St. Louis Blues

Plot

In this groundbreaking two-reel musical short, legendary blues singer Bessie Smith plays a woman devastated by her gambler lover Jimmy's infidelity. When Jimmy (Alec Lovejoy) abandons her for a younger, prettier woman, Bessie is left heartbroken in their modest apartment. As she grapples with the pain of betrayal, she transforms her sorrow into music, delivering a powerful rendition of W.C. Handy's 'St. Louis Blues' while surrounded by a chorus of dancers and musicians. The film culminates in an emotional performance where Bessie's raw vocal talent captures the essence of blues music as an expression of suffering and resilience. Through her singing, she finds catharsis and strength, embodying the transformative power of the blues tradition.

Historical Background

The film was produced in 1929, a pivotal year in American history and cinema. This was the year of the stock market crash that began the Great Depression, and also the year when sound films completely replaced silent films in Hollywood. The Harlem Renaissance was in full swing, and African American culture was gaining unprecedented attention and respect in mainstream American society. Jazz and blues music were moving from underground clubs to mainstream popularity, and film studios were eager to capitalize on this trend. The film emerged during a brief window when studios were experimenting with all-Black cast films before the Hays Code would severely restrict such productions in the 1930s. The transition to sound technology created new opportunities for musical performers like Bessie Smith to reach broader audiences through cinema.

Making Of

The making of 'St. Louis Blues' represented a significant moment in early cinema history, as it was one of the first films to authentically capture African American musical performance on screen. Director Dudley Murphy, who had previously worked with avant-garde artists, approached the project with artistic ambition rather than mere exploitation. The film was shot in New York rather than Hollywood, partly to access the authentic jazz talent available there. Bessie Smith, despite her enormous success as a recording artist, was initially hesitant about appearing in film, as many Black performers were wary of how they would be portrayed. The production team worked to create an environment that respected her artistry and allowed her to perform naturally. The choreography and musical arrangements were kept relatively simple to showcase Smith's powerful voice and emotional delivery. The film's crew included several Black technicians and musicians, which was unusual for the time and contributed to its authentic feel.

Visual Style

The cinematography of 'St. Louis Blues' was handled by cinematographer Joseph Walker, who would later become famous for his work on Frank Capra films. The film uses relatively static camera positions typical of early sound productions, when cameras were often confined to soundproof booths. However, Walker manages to create visual interest through careful composition and lighting that highlights the emotional content of Smith's performance. The film employs dramatic lighting to emphasize the mood of each scene, with darker, more shadowed lighting during the moments of heartbreak and brighter lighting during the musical performance. The camera work during the musical numbers shows some experimentation, with occasional close-ups of Smith's face to capture the emotional intensity of her singing.

Innovations

As an early sound film, 'St. Louis Blues' represents the technical challenges and innovations of the transition from silent to sound cinema. The film was recorded using the sound-on-disc system rather than sound-on-film, which was common in early Columbia productions. The recording engineers had to carefully balance Smith's powerful voice with the accompanying music without the benefit of modern mixing technology. The film demonstrates early attempts at synchronizing musical performance with visual storytelling, a challenge that would define the musical genre for decades to come. The production team had to work around the limitations of early sound recording equipment, including the need for performers to stay relatively close to microphones hidden on set. Despite these technical constraints, the film succeeds in capturing a natural and authentic musical performance.

Music

The soundtrack centers around Bessie Smith's powerful rendition of W.C. Handy's 'St. Louis Blues,' which she had first recorded in 1925. The film's arrangement stays true to the blues tradition while adapting it for the film medium. James P. Johnson provides piano accompaniment, showcasing his innovative stride piano style. The film also features a chorus of background singers and dancers who contribute to the musical texture. The sound quality, while primitive by modern standards, captures the raw power and emotional depth of Smith's voice in a way that her studio recordings sometimes filtered out. The music serves not just as entertainment but as narrative device, conveying the story's emotional arc through the blues tradition of transforming suffering into art.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening scene where Bessie Smith discovers her lover's betrayal, conveying heartbreak through subtle facial expressions and body language
• The powerful musical performance where Smith transforms her pain into art, singing 'St. Louis Blues' with raw emotional intensity
• The final scene where the chorus of dancers and musicians join Smith, creating a communal celebration of blues music as healing and resistance

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews praised the film for its authentic representation of Black music and culture. Variety noted that 'Bessie Smith's rendition of the title song is powerful enough to stand on its own merits,' while The New York Times commented on the film's 'unusual dignity and artistic merit.' Modern critics have hailed the film as a priceless historical document. Film historian Donald Bogle described it as 'a rare glimpse of a blues legend in her prime,' while The Criterion Collection called it 'an essential piece of both American musical and African American cinema history.' The film is now recognized as a landmark in the representation of Black culture in American cinema and is frequently cited in academic studies of early sound film and African American performance.

What Audiences Thought

The film was well-received by both Black and white audiences upon its release, though it was primarily shown in urban theaters with significant Black populations. Many African American viewers appreciated seeing authentic representation of their culture on screen, while white audiences were exposed to genuine blues performance for the first time. The film was particularly popular in Harlem and other urban centers with active jazz scenes. Over time, as Bessie Smith's legend grew, the film became increasingly sought after by music and film enthusiasts. Today, it is considered a must-see for anyone interested in the history of blues music or early American cinema, and screenings at film festivals and museums consistently draw enthusiastic crowds.

You Might Also Like