Lights of Old Broadway

Plot

In 1920s New York City, twin sisters Anne and Lizzie are separated at birth when their Irish immigrant parents die. Anne is adopted by a wealthy family and grows up as a sophisticated society girl, while Lizzie remains in the impoverished Irish slums, working as a shop girl. Years later, both women fall in love with the same man, Roger Towne, a wealthy architect who becomes engaged to Anne while developing feelings for Lizzie, unaware they are twins. When a fire breaks out at a charity event, Lizzie saves Anne's life, leading to the discovery of their true relationship and a heartwarming resolution that bridges the gap between their vastly different worlds.

Historical Background

The film was produced during the height of the Roaring Twenties, a period of dramatic social change and increasing urbanization in America. The 1920s saw massive immigration, particularly from Ireland, leading to the ethnic neighborhoods depicted in the film. This was also the era of Prohibition, which created underground economies in urban slums. The film's release coincided with the growing influence of Hollywood as America's cultural capital and the establishment of the studio system. Additionally, 1925 was a year of significant technological advancement in cinema, with sound technology being developed and color processes becoming more viable, though still expensive and experimental.

Making Of

The production of 'Lights of Old Broadway' was a major undertaking for Cosmopolitan Productions, with William Randolph Hearst investing heavily to showcase Marion Davies' dramatic range. The dual role required Davies to work with pioneering double-exposure techniques, often requiring her to perform scenes twice with different costumes and mannerisms. The set design was particularly ambitious, with MGM's art department creating detailed reproductions of both Fifth Avenue mansions and Lower East Side tenements. Director Monta Bell, known for his meticulous attention to detail, spent weeks researching New York's social divisions to ensure authenticity. The film's Technicolor sequences, though brief, represented a significant technical achievement and additional expense. Hearst personally supervised many aspects of production and even suggested script changes to better highlight Davies' talents.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Ira H. Morgan was pioneering for its time, particularly in the execution of Marion Davies' dual role. Morgan employed sophisticated double-exposure techniques and careful matte work to create convincing scenes featuring both characters simultaneously. The film's visual style contrasted the warm, soft lighting of the society scenes with the harsh, high-contrast lighting of the slum sequences. The Technicolor segments, though brief, showcased early color photography with careful attention to costume and set design. The fire sequence utilized innovative camera angles and editing techniques to create suspense and danger. Morgan's work on this film was considered among the most technically accomplished of 1925.

Innovations

The film's most significant technical achievement was the execution of Marion Davies' dual role, requiring innovative use of double exposure and split-screen photography that was advanced for 1925. The production also pioneered the integration of Technicolor sequences within a predominantly black-and-white film. The fire effects and miniature work used in the climactic sequence were considered state-of-the-art for the time. The film's sound design, while not recorded, included detailed musical cue sheets that synchronized with the action in ways that foreshadowed later sound synchronization techniques. The set design incorporated moving elements and forced perspective to create the illusion of expansive New York locations on studio backlots.

Music

As a silent film, 'Lights of Old Broadway' would have been accompanied by live musical performance in theaters. The original score was composed by William Axt, one of MGM's staff composers, with arrangements that reflected the film's dual settings - sophisticated classical pieces for the society scenes and traditional Irish melodies for the slum sequences. The score included adaptations of popular songs of the era as well as original compositions. In larger theaters, the accompaniment might have included a full orchestra, while smaller venues used piano or organ. The musical direction emphasized the emotional contrasts between the two worlds depicted in the film, using leitmotifs for the twin characters.

Memorable Scenes

• The dramatic fire sequence at the charity ball where Lizzie saves Anne's life, featuring elaborate special effects and stunt work that was groundbreaking for 1925
• The first scene showing both twins simultaneously, using innovative double-exposure photography that amazed contemporary audiences
• The emotional revelation scene where the sisters discover their true relationship, featuring Marion Davies' powerful dual performance

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised 'Lights of Old Broadway' for its technical achievements and Marion Davies' dual performance. The New York Times called it 'a triumph of cinematic artistry' and particularly noted Davies' ability to distinguish between the two characters. Variety magazine praised the film's 'authentic atmosphere' and 'compelling narrative.' Modern critics have re-evaluated the film as an important example of 1920s social drama, with particular appreciation for its technical innovation and Davies' performance. Film historians often cite it as one of Davies' finest dramatic roles and a significant achievement of the Cosmopolitan-MGM partnership.

What Audiences Thought

The film was a commercial success upon its release, particularly popular in urban areas where audiences could relate to its depiction of city life. Marion Davies' dual role was a major draw, with theaters advertising the technical marvel of seeing her play both parts. The film's themes of social mobility and romance resonated strongly with 1920s audiences, many of whom were first or second-generation immigrants themselves. Audience reaction cards from the period show overwhelming positive response, with particular praise for the emotional climax and the fire sequence. The film's success helped cement Davies' popularity and proved that audiences would accept her in serious dramatic roles.

You Might Also Like