Holiday

Plot

Johnny Case, a self-made man with a modest background, returns from a vacation in Lake Placid engaged to Julia Seton, the daughter of an incredibly wealthy and tradition-bound financier. Upon meeting her family, Johnny discovers the stifling expectations of the upper class, finding a kindred spirit only in Julia's rebellious sister, Linda, and her disillusioned, alcoholic brother, Ned. While Julia and her father, Edward Seton, expect Johnny to settle into a lucrative banking career, Johnny reveals his plan to work only until he has enough money to take a 'holiday' and discover the meaning of life. As the conflict between Johnny's free-thinking ideals and the Setons' rigid materialism reaches a breaking point during a lavish New Year's Eve party, Linda realizes she is in love with Johnny and must decide whether to follow her heart or remain loyal to her sister. Ultimately, Johnny realizes Julia will never support his dreams, leading to a dramatic confrontation where he chooses his freedom, followed closely by Linda who finally breaks away from her gilded cage.

Historical Background

Released in 1930, 'Holiday' arrived just as the United States was descending into the Great Depression. The film's themes of rejecting mindless wealth and the pursuit of money for its own sake resonated deeply with an audience that was beginning to see the collapse of the financial systems of the 1920s. It reflects the 'Pre-Code' era of Hollywood, where films often explored more mature themes like alcoholism (through the character of Ned) and social rebellion with less censorship than would be seen after 1934.

Making Of

The production was a significant challenge due to the limitations of early sound recording. Microphones were often hidden in flower vases or behind furniture, which restricted the actors' movements. To combat the 'static' feel of many early talkies, director Edward H. Griffith and cinematographer Norbert Brodine experimented with moving camera shots and process photography for scenes set in moving cars. The casting of Ann Harding was a major coup for Pathé, as she was a celebrated stage actress whose 'theatrical' style was perfectly suited for the sophisticated dialogue of Philip Barry. However, the production had to be carefully managed to ensure the dialogue-heavy script didn't alienate audiences used to the visual action of silent films.

Visual Style

Norbert Brodine's cinematography is noted for its elegance and early experimentation. While many films of 1930 were visually stagnant, Brodine utilized subtle tracking shots and a modest crane shot to give the Seton mansion a sense of three-dimensional space. The lighting is high-key and glamorous, typical of the 'Pathé look' of the period, emphasizing the textures of the lavish costumes and sets.

Innovations

The film is notable for its early use of 'process cinematography' (rear projection) to simulate movement in car scenes, a technique that was still in its infancy. It also demonstrated a sophisticated approach to sound editing, allowing for overlapping dialogue and a more natural conversational flow than many of its contemporaries.

Music

The film features a minimal musical score by Josiah Zuro, as was common in early talkies where music was primarily used for opening and closing credits or justified by on-screen action (diegetic music). The 'soundscape' is dominated by the rhythmic, witty dialogue of Philip Barry, which was the film's primary selling point.

Memorable Scenes

• The New Year's Eve party in the 'playroom' where the outsiders (Johnny, Linda, and the Potters) retreat from the stifling formality of the main party.
• The confrontation between Johnny and Edward Seton where Johnny refuses the banking position, choosing his 'holiday' over a guaranteed fortune.
• The final scene where Linda realizes she is free to follow Johnny and races to catch the ship, leaving her father's house forever.
• Ned's poignant and dark monologue about the effects of drinking, which provides a somber contrast to the film's comedic elements.

What Critics Said

At the time of its release, 'Holiday' was a critical triumph. The New York Times praised it as a 'literate and amusing' adaptation that retained the brilliance of the play. Ann Harding's performance was singled out for its emotional depth and modern sensibility. Modern critics often compare it to the 1938 remake; while the remake is generally preferred for its star power and pacing, the 1930 version is frequently cited for its superior handling of the relationship between the two sisters and Mary Astor's standout performance.

What Audiences Thought

The film was a significant box office success, proving that audiences were hungry for 'intelligent' talkies. It appealed particularly to urban audiences who were familiar with the Broadway play, but its universal themes of family conflict and the desire for freedom helped it perform well across the country. It solidified Ann Harding as one of the top stars of the early sound era.

You Might Also Like