Woman to Woman

Plot

David Compton, a British officer stationed in Paris, abandons his pregnant French girlfriend Louise Boucher, a dancer at the Moulin Rouge, to fight in World War I. During the war, David suffers a traumatic head injury that erases his memory completely. After the war, with no recollection of his past, David builds a new life in London and eventually marries another woman. Meanwhile, Louise believes David died in combat and raises their son alone, eventually becoming a celebrated dancer under the stage name Deloryse. Years later, David attends one of Deloryse's performances where the sight of her triggers his lost memories. When Louise learns that David has married someone else, she entrusts their son to his new wife's care, accepts a demanding dancing engagement at a party, and tragically dies from exhaustion and a broken heart.

Historical Background

Woman to Woman was produced during a transitional period in British cinema when the industry was striving to compete with Hollywood productions. The early 1920s saw British studios investing in higher-budget films with international appeal, often importing American stars to increase marketability. The film's themes of war trauma and memory loss resonated strongly with post-World War I audiences, many of whom had experienced similar losses or knew someone suffering from shell shock. The film emerged during the golden age of silent cinema, just before the industry would be revolutionized by sound technology. Its production coincided with the rise of Gainsborough Pictures as a major force in British cinema, and the film's success helped establish the studio's reputation for sophisticated melodramas.

Making Of

Woman to Woman was a landmark production in British cinema history, marking the beginning of Alfred Hitchcock's association with Gainsborough Pictures. Hitchcock, then just 24 years old, served as assistant director to Graham Cutts and also contributed to the screenplay adaptation. The production was ambitious for its time, featuring expensive location shooting, elaborate sets, and international star power with American actress Betty Compson. The film's success led to a series of collaborations between Hitchcock and Cutts, though their relationship became strained as Hitchcock's talent grew. The production team employed innovative techniques for depicting memory loss, including double exposures and dissolves that were considered groundbreaking for the time. The film's emotional intensity was enhanced by Compson's method acting approach, which was unusual for the silent era.

Visual Style

The cinematography of Woman to Woman was handled by Hal Young, who employed innovative techniques for the period. The film featured elaborate lighting schemes to create dramatic shadows and highlights, particularly in the Moulin Rouge sequences. Young used soft focus techniques to emphasize emotional moments and employed tracking shots that were relatively advanced for British cinema of the time. The war sequences utilized handheld camera techniques to create a sense of chaos and immediacy. The film's visual style was influenced by German Expressionist cinema, particularly in its use of dramatic lighting and composition to convey psychological states.

Innovations

Woman to Woman featured several technical innovations for British cinema of the period. The film employed sophisticated double exposure techniques to depict memory sequences and dream states. The production used elaborate matte paintings to create the illusion of Parisian locations, a technique that was still relatively new in 1923. The film's war sequences featured innovative editing techniques, including rapid cutting to create tension and chaos. The production also utilized complex makeup effects to show the passage of time and the physical toll of illness on the characters.

Music

As a silent film, Woman to Woman would have been accompanied by live musical performance during its theatrical run. The original score was composed by Louis Meyer and featured a mix of classical pieces and original compositions tailored to the film's emotional beats. The Moulin Rouge sequences would have featured lively, Parisian-style music, while the dramatic scenes were accompanied by more somber, romantic themes. The film's success led to the publication of sheet music for its main themes, which became popular parlor pieces in the 1920s.

Memorable Scenes

• The dramatic Moulin Rouge performance where Deloryse's dancing triggers David's memory recovery
• The emotional confrontation scene where Louise learns of David's marriage
• The tragic final scene where Louise collapses during her performance, having sacrificed herself for her son's future
• The war sequence showing David's injury and memory loss
• The poignant moment when Louise entrusts her son to David's wife

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised Woman to Woman for its emotional power and sophisticated storytelling. The Times of London called it 'a triumph of British cinema' and specifically highlighted Betty Compson's performance as 'nothing short of extraordinary.' The film's technical achievements, particularly its visual storytelling and innovative use of cinematic techniques to depict memory loss, were widely noted in trade publications. Modern film historians regard the film as a crucial stepping stone in the development of British cinema and an important early work in Hitchcock's career, though its lost status prevents comprehensive contemporary reassessment.

What Audiences Thought

The film was a major commercial success upon its release, running for extended engagements in London and other major cities. Audiences were particularly moved by the film's emotional storyline and Betty Compson's performance, with many reports of viewers being reduced to tears during the film's tragic conclusion. The film's success at the British box office was unusual for a domestic production of the period, as American films typically dominated. Its popularity extended to international markets, including the United States where it was distributed by Paramount Pictures. The film's themes of lost love and sacrifice resonated deeply with post-war audiences who had experienced similar losses during World War I.

You Might Also Like