Also available on: YouTube
Hearts and Flowers

Hearts and Flowers

1919 20 minutes United States
Infidelity and temptationSocial class dynamicsUrban sophisticationRomantic jealousyDeception and misunderstanding

Plot

In this silent comedy, Ford Sterling plays a flamboyant hotel orchestra leader whose womanizing ways create chaos among the hotel staff and guests. His flirtatious advances toward various women, including characters played by Louise Fazenda and Phyllis Haver, lead to a series of misunderstandings and comedic confrontations. The orchestra leader's attempts to juggle multiple romantic interests result in increasingly elaborate schemes to avoid being discovered. As tensions escalate, the hotel becomes a battleground of jealous lovers, mistaken identities, and slapstick mishaps. The film culminates in a wild chase sequence through the hotel corridors as all the parties converge for a chaotic but humorous resolution.

About the Production

Release Date March 30, 1919
Production Fox Film Corporation
Filmed In Fox Studio, Los Angeles, California

The film was produced during the golden age of silent comedy, utilizing the Fox Studio facilities in Los Angeles. Edward F. Cline, who had previously worked with Buster Keaton and Charlie Chaplin, brought his expertise in physical comedy to this production. The hotel setting allowed for elaborate set designs and multi-level comedic sequences typical of the era's sophisticated comedies.

Historical Background

1919 was a pivotal year in American cinema, occurring just after World War I and during the Spanish Flu pandemic. The film industry was transitioning from short films to feature-length productions, though comedy shorts remained extremely popular. This was also the year of the 1919 actors' strike, which led to the formation of the Screen Actors Guild. The film reflected the post-war desire for light entertainment and escapism. Hotel settings in films were particularly resonant as they represented modern luxury and the changing social dynamics of the Jazz Age that was about to emerge.

Why This Film Matters

While not a groundbreaking film, 'Hearts and Flowers' represents the sophisticated evolution of silent comedy beyond the simple slapstick of earlier years. The film's hotel setting and character types influenced numerous subsequent comedies. It showcases the transition from Keystone's rough-and-tumble style to more narrative-driven comedy with character development. The film also demonstrates how Fox Film Corporation was building its comedy division to compete with established players like Keystone and Hal Roach studios.

Making Of

Edward F. Cline brought his extensive experience from working with comedy legends to this production. The film was shot on elaborate hotel sets constructed at Fox Studios, designed to allow for maximum physical comedy opportunities. Ford Sterling, known for his exaggerated expressions and comedic timing, likely improvised many of his scenes. The cast, all seasoned comedy veterans, would have rehearsed extensively to perfect the timing of the slapstick sequences. The orchestra scenes required actual musicians to be present on set to create authenticity, though the music itself would have been added later by theater organists during exhibition.

Visual Style

The cinematography, typical of 1919 Fox productions, utilized static camera positions with careful composition to frame the physical comedy. The hotel setting allowed for vertical compositions with actors moving up and down staircases and between floors. The film likely used the then-standard 35mm film format with an aspect ratio of 1.33:1. Lighting would have been primarily artificial studio lighting, creating the glamorous atmosphere expected in hotel-set films.

Innovations

The film employed standard technical practices of 1919 but may have featured some innovative set design for the hotel sequences. The multi-level hotel set allowed for more complex staging than earlier single-room comedies. The film likely used the latest lighting equipment available at Fox Studios, which was known for its technical innovations in the late 1910s.

Music

As a silent film, 'Hearts and Flowers' would have been accompanied by live music during exhibition. The title suggests that theater organists might have used the popular sentimental piece 'Hearts and Flowers' as thematic material. The orchestra scenes within the film would have been accompanied by appropriate musical cues, and the overall accompaniment would have followed the standard practice of using mood-appropriate classical and popular music selections.

Memorable Scenes

  • The climactic chase sequence through the hotel corridors where all the jealous lovers converge on the orchestra leader, creating a symphony of slapstick chaos as characters run in and out of rooms, hide in closets, and create increasingly elaborate attempts to avoid confrontation.

Did You Know?

  • Edward F. Cline would later co-direct some of Buster Keaton's most famous films including 'The General' (1926)
  • Ford Sterling was a veteran of Mack Sennett's Keystone Studios and helped establish many early comedy tropes
  • Louise Fazenda was known for her ability to transform into various comedic characters and was one of the highest-paid supporting actresses of the silent era
  • The film was released as a two-reeler, which was the standard length for comedy shorts of this period
  • Phyllis Haver would later star as the lead in the first Oscar-winning film 'Wings' (1927)
  • The title 'Hearts and Flowers' was likely a play on the popular sentimental music of the same name, creating ironic contrast with the film's chaotic comedy
  • Fox Film Corporation was still relatively new in 1919, having been founded just a few years earlier in 1915
  • The film was part of a series of comedy shorts Fox produced to compete with the more established comedy studios like Keystone and Hal Roach
  • Silent era hotel comedies were popular because they allowed for multiple storylines to converge in one location
  • The orchestra leader character was a popular archetype in silent comedies, representing the sophisticated but morally ambiguous city dweller

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews in trade publications like Variety and Moving Picture World generally praised the film for its comedic timing and the performances of its stars. Critics noted Ford Sterling's return to form after his Keystone years and Louise Fazenda's reliable comic support. Modern assessments of the film are limited due to its rarity, but film historians recognize it as a solid example of the transition period in American comedy cinema.

What Audiences Thought

The film was well-received by audiences of 1919 who were familiar with the stars from their previous work. Hotel comedies were particularly popular with urban audiences who could relate to the settings and situations. The combination of established comedy stars guaranteed audience interest, and the film likely performed well in the vaudeville theater circuit where comedy shorts were in high demand.

Film Connections

Influenced By

  • Mack Sennett comedies
  • Charlie Chaplin's character-driven comedies
  • Buster Keaton's physical comedy style

This Film Influenced

  • Later hotel comedies of the 1920s
  • Musical comedy shorts of the early sound era

You Might Also Like

The Bell Boy (1918)The Garage (1920)The Boat (1921)The Haunted House (1921)The Playhouse (1921)

Film Restoration

The preservation status of 'Hearts and Flowers' (1919) is uncertain. Many Fox Film Corporation productions from this period have been lost due to the 1937 Fox vault fire. However, some copies may exist in film archives or private collections. The film has not been widely available for home video or streaming, suggesting it may be among the many lost silent comedies. Film preservation organizations continue to search for missing films from this era.

Themes & Topics

hotelorchestraflirtationmistaken identityslapstickchasejealousydeceptionromantic comedymusician