The Big Trail

Plot

Breck Coleman, a young and determined trail scout, is tasked with guiding a massive wagon train of settlers from the banks of the Mississippi River across 2,500 miles of treacherous wilderness to the Oregon Territory. Along the arduous journey, the pioneers must survive brutal river crossings, mountain blizzards, and hostile Native American attacks while internal tensions threaten to tear the group apart. Amidst the struggle for survival, Breck pursues a tentative romance with the beautiful pioneer Ruth Cameron, though he remains focused on his secret mission: identifying and seeking vengeance against the ruthless scoundrels who murdered his mentor. As the caravan reaches its final destination, Breck must confront the killers in a snowy showdown to achieve justice and secure a future for the settlers in the new land.

Historical Background

Released just one year after the Wall Street Crash of 1929, 'The Big Trail' arrived at the worst possible moment for a high-budget technical experiment. The film industry was already struggling with the massive capital investment required to convert theaters to sound. When Fox introduced the 70mm Grandeur format, theater owners—already reeling from the Depression—refused to buy yet another set of expensive projection equipment. Consequently, the widescreen version played in only two theaters (the Roxy in NYC and Grauman's Chinese in LA), while the rest of the world saw a vastly inferior 35mm version that lacked the film's intended visual sweep.

Making Of

The making of 'The Big Trail' was an epic in itself, characterized by Raoul Walsh's 'cowboy' style of directing. The crew lived in tents and cooked over open fires, mirroring the lives of the pioneers they were portraying. Technical challenges were immense; the 70mm Grandeur cameras were massive, weighing hundreds of pounds and requiring specialized soundproof 'blimps' to dampen the motor noise for the new sound-on-film technology. Because the 70mm lenses could not focus well on close-ups, Walsh and cinematographer Arthur Edeson pioneered a 'deep focus' style that utilized the vast landscape to tell the story through composition rather than editing. The production was also plagued by harsh weather, including real snowstorms and mud, which Walsh incorporated into the film to enhance the realism.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Arthur Edeson (70mm) and Lucien Andriot (35mm) is revolutionary. Edeson utilized the 2.10:1 aspect ratio to create 'tableaux' compositions, where multiple actions happen simultaneously in the foreground, middle ground, and background. This reduced the need for close-ups and cutting, creating a sense of scale and continuity that wouldn't be seen again until the advent of CinemaScope. The use of natural light and real locations gives the film a raw, authentic texture that stands in stark contrast to the studio-bound films of the era.

Innovations

First major feature film shot in 70mm widescreen (Fox Grandeur).,Pioneered the use of deep-focus cinematography in a widescreen format.,One of the first films to successfully record complex, multi-layered sound on location.,Innovated the 'simultaneous multi-language' production method for international distribution.,Utilized massive logistical coordination for thousands of animals and extras in remote wilderness locations.

Music

The film features an uncredited score by several composers including R.H. Bassett and Peter Brunelli. As an early 'talkie,' the sound design is notable for its use of ambient outdoor noise—the creaking of wagons, the lowing of cattle, and the rushing of rivers—which was extremely difficult to capture with the primitive microphones of 1930. The dialogue is often delivered in a 'stagey' manner typical of early sound films, but the environmental soundscape is remarkably modern.

Memorable Scenes

• The Descent: A breathtaking sequence where the pioneers use ropes and pulleys to lower entire wagons and livestock down a sheer 300-foot cliff.
• The River Crossing: A chaotic and dangerous scene where the wagon train fords a swollen, muddy river during a storm, filmed with terrifying realism.
• The Buffalo Stampede: A massive, wide-angle shot of hundreds of buffalo charging across the plains, captured in the full majesty of 70mm Grandeur.
• The Final Showdown: Breck Coleman tracks the villains through a heavy snowstorm in a pine forest, culminating in a tense, silent confrontation.

What Critics Said

At the time of release, critics were divided; many praised the spectacular visuals and the scale of the production but found the plot repetitive and John Wayne's acting 'green.' Modern critics, however, view it as a masterpiece of early cinema. Contemporary scholars highlight Raoul Walsh's sophisticated use of the widescreen frame and the film's gritty, unromanticized depiction of pioneer life, which was decades ahead of its time compared to the more 'staged' Westerns of the 1930s.

What Audiences Thought

Initial audiences were largely indifferent, as the vast majority saw the 35mm version which lacked the immersive power of the 70mm Grandeur experience. The film failed to recoup its massive budget, leading to the bankruptcy of William Fox's empire. Today, it has a cult following among cinephiles and Western enthusiasts who appreciate its documentary-like realism and the rare chance to see a young John Wayne before he became a screen icon.

You Might Also Like