, particularly the foot-based knife throwing, represented a significant technical challenge that was successfully overcome through extensive preparation and innovative filming techniques.

Music

As a silent film, 'The Unknown' was originally accompanied by live musical performance in theaters, with specific musical cues suggested in the film's cue sheets. The original score would have typically featured a mix of classical pieces and popular music of the era, carefully selected to match the film's emotional tone and dramatic moments. For the circus sequences, lively and exotic music would have been used to create the atmosphere of the big top, while more romantic themes would have accompanied the scenes between Alonzo and Nanon. The film's tense and psychologically intense moments would have been underscored with dramatic, dissonant music to enhance the feeling of unease and obsession. Modern restorations of the film have featured newly composed scores by various musicians, including organists and silent film accompanists who specialize in creating period-appropriate music. Some contemporary screenings have featured experimental scores that emphasize the film's psychological horror elements using modern musical techniques. The music for the knife-throwing sequences would have been particularly important in creating tension and excitement, typically using fast-paced, rhythmic patterns that matched the visual action. The absence of dialogue made the musical accompaniment crucial in conveying the film's emotional and psychological nuances, with the score serving as an essential element of the storytelling.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening knife-throwing sequence where Alonzo demonstrates his incredible skill using only his feet, throwing knives around a terrified assistant while the circus audience watches in amazement
• The intimate scene where Nanon confesses her fear of men's hands to Alonzo, not realizing he has arms, creating dramatic irony
• The climactic sequence where Alonzo, driven by obsession, contemplates permanent self-mutilation to remain with Nanon
• The final confrontation scene where Alonzo's true identity is revealed, leading to his tragic downfall

What Critics Said

Upon its release, 'The Unknown' received generally positive reviews from critics, who particularly praised Lon Chaney's extraordinary performance and the film's atmospheric tension. The New York Times noted Chaney's 'remarkable ability to convey emotion through physical expression alone,' while Variety called it 'a gripping tale of obsession that showcases Chaney at his most intense.' However, some contemporary critics found the film's themes disturbing and its psychological elements too intense for mainstream audiences. Over the decades, critical appreciation for the film has grown substantially, with modern film scholars recognizing it as a masterpiece of silent cinema and a key work in the horror genre. Critics now praise the film's sophisticated exploration of psychological themes, its innovative visual storytelling, and Chaney's transformative performance. The film is frequently cited in academic studies of horror cinema, silent film performance, and the actor-director collaboration. Many contemporary critics consider it one of the greatest horror films of the silent era, ranking it alongside other classics like 'Nosferatu' and 'The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari.' The film's reputation has been enhanced by its preservation and restoration, allowing modern audiences to appreciate its technical and artistic achievements.

What Audiences Thought

Initial audience reactions to 'The Unknown' were mixed but generally positive, with many theatergoers drawn by Lon Chaney's star power and the film's sensational premise. Contemporary audience members reported being both fascinated and disturbed by the film's dark themes and psychological intensity, with some finding the knife-throwing sequences particularly thrilling and others finding Alonzo's obsession unsettling. The film performed reasonably well at the box office, particularly in urban areas where Chaney had a strong following, though it didn't achieve the massive success of some of his other films like 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame.' Over time, as the film gained cult status among horror and silent film enthusiasts, audience appreciation has grown significantly. Modern audiences viewing the restored version often express admiration for Chaney's physical performance and the film's ability to create tension and psychological depth without dialogue. The film has become a favorite at silent film festivals and revival screenings, where audiences respond enthusiastically to its dramatic intensity and visual storytelling. Contemporary viewers often note how surprisingly modern the film's psychological themes feel, despite being nearly a century old. The film's reputation among horror fans has grown steadily, with many considering it an essential work in the genre's history.

You Might Also Like