My Favorite Brunette

Plot

Ronnie Jackson, a baby photographer with dreams of being a private detective, gets his chance when Baroness Carlotta Montay mistakes him for detective Sam McCloud and hires him to find her missing husband. Ronnie's investigation leads him through a series of dangerous encounters with mysterious characters, including the sinister Kismet and his accomplice Willie, who are after a map to valuable uranium deposits. After being framed for murder, Ronnie finds himself on death row recounting his improbable adventure to reporters. The story unfolds through flashbacks as he desperately tries to prove his innocence before his execution. In the end, Ronnie's bumbling but persistent nature helps him uncover the truth and win the girl.

Historical Background

Released in 1947, 'My Favorite Brunette' emerged during the post-World War II period when America was experiencing significant social and cultural changes. The film noir genre was at its peak popularity, with dark, cynical stories reflecting the disillusionment and anxiety of the postwar era. Hope's parody of this genre provided audiences with comic relief from the serious tone of many contemporary films. The atomic age had just begun, and references to uranium in the plot tapped into public fascination and fear about nuclear technology. Hollywood was also transitioning from the studio system's golden age, with stars like Hope becoming powerful enough to demand creative control and profit participation. The film's release came just as the Cold War was beginning to shape American politics and culture, though its light-hearted tone deliberately avoided these heavier themes.

Making Of

The production was a smooth affair despite its ambitious blend of comedy and noir elements. Bob Hope, known for his ad-libbing skills, was given considerable freedom to improvise on set, much to director Elliott Nugent's approval. The chemistry between Hope and Lamour was well-established from their previous 'Road to...' pictures, making their romantic scenes effortless. Peter Lorre, who had become typecast in villainous roles, embraced the opportunity to play against his sinister image in a comedy context. The film's noir parody elements were carefully crafted by cinematographer Lionel Lindon, who used low-key lighting techniques typical of film noir but maintained the bright, clear look needed for comedy. The prison scenes were filmed on standing sets that had been used in numerous other Paramount productions, modified to give them a fresh appearance.

Visual Style

Lionel Lindon's cinematography masterfully walks the line between film noir and comedy, using the shadowy lighting and dramatic camera angles typical of noir while maintaining the visual clarity needed for comedy. The film employs low-key lighting techniques in the mystery sequences, creating the appropriate noir atmosphere, but brightens considerably for the comedic moments. Lindon uses Dutch angles and deep shadows during the suspense scenes, then switches to more conventional, well-lit compositions for the dialogue-heavy comedy scenes. The contrast between these visual styles enhances the film's parody elements. The prison sequences are particularly noteworthy for their use of dramatic lighting that simultaneously creates tension and allows for Hope's comedic expressions to remain visible.

Innovations

While not groundbreaking in technical terms, 'My Favorite Brunette' achieved notable success in its seamless integration of two very different visual styles – film noir and comedy. The film's editing, supervised by Doane Harrison, effectively balanced the pacing required for both mystery and comedy, a difficult technical achievement. The production design by Hans Dreier and A. Earl Hedrick created sets that could accommodate both dramatic lighting and comedic staging. The film also demonstrated technical proficiency in its use of process photography for the driving sequences, which were common in films of this era but particularly well-executed here. The sound recording successfully captured both the whispered dialogue typical of noir and the broader comedic delivery required for Hope's performance.

Music

The musical score was composed by Robert Emmett Dolan, who frequently collaborated with Bob Hope. The soundtrack cleverly incorporates elements typical of film noir music – dramatic brass stings, moody string passages, and suspenseful percussion – but adapts them for comedic effect. The main theme, 'My Favorite Brunette,' became a minor hit and was performed by various artists of the period. Dolan's score punctuates the action with musical cues that both parody and celebrate noir conventions. The film also features several popular songs of the era, though none performed by the leads themselves. The sound design emphasizes the contrast between the serious tone of the mystery elements and the light-hearted comedy, with dramatic musical swells often undercut by Hope's comic timing.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence where Ronnie Jackson is photographing babies while fantasizing about being a hard-boiled detective, complete with dramatic narration and shadowy lighting that contrasts with the cheerful baby studio setting.
• The mistaken identity scene where Baroness Montay first approaches Ronnie, believing him to be detective Sam McCloud, leading to a series of increasingly desperate attempts by Ronnie to maintain the charade.
• The prison scenes where Ronnie recounts his story to reporters, using flashbacks to explain how he ended up on death row, with Hope's comedic timing creating humor even in the dire situation.
• The climactic chase sequence where Ronnie, despite his incompetence, manages to outwit the villains through sheer luck and persistence, culminating in a slapstick confrontation.
• The final scene where Ronnie's true identity as a baby photographer is revealed, but he still gets the girl, subverting traditional detective story conventions.

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised 'My Favorite Brunette' for its clever parody of film noir tropes and Bob Hope's comedic timing. The New York Times noted that 'Hope manages to be funny even while pretending to be serious, which is no small feat.' Variety called it 'a thoroughly entertaining romp that successfully blends mystery and mirth.' Modern critics have come to appreciate the film as a classic example of Hollywood's ability to produce sophisticated genre parodies. The film is often cited in film studies courses as an example of how comedy can deconstruct and celebrate genre conventions simultaneously. Critics particularly praise Peter Lorre's willingness to poke fun at his own sinister image, which adds an extra layer of meta-humor to the proceedings.

What Audiences Thought

Audiences in 1947 embraced 'My Favorite Brunette' enthusiastically, making it one of the year's highest-grossing comedies. The film's blend of mystery and romance appealed to a broad demographic, from teenagers to adults. Hope's fans particularly enjoyed seeing him play the bumbling but ultimately heroic detective, a character type that would become his signature. The film's success at the box office proved that audiences were ready for lighter fare after years of war-themed dramas. In subsequent decades, the film has maintained its popularity through television broadcasts and home video releases, with new generations discovering its charms. Modern audiences often appreciate the film's clever wordplay and the chemistry between Hope and Lamour, which transcends the specific humor of its era.

You Might Also Like