Pot o' Gold

Plot

Jimmy Haskell, the owner of a failed music shop, travels to New York to work with his uncle C.J. Haskell, who owns a health food company. Along the way, he meets Molly McCorkle and her large Irish-American family, who live in the same building as his uncle's business and are constantly making music with their in-house band led by Horace Heidt. Jimmy finds himself caught between his uncle's hatred of the constant noise and his growing affection for Molly and her family's musical passion. As he falls for Molly, Jimmy secretly helps the band get a radio audition while attempting to reconcile the feuding families, ultimately discovering that music and love can bridge even the deepest divides.

Historical Background

'Pot o' Gold' was released in April 1941, during a pivotal moment in American history. The film emerged during the height of Hollywood's golden age, just eight months before the attack on Pearl Harbor would thrust the United States into World War II. This period saw Hollywood producing escapist entertainment to help audiences cope with growing international tensions. Musical comedies were particularly popular as they offered temporary relief from the looming war in Europe. The film also reflects the American fascination with Irish culture and music, a recurring theme in Hollywood films of the 1930s and early 1940s that resonated with the large Irish-American population. The movie's setting of a health food business versus a musical family touches on the emerging health consciousness movement in American society. The film's release came at the peak of James Stewart's popularity, just two years after his Oscar-winning performance and one year before he would enlist in the Army Air Corps following America's entry into the war.

Making Of

The production of 'Pot o' Gold' faced challenges primarily due to James Stewart's discomfort with the musical genre. He had to be convinced by Universal executives to take the role, as they wanted to capitalize on his immense popularity following his Oscar win for 'Mr. Smith Goes to Washington.' Stewart reportedly felt awkward during the dance sequences and struggled with the musical timing. Paulette Goddard, who had extensive musical experience, often helped Stewart through the more difficult numbers. Director George Marshall had to carefully balance the film's musical elements with its comedy and romance to satisfy both the studio and the stars. The relationship between Stewart and Goddard off-screen was strictly professional, which some critics believe affected their on-screen chemistry. Horace Heidt and His Orchestra were given prominent billing and significant screen time, as the film was partially intended to promote their radio show and records. The musical numbers were pre-recorded, a standard practice of the era, with the actors lip-syncing during filming.

Visual Style

The cinematography for 'Pot o' Gold' was handled by Milton R. Krasner, who brought a straightforward but polished visual style to the production. The film was shot in black and white, using standard studio lighting techniques of the era with soft focus on the romantic leads and more dramatic lighting for the musical numbers. Krasner employs more dynamic camera work during the musical sequences, with movement that follows the choreography and highlights the orchestra performances. The film's visual style is representative of Universal's approach to musical comedies in the early 1940s – competent but not innovative, with a focus on clarity and star appeal over artistic experimentation. The set design for the McCorkle family apartment and the Haskell factory creates a visual contrast between the warm, lived-in space of the musicians and the sterile, business-like environment of the health food company.

Innovations

'Pot o' Gold' does not feature any particularly notable technical achievements or innovations. The film was produced using standard techniques and technologies of the early 1940s Hollywood studio system. The sound recording was typical of the era, with microphones hidden throughout the sets to capture dialogue and musical performances. The musical sequences were recorded using the pre-recording method common at the time, where the songs were recorded first and the actors lip-synced during filming. Some scenes use early forms of process photography for background effects, but nothing groundbreaking for the period. The film does make effective use of Universal's sound stages and backlot, creating convincing interior and exterior settings within the constraints of studio production. While not technically innovative, the film demonstrates the high level of craftsmanship that Hollywood studios had achieved by the early 1940s in producing efficient and entertaining musical comedies.

Music

The soundtrack for 'Pot o' Gold' features music by various composers, with songs performed by Horace Heidt and His Orchestra as well as the film's stars. Notable songs include 'When You Wore a Tulip,' 'A Good Man is Hard to Find,' 'Pennies from Heaven,' and 'It's a Lovely Day Tomorrow.' The musical numbers range from traditional Irish tunes to contemporary pop songs of the era. James Stewart performs several songs, though his singing voice was reportedly not considered his strong suit. The soundtrack also includes incidental music composed by Frank Skinner, who was Universal's house composer at the time. The musical arrangements were tailored to showcase Horace Heidt's orchestra, which was known for its big band sound and popular radio presence. The soundtrack was released on records by Decca Records, capitalizing on the film's promotion of the orchestra.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening scene where Jimmy's music shop fails, establishing his character's financial struggles and love for music
• Jimmy's first encounter with the McCorkle family, where he hears their band practicing for the first time
• The musical number 'When You Wore a Tulip' performed by James Stewart and Paulette Goddard, showcasing their chemistry
• The scene where Jimmy tries to secretly record the McCorkle band for his uncle's radio program
• The final musical performance where both families come together, resolving their conflict through music

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews for 'Pot o' Gold' were mixed to moderate. The New York Times praised the chemistry between Stewart and Goddard but noted that Stewart seemed uncomfortable in the musical numbers. Variety called it 'a pleasant but unremarkable musical comedy' that would satisfy fans of the stars but wouldn't break any new ground. Modern critics generally view the film as a minor entry in Stewart's career, with most agreeing that it's watchable but not essential viewing. The musical numbers featuring Horace Heidt and His Orchestra are often cited as the film's strongest elements, while the romantic storyline is considered formulaic even for its time. Some modern critics have noted the film's historical value as a document of pre-war American entertainment and as Stewart's only musical outing, though few consider it among the better musicals of its era.

What Audiences Thought

Audiences in 1941 responded moderately well to 'Pot o' Gold,' with the film performing respectably at the box office but not achieving blockbuster status. Fans of James Stewart and Paulette Goddard were drawn to the film primarily for the star power, while followers of Horace Heidt's radio show came for the musical elements. The film's light-hearted tone and escapist entertainment value were appreciated by audiences looking for relief from the growing international tensions. Modern audiences who discover the film are typically Stewart completists or classic film enthusiasts, with reactions generally divided between those who enjoy its nostalgic charm and those who find it dated compared to the more sophisticated musicals of the era. The film has developed a small cult following among classic movie fans who appreciate its historical significance as Stewart's only musical and its representation of 1940s popular culture.

You Might Also Like