Tol'able David

Plot

Young David Kinemon is a gentle, good-natured boy living in a rural mountain community who is considered too young and weak for serious responsibilities. When his older brother, the town's mail carrier, is injured in a fight with the vicious Hatburn brothers, David must step up to take his place despite his youth. As David begins his mail route through the dangerous mountain terrain, he encounters the Hatburn brothers who have terrorized the community, leading to a series of violent confrontations that force David to transform from a timid boy into a courageous man. The film follows David's journey of self-discovery as he faces deadly challenges, protects his family's honor, and ultimately proves his worth to the community that once doubted him.

Historical Background

Released in December 1921, 'Tol'able David' emerged during the silent film era's artistic golden age and a period of significant social change in America. The film came just three years after World War I ended, when the nation was grappling with modernization, urbanization, and a nostalgic yearning for traditional American values. The early 1920s saw Hollywood transitioning from short films to feature-length productions, with studios investing more heavily in ambitious projects. This film reflected the post-war fascination with rural authenticity and the American character, tapping into audiences' desire for stories that celebrated traditional values and individual courage. The film's release coincided with the rise of the 'star system' in Hollywood, and it played a crucial role in establishing Richard Barthelmess as one of the era's leading actors.

Making Of

Director Henry King and star Richard Barthelmess had previously worked together on 'Tol'able David' and developed a collaborative relationship that would span multiple films. The production faced significant challenges filming in the remote Blue Ridge Mountains, with the crew having to transport heavy equipment up steep trails and sometimes camp overnight in primitive conditions. Barthelmess prepared extensively for his role by spending weeks in mountain communities, studying the local dialect, mannerisms, and way of life. The film's realistic approach to rural storytelling was revolutionary for its time, with King insisting on natural performances from his actors and avoiding the theatrical acting style common in silent films. The famous scene where David delivers mail while being pursued was filmed in a single take with multiple cameras, a technical innovation that added to the sequence's tension and authenticity.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Henry Cronjager was revolutionary for its time, featuring extensive use of natural landscapes and authentic outdoor locations rather than studio sets. Cronjager employed innovative camera techniques to capture the majesty and danger of the Blue Ridge Mountains, including dramatic tracking shots following David's journey through rugged terrain. The film's visual style emphasized natural lighting, particularly in outdoor scenes where the changing mountain light was used to enhance emotional moments. Cronjager's work demonstrated remarkable technical skill in capturing both sweeping landscape vistas and intimate character moments, often in the same sequence. The cinematography played a crucial role in establishing the film's authentic atmosphere and remains one of its most praised artistic achievements.

Innovations

The film pioneered several technical innovations that would influence cinema for decades. Its extensive use of location shooting in remote mountain areas was groundbreaking, demonstrating that dramatic films could be successfully produced outside studio environments. The production employed innovative camera mounting techniques to capture movement along mountain trails, including early uses of what would become tracking shots. The film's action sequences, particularly the climactic confrontation scenes, featured advanced editing techniques that created suspense and momentum. The production also developed new methods for recording synchronized sound effects on location, even though the film itself was silent, to help actors time their performances more realistically. These technical achievements helped establish new standards for location filming and action cinematography in American cinema.

Music

As a silent film, 'Tol'able David' was accompanied by live musical performance during its original theatrical run. The original score was composed by William Frederick Peters and was designed to enhance the film's emotional arc and dramatic moments. The music incorporated American folk themes and pastoral melodies to complement the rural setting, with more dramatic orchestration for the action sequences. Different theaters would have adapted the score based on their available musicians, ranging from simple piano accompaniment in smaller venues to full orchestral arrangements in premier theaters. Modern restorations of the film have featured new scores by contemporary composers who have created music that respects the film's original aesthetic while utilizing modern orchestral capabilities.

Memorable Scenes

• David's first journey as mail carrier, showing his determination despite fear and physical hardship as he navigates dangerous mountain paths
• The climactic confrontation between David and the Hatburn brothers, filmed on a mountainside with dramatic natural lighting
• The scene where David carries his injured brother home, demonstrating his emerging strength and responsibility
• The village celebration when David returns successful from his mail route, showing the community's acceptance of his maturity

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics overwhelmingly praised 'Tol'able David' as a masterpiece of silent cinema, with many reviewers hailing it as the best American film of 1921. The New York Times called it 'a triumph of American filmmaking' while Variety praised its 'unusual realism and emotional power.' Modern critics continue to regard the film highly, with Leonard Maltin describing it as 'one of the greatest of all silent films' and the American Film Institute including it in their list of important American films. Critics particularly commend Richard Barthelmess's natural performance, Henry King's sensitive direction, and the film's authentic portrayal of rural American life. The film is frequently cited in film studies courses as an exemplary work of silent-era storytelling and visual composition.

What Audiences Thought

Audiences in 1921 embraced 'Tol'able David' with tremendous enthusiasm, making it one of the year's biggest box office successes and turning Richard Barthelmess into a major star. The film's emotional story of a boy's journey to manhood resonated deeply with post-WWI audiences who valued themes of courage, family loyalty, and personal growth. Contemporary reports describe theaters being filled to capacity and audiences responding emotionally to David's struggles and triumphs. The film's popularity extended beyond urban centers to rural communities who appreciated its authentic portrayal of mountain life. Even decades later, the film continues to find appreciative audiences through revivals at classic film festivals and home video releases, with modern viewers responding to its timeless themes and masterful storytelling.

You Might Also Like