A Florida Enchantment

Plot

Lillian Travers, a wealthy New York heiress, travels to Saint Augustine, Florida to surprise her fiancé Dr. Fred Cassadene, only to discover him in compromising situations with a flirtatious widow. Heartbroken and desperate, Lillian discovers an antique shop containing magical African seeds that can transform a person's gender when consumed. After taking one of the seeds, Lillian transforms into a man and adopts the name Lawrence, allowing her to observe Fred's true character while navigating the complications of her new identity. The situation becomes increasingly complex when Fred also takes a seed, transforming into a woman, leading to a series of comedic misunderstandings and gender-role reversals. Eventually, the effects wear off, and the characters return to their original forms, having learned valuable lessons about trust, identity, and relationships in this early exploration of gender fluidity.

Historical Background

1914 was a pivotal year in world history, marking the beginning of World War I in Europe, though America would not enter the war until 1917. In the film industry, this period represented the transition from short films to feature-length productions, with 'A Florida Enchantment' being relatively long at 50 minutes. The American film industry was centered in New York and New Jersey, with Hollywood just beginning to emerge as the dominant production center. Progressive Era reforms were transforming American society, with growing discussions about women's rights and social roles, making the film's gender-bending themes particularly timely. The film industry was also establishing its own censorship standards with the formation of the National Board of Review in 1909, though local censorship boards still held significant power. The popularity of Florida as a winter destination for wealthy Americans was at its peak, making the setting particularly relatable to contemporary audiences.

Making Of

The production of 'A Florida Enchantment' was a significant undertaking for Vitagraph in 1914. Sidney Drew, who was not only the star but also the studio's leading comedy director, insisted on location shooting in Florida to capture the authentic atmosphere of St. Augustine. This was unusual for the time, as most films were shot entirely on studio backlots. The cast and crew faced considerable challenges including Florida's humidity, which affected the film stock, and the primitive nature of film equipment that had to be transported to remote locations. Mrs. Sidney Drew (Lucile McVey) took an active role in adapting the source material, updating the 1891 story to suit contemporary audiences while maintaining its progressive themes. The gender transformation scenes required careful choreography and timing, as the actors had to convincingly portray both their original gender and their transformed state through mannerisms, voice (in intertitles), and movement. The film's success helped establish Vitagraph as a studio willing to tackle unconventional themes and invest in ambitious productions.

Visual Style

The cinematography by William R. 'Billy' Bitzer (though unconfirmed, as was common for the period) demonstrates the growing sophistication of visual storytelling in 1914. The Florida location scenes provided opportunities for outdoor photography that contrasted with the interior hotel scenes, creating visual variety. The camera work was relatively static, as was typical of the period, but showed careful composition and attention to detail in framing the transformation scenes. The use of medium shots and close-ups for emotional moments was becoming more common, and this film utilized these techniques effectively to convey the characters' reactions to their gender transformations. The lighting in the Florida scenes took advantage of natural sunlight, while interior scenes used the artificial lighting techniques being developed at Vitagraph Studios.

Innovations

While not technologically groundbreaking in terms of special effects, the film demonstrated sophisticated narrative techniques for its time. The gender transformations were achieved through clever editing, costume changes, and the actors' performances rather than optical effects. The film's five-reel length was ambitious for a comedy in 1914, allowing for more complex character development and plot progression than typical short comedies of the era. The location shooting in Florida represented a significant technical and logistical achievement, requiring the transport of heavy camera equipment and film stock to remote locations. The film also showed advanced understanding of continuity editing and narrative structure, helping establish conventions that would become standard in feature filmmaking.

Music

As a silent film, 'A Florida Enchantment' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during theatrical exhibitions. The typical score would have been compiled from classical pieces and popular songs of the era, with theater organists or small orchestras providing appropriate mood music for different scenes. No original composed score survives, and modern screenings typically feature newly composed scores or carefully selected period-appropriate music. The intertitles, which conveyed dialogue and narrative information, were likely written by Mrs. Sidney Drew, who co-wrote the screenplay adaptation.

Memorable Scenes

• The scene where Lillian first discovers the magical seeds in the curiosity shop, with close-ups on the mysterious package and her decision to take one
• The transformation sequence where Lillian becomes Lawrence, shown through costume changes and altered mannerisms
• The hotel lobby scenes where Lawrence observes Fred's behavior with the widow, using the new male perspective
• The comedic moment when Fred also transforms into a woman, creating dual gender confusion
• The final reversal scene where both characters return to their original forms and face the consequences of their actions

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception was generally positive, with trade publications like 'The Moving Picture World' praising the film's originality and the performances of the Drews. Critics noted the film's bold premise but appreciated how it was handled with taste and humor. The New York Dramatic Mirror called it 'a most unusual and entertaining photoplay' while Variety noted 'the clever handling of a difficult subject.' Modern critics and film historians have reassessed the film as remarkably ahead of its time, with scholars of early cinema frequently citing it as an example of the sophistication of silent-era narrative filmmaking. The film is now recognized as an important precursor to gender-bending comedies and is studied in film courses examining early representations of gender and sexuality in cinema.

What Audiences Thought

The film was commercially successful upon its release, attracting audiences curious about its unusual premise. Contemporary audience reactions were mixed in different regions, with more urban and progressive audiences embracing the film's themes while some conservative communities found it controversial. Despite occasional censorship in certain areas, the film's popularity helped establish Sidney Drew as a major comedy star of the era. Modern audiences who have discovered the film through screenings at silent film festivals and archives have generally responded with fascination at its progressive themes and sophisticated humor, often expressing surprise that such a film could have been produced in 1914.

You Might Also Like