Their Purple Moment

Plot

Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy plan a night of extravagant entertainment at a glamorous nightclub, believing they have plenty of money to spend. Unbeknownst to Stan, his suspicious wife has discovered his secret stash of 'mad money' and cleverly replaced it with worthless grocery coupons. The boys, accompanied by two young women they're trying to impress, order lavishly at the expensive establishment, running up an enormous bill through their increasingly extravagant choices. When the time comes to settle the account, they discover the devastating switch and must devise desperate schemes to escape without paying. The situation escalates into classic Laurel and Hardy chaos as they face the formidable nightclub manager and attempt various hilarious escape plans, ultimately leading to their usual comic downfall.

Historical Background

1928 represented the pinnacle of the silent film era and the cusp of the sound revolution. The Jazz Singer had been released in 1927, and Hollywood was in a state of technological upheaval as studios rushed to convert to sound production. Despite this chaos, Laurel and Hardy were at the height of their popularity as a comedy team, having perfected their screen personas through years of collaboration. The late 1920s economic boom meant audiences had disposable income for entertainment, and films depicting nightlife and extravagance resonated strongly with moviegoers. The Hal Roach Studios were known for producing technically superior comedy shorts, with elaborate sets and sophisticated cinematography that rivaled many feature films. This period also saw the maturation of film comedy as an art form, with complex narrative structures and refined visual gags replacing the simpler slapstick of earlier decades.

Making Of

The production of 'Their Purple Moment' took place during one of the most tumultuous periods in Hollywood history - the transition from silent to sound films. The Hal Roach Studios were at the forefront of comedy production, with some of the most sophisticated facilities and talent in the industry. The elaborate nightclub set represented a significant investment for a two-reel comedy, reflecting both the studio's success and their commitment to quality. Stan Laurel was intimately involved in the creative process, working closely with director James Parrott to perfect the timing and development of gags. The cast and crew were acutely aware that they were creating what might be among the last great silent comedies, adding both urgency and a sense of historical significance to the production. The filming followed the efficient Roach studio system, with careful planning and rehearsal to maximize the limited shooting time available for short subjects.

Visual Style

The cinematography by George Stevens (who would later become a renowned director) showcases the sophisticated visual techniques developed by the late silent era. The film employs advanced lighting methods, particularly in the nightclub scenes where elaborate illumination creates a glamorous atmosphere. The camera work follows the refined comedy shooting style perfected at the Roach studio, using wide shots to establish physical comedy and medium shots for character reactions. The photography demonstrates the visual sophistication achieved in comedy by this period, with careful composition and movement that enhances the humor without distracting from it. The film's visual style represents the peak of silent comedy cinematography, just before the technical challenges of sound would temporarily simplify film visuals.

Innovations

The film showcases several notable technical achievements for its era, particularly in set construction and lighting. The elaborate nightclub set represented one of the most sophisticated ever built for a comedy short at the Roach studio, featuring multiple levels, detailed decorations, and working elements. The lighting techniques used were advanced for 1928, creating depth and atmosphere that enhanced the comedy. The film demonstrates the refined editing capabilities developed for comedy timing by the late silent era, with precise cuts that maximize humorous effect. The production also utilized the improved film stocks available by 1928, allowing for better image quality in low-light conditions. These technical elements combined to create a short film with production values rivaling many contemporary features.

Music

As a silent film, 'Their Purple Moment' would have been accompanied by live musical accompaniment in theaters, typically compiled from standard photoplay music libraries. The musical score would have included specific cues for comic moments, dramatic tension, and romantic scenes. Larger theaters might have employed small orchestras, while smaller venues would have used piano accompaniment. The nightclub scenes would have featured more sophisticated, jazz-influenced music to match the setting. No specific composed score was created for the film itself, as was standard practice for short subjects of this era. Modern screenings often use compiled scores or original compositions created specifically for silent film presentations.

Memorable Scenes

• The discovery scene where Stan finds his money replaced by grocery coupons, the escalating dinner orders where the boys try to impress their dates with increasingly expensive items, the frantic attempts to escape the nightclub when they can't pay the bill, the confrontation with the formidable nightclub manager, and the classic Laurel and Hardy physical comedy throughout their escape attempts.

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised the film's production values and the team's comic timing, with Variety noting the increasingly sophisticated sets and lighting at the Roach studio. The film trade publications highlighted the elaborate nightclub setting as evidence of comedy shorts evolving beyond simple gag films. Modern film historians regard 'Their Purple Moment' as a prime example of late-silent era comedy craftsmanship, demonstrating the visual storytelling sophistication achieved by this period. Critics today appreciate how the film maintains its comedic effectiveness without dialogue, relying purely on visual humor and situation comedy. The film is often cited in comprehensive Laurel and Hardy filmographies as representative of their mature silent period work, showing the team at the height of their silent film powers.

What Audiences Thought

The film was enthusiastically received by 1928 audiences who were thoroughly familiar with Laurel and Hardy's established screen personas and comic relationship. Moviegoers of the era particularly enjoyed the glamorous nightclub setting and the relatable theme of trying to impress while avoiding financial responsibility. The film's release during the prosperous late 1920s meant its themes of extravagance and social aspiration resonated strongly with theater-goers. Modern audiences who discover the film through revival screenings or home video releases consistently praise it as a perfect example of silent comedy timing and visual storytelling. The film continues to entertain Laurel and Hardy fans and serves as an excellent introduction to their work for new viewers, demonstrating why the team remains beloved decades later.

You Might Also Like