When the Clouds Roll By

Plot

Daniel Boone Brown is a carefree, wealthy playboy living life to the fullest in New York City, spending his nights carousing and his days avoiding responsibility. His life takes an unexpected turn when he becomes the unwilling subject of a series of psychological experiments conducted by the sinister Dr. Ulrich Metz, a sadistic psychiatrist who believes he can control human behavior through manipulation of the mind. Through various methods including sleep deprivation, sensory manipulation, and psychological torment, Dr. Metz drives Daniel to the brink of insanity, making him question his own sanity and reality. Amidst this psychological nightmare, Daniel encounters the lovely Lucette, who becomes his anchor and potential salvation. The film follows Daniel's harrowing journey through these experiments, his struggle to maintain his identity, and his burgeoning romance with Lucette, ultimately leading to a dramatic confrontation with his tormentor and a triumph of love and human will over scientific manipulation.

Historical Background

The production of 'When the Clouds Roll By' occurred during a pivotal period in American cinema and society. Released in November 1919, the film emerged in the immediate aftermath of World War I, a time when America was experiencing rapid social change and technological advancement. The film's exploration of psychological manipulation reflected the growing public fascination with psychoanalysis, which had gained significant attention following Sigmund Freud's lectures in the United States. This period also saw the rise of the independent producer movement in Hollywood, with stars like Fairbanks, Chaplin, and Pickford breaking away from the studio system to form United Artists the following year. The film's New York setting captured the energy and moral ambiguity of the Jazz Age that was about to dawn. The technical innovations displayed in the film, particularly its special effects, demonstrated the rapid evolution of cinematic language during the silent era. The movie's blend of comedy, romance, and psychological thriller elements also reflected the increasing sophistication of film audiences who were demanding more complex narratives than the simple melodramas that had dominated earlier cinema.

Making Of

The making of 'When the Clouds Roll By' marked a significant turning point in Hollywood history, representing the growing power of independent producers against the studio system. Douglas Fairbanks, having recently broken away from the established studio system, invested his own money and reputation into this ambitious project. Victor Fleming, then primarily known as a cinematographer, was given his first directorial opportunity largely due to Fairbanks' confidence in his visual sensibility. The production faced numerous challenges, particularly in creating the surreal dream sequences that were central to the plot. The special effects team, led by cinematographer William C. McGann, developed innovative techniques using multiple exposures, mirror effects, and carefully timed camera movements to achieve the otherworldly atmosphere. Fairbanks' insistence on performing his own stunts created tension on set, as the production team struggled to balance safety with his desire for authenticity. The film's psychological themes required extensive research and consultation with actual psychologists of the era to ensure accuracy while maintaining entertainment value. The New York City location shooting was particularly challenging due to the primitive equipment of the time and the need to control crowds in the bustling metropolis.

Visual Style

The cinematography by William C. McGann and Harry Perry was groundbreaking for its time, featuring innovative techniques that pushed the boundaries of what was possible in 1919. The film employed extensive use of double exposures to create dream sequences and psychological effects, with clouds literally rolling by as suggested by the title. The camera work incorporated unusual angles and movements that were rare in silent cinema, particularly in scenes depicting Daniel's psychological distress. The New York City location shooting utilized natural lighting in ways that created dramatic contrasts between the urban landscape and the characters' emotional states. The cinematographers developed new techniques for representing altered consciousness through visual distortion, slow motion, and rapid editing. The film's visual style influenced later psychological thrillers and contributed to the development of cinematic language for representing mental states. The use of shadow and light was particularly sophisticated for the era, creating a noir-like atmosphere that anticipated later developments in film noir cinematography.

Innovations

The film pioneered several technical innovations that would influence cinema for decades. The special effects team developed new techniques for creating realistic dream sequences using multiple exposure photography and mirror effects. The film featured some of the earliest examples of forced perspective photography to create surreal visual distortions. The production utilized innovative editing techniques to represent psychological states, including rapid cutting and montage sequences that were ahead of their time. The camera movement was particularly advanced for 1919, including tracking shots and crane movements that enhanced the film's dynamic quality. The sound effects created for the theatrical presentation (since it was a silent film) were innovative in their use of various objects to create psychological audio cues. The film's makeup effects, particularly those used to show Daniel's psychological deterioration, were considered groundbreaking for their subtlety and effectiveness. The production also pioneered new safety techniques for stunt work, which Fairbanks insisted upon despite performing his own stunts.

Music

As a silent film, 'When the Clouds Roll By' would have been accompanied by live musical performances during its theatrical run. The original score was composed by Victor Schertzinger, who was one of the era's most prominent film composers. The music incorporated popular songs of the period as well as original compositions designed to enhance the film's psychological themes. The score featured leitmotifs for different characters and psychological states, with dissonant chords accompanying the scenes of mental manipulation and romantic melodies for the love scenes. The musical accompaniment was designed to be particularly elaborate during the dream sequences, using orchestral effects to mirror the surreal visual imagery. Theater organists and small orchestras would have had detailed cue sheets to follow, ensuring consistency in the musical presentation across different venues. The score was considered unusually sophisticated for a comedy film, reflecting the production's ambitions to blend multiple genres.

Memorable Scenes

• The surreal dream sequence where clouds literally roll across the screen while Daniel floats through a distorted version of New York City
• The climactic confrontation between Daniel and Dr. Metz in the psychiatrist's laboratory, featuring elaborate special effects and psychological warfare
• The opening sequence establishing Daniel's carefree lifestyle through rapid cutting and dynamic camera movement
• The scene where Daniel first meets Lucette during one of his psychological episodes, blending romance with surreal imagery
• The experimental sequences showing Dr. Metz's various methods of psychological manipulation, including sensory deprivation and hypnotic suggestion

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised 'When the Clouds Roll By' for its innovation and ambition. The New York Times hailed it as 'a triumph of imagination and technical skill,' while Variety noted that Fairbanks had 'successfully expanded his range beyond pure athletic comedy to embrace more complex psychological material.' Critics particularly praised the film's dream sequences and special effects as groundbreaking for the time. Some reviewers found the psychological themes too complex for a mainstream audience, but most acknowledged Fairbanks' skill in making the material accessible and entertaining. Modern critics and film historians have reassessed the film as an important transitional work in Fairbanks' career and a significant early example of the psychological thriller genre. The film is now recognized for its technical achievements and its role in establishing Victor Fleming as a major directorial talent. Some contemporary scholars have noted the film's surprisingly sophisticated treatment of mental health issues for its era, though others criticize some of its dated psychological concepts.

What Audiences Thought

The film was a commercial success upon its release, drawing large audiences curious to see Fairbanks in a more complex role than his previous swashbuckling adventures. Contemporary audience reports indicate that viewers were particularly impressed by the film's special effects and dream sequences, which were unlike anything they had seen before. The combination of Fairbanks' trademark physical comedy with the more serious psychological elements proved popular with audiences seeking more sophisticated entertainment. The film's success at the box office helped validate Fairbanks' decision to form his own production company and pursue more ambitious projects. Audience reactions to the psychological themes were mixed, with some finding them confusing while others praised the film's intellectual depth. The romance between Fairbanks and Kathleen Clifford's characters was well-received, providing an emotional anchor to the more abstract psychological elements. Word-of-mouth was particularly strong regarding the film's visual spectacle, with many viewers recommending it specifically for its innovative dream sequences.

You Might Also Like