Lady Windermere's Fan

Plot

In Victorian London, young Lady Windermere discovers her husband Lord Windermere has been secretly giving money to the mysterious Mrs. Erlynne, leading her to believe he's having an affair. When Mrs. Erlynne appears at Lady Windermere's birthday ball, the young woman is horrified and contemplates leaving her husband for the persistent Lord Darlington. In a dramatic turn of events, Mrs. Erlynne reveals she is actually Lady Windermere's long-lost mother, who was disgraced years ago and has now returned to protect her daughter's reputation. After Lady Windermere nearly compromises herself by leaving with Darlington, Mrs. Erlynne sacrifices her own social standing by retrieving her daughter's fan from Darlington's rooms, allowing Lady Windermere to return to her husband unaware of her near-disgrace. The film concludes with Mrs. Erlynne accepting a marriage proposal from Lord Augustus, finding redemption while preserving her daughter's happiness.

Historical Background

The mid-1920s was a period of transition in Hollywood, as studios moved toward bigger budget prestige productions to compete with radio's growing popularity. Warner Bros., in particular, was trying to establish itself as a major studio capable of producing sophisticated literary adaptations. The film emerged during the Jazz Age, when Victorian morality was being questioned and reexamined, making Wilde's critique of hypocrisy particularly relevant. This was also the peak of the silent era, just before the transition to sound would revolutionize filmmaking. The Roaring Twenties' fascination with the past and European sophistication created an appetite for films like this that offered escapist glamour while still commenting on contemporary moral questions.

Making Of

Ernst Lubitsch, already renowned in Europe for his sophisticated comedies, was brought to America by Warner Bros. specifically to elevate their productions with his distinctive directorial style. The adaptation process was particularly challenging as Wilde's play was famous for its brilliant dialogue, which couldn't be fully utilized in a silent film. Lubitsch and his screenwriters solved this by emphasizing visual gags, meaningful glances, and clever intertitles that captured the spirit of Wilde's wit. The casting was crucial - Ronald Colman, though not yet the major star he would become, brought the perfect blend of aristocratic charm and moral ambiguity to Lord Windermere. May McAvoy underwent extensive preparation to portray the innocent but strong-willed Lady Windermere. The production design was meticulous, with art directors creating authentic Victorian London sets that would impress contemporary audiences. Lubitsch was known for his attention to detail, often shooting dozens of takes to get the perfect subtle reaction or gesture that would convey meaning without words.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Charles Van Enger employed sophisticated lighting techniques that created the elegant atmosphere of Victorian London. Van Enger used soft focus and backlighting to create a dreamlike quality in the ballroom scenes, while using more dramatic lighting for the confrontational moments. The camera movement was relatively static, as was typical of the era, but the composition was carefully planned to convey social relationships and power dynamics. The film made effective use of close-ups to capture the subtle emotions that would normally be conveyed through dialogue. The black and white photography was particularly effective in creating the contrast between the respectable surface of society and the darker undercurrents beneath.

Innovations

The film was notable for its innovative use of intertitles that didn't merely convey dialogue but added to the comedy with their own wit. The production design featured some of the most elaborate recreations of Victorian London seen in American cinema up to that point. The film also employed early examples of what would become continuity editing techniques, particularly in the tense scenes involving the fan. The makeup and costume departments created authentic period looks that influenced subsequent historical films. The film's success helped establish technical standards for literary adaptations in the silent era.

Music

As a silent film, Lady Windermere's Fan was accompanied by live musical scores in theaters. For its premiere at the Criterion Theatre in New York, Warner Bros. commissioned a special orchestral score that incorporated popular songs of the Victorian era. In theaters equipped with the Vitaphone system, the film was accompanied by recorded music and sound effects. The score emphasized the comedic moments with light, playful motifs while using more dramatic music for the emotional scenes. Some theaters used classical pieces, particularly works by composers like Johann Strauss II, to enhance the Victorian atmosphere.

Memorable Scenes

• The birthday ball scene where Mrs. Erlynne makes her dramatic entrance, causing a stir among the society guests and leading to Lady Windermere's confrontation with her husband
• The tense moment when Mrs. Erlynne discovers her daughter's fan in Lord Darlington's rooms and must decide whether to sacrifice herself to save Lady Windermere's reputation
• The opening sequence showing the elaborate fan that gives the film its title, establishing the visual motif that recurs throughout the story

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised the film for its sophisticated direction and excellent performances. The New York Times called it 'a triumph of cinematic art' and particularly lauded Lubitsch's ability to translate Wilde's wit to the silent medium. Variety noted that 'the picture proves that good dialogue is not essential when you have good direction.' Modern critics have reevaluated the film as a masterpiece of silent comedy, with the British Film Institute describing it as 'one of the most sophisticated American films of the 1920s.' The film is frequently cited in film studies courses as an example of how visual storytelling can replace dialogue effectively.

What Audiences Thought

The film was a commercial success upon release, particularly with urban audiences who appreciated its sophisticated humor and elegant production values. It played well in major cities like New York and Chicago where audiences were familiar with Wilde's work. The film's themes of marital fidelity and social hypocrisy resonated with 1920s audiences who were questioning traditional values. Word-of-mouth was strong, and the film's run was extended in many theaters. However, in smaller towns and rural areas, it was less successful as the sophisticated humor and themes didn't connect as strongly with those audiences.

You Might Also Like