Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde

Plot

Dr. Henry Jekyll, a respected London physician and philanthropist, becomes fascinated with the duality of human nature and develops a potion to separate his good and evil impulses. After consuming the formula, he transforms into the grotesque and depraved Edward Hyde, who terrorizes the city and commits heinous acts including the murder of a politician. As Jekyll struggles to control his transformations, Hyde emerges more frequently without the potion, leading to a violent confrontation where Jekyll kills himself to prevent Hyde from causing further harm. The film concludes with Jekyll's death and the revelation of his dark secret to his fiancée and her father.

Historical Background

The film emerged in the aftermath of World War I, during a period of significant social and cultural upheaval. The 1920s saw growing interest in psychology and the subconscious mind, influenced by the work of Sigmund Freud and Carl Jung. This fascination with the duality of human nature made Stevenson's story particularly resonant for contemporary audiences. The film also reflected post-war anxieties about the thin veneer of civilization and the potential for darkness within seemingly respectable individuals. Additionally, the rise of the scientific method and medical advances made the concept of a doctor experimenting with human nature both fascinating and terrifying to audiences. The film's production during the transition from Victorian to modern sensibilities allowed it to explore themes that would have been too controversial in earlier decades.

Making Of

The production faced several unique challenges, particularly in creating the transformation effects without modern special effects technology. Director John S. Robertson worked closely with cinematographer Roy Overbaugh to develop innovative lighting techniques that would enhance Barrymore's facial transformations. Barrymore prepared extensively for the dual role, studying the original Stevenson novella and reportedly observing patients at mental institutions to understand Hyde's depraved psychology. The decision to film in New York rather than Hollywood was partly due to Barrymore's successful stage career on Broadway and his reluctance to relocate to California. The production team utilized early makeup techniques by director and actor James Kirkwood, who created subtle prosthetics that complemented rather than dominated Barrymore's performance. The film's success surprised Paramount executives, who had been uncertain about investing in a horror production.

Visual Style

Roy Overbaugh's cinematography employed innovative techniques influenced by German Expressionism, using dramatic lighting and shadow play to enhance the film's psychological horror. The camera work utilized unusual angles and compositions to create a sense of unease, particularly during Hyde's scenes. The transformation sequences featured carefully choreographed camera movements and lighting changes to accentuate Barrymore's physical performance. The film made extensive use of low-key lighting and silhouette effects to create a Gothic atmosphere, particularly in the London street scenes. Overbaugh also employed soft focus techniques during Jekyll's scenes to create a sense of respectability, contrasted with sharp, harsh lighting for Hyde's appearances. The cinematography helped establish visual conventions for horror films that would influence the genre for decades.

Innovations

The film pioneered several technical innovations in special effects and makeup artistry. The transformation scenes utilized carefully timed lighting changes and camera techniques to enhance Barrymore's physical performance. The makeup department, led by James Kirkwood, developed subtle prosthetic techniques that could be applied and removed quickly during filming. The production employed early double exposure techniques for certain supernatural effects, though these were used sparingly. The film's lighting design represented some of the most sophisticated use of shadow and contrast in American cinema up to that point. The production also experimented with camera movement during transformation scenes, using dollies and cranes to create a sense of disorientation. These technical achievements helped establish new standards for horror film production and influenced subsequent special effects development.

Music

As a silent film, Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde was accompanied by live musical performances during its theatrical run. The original score was composed by William Axt and David Mendoza, who created a thematic score that contrasted gentle, romantic melodies for Jekyll's scenes with dissonant, dramatic music for Hyde's appearances. The score utilized leitmotifs for the main characters and employed techniques such as tremolo strings and brass clusters to create tension during transformation scenes. Modern restorations have featured newly composed scores by contemporary silent film composers, including the Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra and the Alloy Orchestra. These modern scores attempt to recreate the emotional impact of the original while utilizing contemporary orchestral techniques.

Memorable Scenes

• The first transformation sequence where Barrymore contorts his face and body without makeup to become Hyde, considered one of the most remarkable physical performances in silent cinema
• The scene where Hyde terrorizes a dance hall, displaying his violent and depraved nature
• The final confrontation between Jekyll and Hyde where Jekyll takes his own life to prevent further evil
• The laboratory scenes where Jekyll conducts his experiments, establishing the scientific hubris theme
• The romantic scenes between Jekyll and Millicent that establish the stakes of his transformation

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised Barrymore's performance as revolutionary, with many publications calling it the finest acting achievement of the silent era. The New York Times hailed Barrymore's transformation scenes as 'nothing short of miraculous,' while Variety noted that the film 'elevated horror to an art form.' Modern critics continue to acclaim the film, with many considering it Barrymore's finest screen performance. The film holds a 92% rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on critical reviews, with particular praise for Barrymore's physical performance and the film's atmospheric direction. Film historians often cite it as a crucial transitional work between Gothic horror traditions and modern psychological horror. The British Film Institute includes it in their list of essential horror films, and it's frequently studied in film courses for its innovative techniques and Barrymore's performance.

What Audiences Thought

The film was a tremendous box office success upon its release, becoming one of Paramount Pictures' highest-grossing films of 1920. Contemporary audiences were both terrified and fascinated by Barrymore's transformation scenes, with many reports of theater patrons screaming during Hyde's appearances. The film's success led to increased demand for horror productions and established Barrymore as a major box office draw. Despite some controversy over its violent content, the film played to packed houses across the United States and internationally. Modern audiences continue to appreciate the film through revivals at film festivals and classic cinema screenings, with many noting Barrymore's performance remains powerful even by contemporary standards. The film has developed a cult following among silent film enthusiasts and horror aficionados, who often cite it as superior to many later sound adaptations.

You Might Also Like