Hook, Line and Sinker

Plot

Two fast-talking insurance salesmen, Wilbur and Addington, encounter Mary Blake, a young woman fleeing from her wealthy mother's control. Mary reveals she owns a hotel but has never seen it, and the scheming salesmen agree to help her run it in exchange for a share of the profits. Upon arrival, they discover the hotel is a dilapidated, nearly abandoned establishment in desperate need of repair. Undeterred, they launch an elaborate phony public relations campaign, presenting the hotel as an exclusive resort favored by the wealthy elite. Their fraudulent advertising proves too successful, attracting actual rich guests who expect luxury accommodations, leading to increasingly frantic and comedic complications as the trio struggles to maintain their deception while dealing with suspicious guests, Mary's mother's investigators, and their own romantic entanglements.

Historical Background

Hook, Line and Sinker was released in 1930, during a pivotal year in American cinema and history. The film industry was still adapting to the revolutionary transition from silent to sound pictures that had begun just a few years earlier. This technological shift created enormous opportunities for comedy teams like Wheeler & Woolsey, whose vaudeville-honed dialogue skills were perfectly suited to the new medium. Meanwhile, the Great Depression was in its early stages, profoundly affecting American society and the film industry. Movies became an escape for struggling audiences, and comedies were particularly popular as they offered temporary relief from economic hardships. The film was also produced during the pre-Code era, before the strict enforcement of the Hays Code in 1934, allowing for more risqué humor and adult themes that would soon be censored. The early 1930s represented the peak of Wheeler & Woolsey's popularity, as they competed with other comedy teams like Laurel & Hardy and The Marx Brothers for audience attention.

Making Of

The production of 'Hook, Line and Sinker' took place during a fascinating transitional period in Hollywood history. As an early sound film, it was subject to the technical limitations of the era, including cumbersome microphone setups that restricted actor movement and camera positioning. Wheeler & Woolsey, who had honed their craft in vaudeville and on Broadway, adapted their fast-paced comedic style to the new medium, developing a rapid-fire delivery style that became their trademark. The film's director, Edward F. Cline, was a veteran comedy director who had worked with Buster Keaton and W.C. Fields, bringing considerable experience to the project. The chemistry between the three leads was genuine and well-established by this point in their collaboration, with Dorothy Lee having previously worked with the comedy team in their successful debut 'Rio Rita'. The production faced the economic pressures of the Great Depression, leading to efficient use of studio sets and resources, though this didn't prevent the filmmakers from creating elaborate sequences that showcased the team's comedic talents.

Visual Style

The cinematography of Hook, Line and Sinker reflects the technical limitations and aesthetic approaches of early sound films. Shot by Jack MacKenzie, the film employs relatively static camera positions compared to silent films, as the early sound recording equipment required microphones to be strategically placed and limited camera movement. The lighting follows the standard three-point lighting system common in studio productions of the era, providing clear visibility for the actors and their dialogue-driven performances. The hotel sequences make effective use of deep space composition to frame multiple characters and comic business simultaneously. The cinematography prioritizes clarity of performance over visual dynamism, which was typical of early sound comedies that focused on verbal humor rather than visual gags. The film's visual style is clean and straightforward, serving the comedy without drawing attention to itself, which was appropriate for a comedy team whose primary appeal was their rapid-fire dialogue and comic timing.

Innovations

Hook, Line and Sinker does not represent major technical innovations but rather exemplifies the standard technical practices of early sound film production. The film was made using the sound-on-disc technology that RKO was using during this period, before transitioning to sound-on-film. The recording techniques required actors to remain relatively close to hidden microphones, which influenced staging and performance styles. The film demonstrates the successful integration of musical numbers with dialogue scenes, a technical challenge for early sound films. The editing balances the need for clear audio with visual continuity, using techniques that would soon become standard in sound film editing. While not groundbreaking technically, the film represents the maturation of sound comedy techniques that had been experimental just a year or two earlier. The production team's ability to maintain comedic timing while working within sound recording constraints was itself an achievement, as early sound films often suffered from stiff performances due to technical limitations.

Music

The musical score for Hook, Line and Sinker was typical of early sound film productions, featuring a combination of original background music and several musical numbers. The film included songs performed by the cast, taking advantage of the new sound technology that allowed for musical sequences in films. Dorothy Lee, who had a singing background, likely performed in these musical segments. The score was composed by Max Steiner, who was one of RKO's prominent composers during this period and would later become famous for his groundbreaking work on King Kong (1933). The music served both as accompaniment to the action and as part of the entertainment value, as audiences of the era expected musical elements in their films. The sound recording quality reflects the technological limitations of 1930, with some background noise and limited dynamic range, but was considered adequate for its time. The musical numbers provided opportunities for the comedy team to showcase their versatility beyond their verbal humor.

Memorable Scenes

• The chaotic opening sequence where Wheeler and Woolsey attempt to sell insurance policies using increasingly absurd sales pitches
• The trio's first arrival at the dilapidated hotel and their shocked reactions to its condition
• The elaborate phony press conference where they present the hotel as a luxury resort
• The frantic sequence where they must simultaneously entertain wealthy guests while hiding the hotel's true condition
• The climactic chase scene involving suspicious guests, hotel inspectors, and Mary's mother's investigators

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception of Hook, Line and Sinker was generally positive, with reviewers praising the chemistry between Wheeler, Woolsey, and Dorothy Lee. The film's rapid-fire dialogue and comic situations were highlighted as strengths, though some critics noted that the plot followed familiar comedy conventions. The trade publication Variety gave the film a favorable review, noting that 'Wheeler and Woolsey are in their usual fine form' and that 'the picture moves along at a good pace.' The Film Daily also praised the comedy team's performance, calling it 'ample entertainment for those who enjoy this type of comedy.' Modern critical assessment of the film is limited due to its relative obscurity compared to other comedies of the era, but film historians who have examined Wheeler & Woolsey's work recognize Hook, Line and Sinker as a solid example of their early sound style. The film is generally regarded as a competent, entertaining comedy that successfully showcases the team's talents, though not considered their absolute best work.

What Audiences Thought

Audience reception to Hook, Line and Sinker in 1930 was generally positive, as Wheeler & Woolsey were at the height of their popularity during this period. The comedy team had built a substantial following following their successful debut in Rio Rita, and audiences appreciated their fast-paced humor and the romantic elements provided by Dorothy Lee. The film's theme of ordinary people outsmarting the wealthy resonated with Depression-era audiences who were struggling economically. Box office performance was solid, though exact figures are not available, and the film helped reinforce Wheeler & Woolsey's status as bankable stars for RKO Pictures. Audience feedback of the era, as reported in trade publications, indicated that viewers particularly enjoyed the verbal sparring between the two comedians and the film's various comic set pieces. The film's success with audiences helped ensure that RKO would continue producing Wheeler & Woolsey vehicles throughout the early 1930s.

You Might Also Like