Salute
"Two Brothers... One Girl... The Greatest Game of All!"
Plot
Two brothers, John and Dan Donahue, are both attending West Point Military Academy but couldn't be more different in their personalities and approaches to life. John, the older brother, is serious, disciplined, and dedicated to his military career, while Dan is carefree, popular, and more interested in social activities and romance. Their rivalry intensifies when they both fall for the same woman, Nancy Wayne, whose father is a respected general at the academy. The brothers' competition leads to various conflicts and challenges, including a crucial football game between West Point and Navy, where their personal and professional loyalties are tested. Ultimately, the brothers must reconcile their differences and learn the true meaning of brotherhood, duty, and honor while navigating their romantic entanglements and military responsibilities.
About the Production
This was one of John Ford's early sound films, made during the challenging transition from silent to talking pictures. The film was partially shot on location at the actual West Point Military Academy, providing authentic settings and atmosphere. Ford utilized both synchronized sound sequences and silent footage with musical accompaniment, reflecting the transitional nature of late 1920s cinema. The production faced challenges with early sound recording equipment, which limited camera mobility and required actors to remain relatively stationary during dialogue scenes.
Historical Background
1929 was a pivotal year in cinema history, marking the full transition from silent films to talkies. 'Salute' was produced during this technological revolution, when studios were desperately trying to adapt to sound technology while maintaining the artistic qualities of silent cinema. The film reflected the cultural values of pre-Depression America, with its emphasis on military honor, brotherhood, and traditional romance. West Point Military Academy held a special place in American popular culture during this era, symbolizing discipline, honor, and the strength of American institutions. The film's release in April 1929 came just six months before the stock market crash that would trigger the Great Depression, making it part of the final wave of films from the prosperous Jazz Age. The military themes also resonated with a society that still remembered World War I and held military service in high regard. The film's focus on the Army-Navy rivalry tapped into a long-standing American tradition that represented more than just sports – it symbolized the competition between different branches of military service and regional pride.
Why This Film Matters
While not considered one of John Ford's masterpieces, 'Salute' holds importance as a transitional work that demonstrates how a major director adapted to the sound revolution. The film represents the early sound era's attempt to combine traditional American values with new cinematic technology. Its depiction of military academy life helped establish tropes and conventions that would appear in countless subsequent films about military education. The movie also contributed to the popularization of West Point as a romantic setting in American cinema, influencing later films like 'The Long Gray Line' (1955) and 'Taps' (1981). The film's approach to sound – mixing dialogue sequences with silent-style visual storytelling – was typical of the period but particularly well-executed under Ford's direction. The brother rivalry theme would become a recurring motif in Ford's later work, most notably in 'The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance' (1962). The film also represents an early example of sports integration into mainstream narrative cinema, with the football sequences serving as both spectacle and plot device.
Making Of
The making of 'Salute' represented a significant milestone in John Ford's career as he navigated the challenging transition from silent to sound cinema. Ford, who had built his reputation on visually dynamic silent films, initially struggled with the technical limitations of early sound recording, which required bulky microphones and restricted camera movement. The production team developed innovative solutions, including using hidden microphones and creating special soundproof sets. Ford's collaboration with cinematographer George Schneiderman resulted in a visually impressive film that maintained his signature style while accommodating the new sound technology. The casting process was particularly interesting, as Ford chose George O'Brien, his frequent collaborator from silent films, to help bridge the gap between his old and new styles. The on-location shooting at West Point presented unique challenges, as the production had to work around the academy's strict schedule and regulations. Ford's military background (he had served in the Navy) helped him gain the trust and cooperation of the military officials, allowing for unprecedented access to authentic locations and personnel.
Visual Style
The cinematography by George Schneiderman successfully blended Ford's silent film visual style with the requirements of early sound recording. Despite the technical limitations of early sound equipment, which often resulted in static camera positions, Schneiderman managed to create dynamic compositions within these constraints. The on-location shooting at West Point provided opportunities for impressive exterior shots that contrasted with the more confined interior scenes required for sound recording. The football sequences were particularly well-shot, using multiple camera angles and innovative tracking shots that captured the action's excitement. The film's visual style maintained Ford's preference for deep focus composition and carefully staged group scenes, techniques that would become hallmarks of his later work. The black and white photography showed excellent contrast and clarity, especially in the exterior military academy scenes.
Innovations
As one of Fox Film Corporation's early sound productions, 'Salute' demonstrated several technical innovations for its time. The film utilized the Fox Movietone sound-on-film system, which was among the more advanced sound technologies of 1929. The production team developed innovative microphone placement techniques to maintain visual quality while capturing clear dialogue. The football sequences featured some of the earliest examples of synchronized sports sound recording, capturing the authentic sounds of the game. The film also experimented with mixing location sound with studio recording, a practice that would become standard in later years. The seamless integration of silent-style visual storytelling with sound sequences represented an important technical achievement in transitional cinema. The on-location sound recording at West Point was particularly noteworthy, as it required portable equipment that was still in its developmental stages.
Music
The film's music was composed by Samuel Kaylin, who created a score that blended traditional military themes with romantic melodies appropriate for the story. As an early sound film, 'Salute' utilized the Fox Movietone system, which provided better audio quality than many competing sound technologies of the era. The soundtrack included both diegetic music (music within the story, such as military band performances) and non-diegetic orchestral accompaniment. The film featured several popular songs of the period, which helped enhance its commercial appeal. The sound design also included carefully synchronized sound effects for the military sequences and football game, adding to the film's realism. The audio quality, while impressive for 1929, still showed the limitations of early recording technology, with occasional background noise and limited dynamic range.
Famous Quotes
A man's honor is more precious than his life.
In this academy, we learn that discipline is the bridge between goals and accomplishment.
The toughest battle isn't on the football field - it's in here, between brothers.
West Point doesn't just make soldiers, it makes men.
Memorable Scenes
- The climactic Army-Navy football game sequence, which combines authentic game footage with dramatic narrative moments and represents the brothers' ultimate confrontation and reconciliation
Did You Know?
- This was John Ford's first sound film, marking his transition from silent to talking pictures
- George O'Brien and John Ford had previously collaborated on several successful silent films including 'The Iron Horse' (1924) and '3 Bad Men' (1926)
- The film features authentic footage of the actual Army-Navy football game, providing documentary-like realism
- Helen Chandler, who played the female lead, would later become famous for her role as Mina in the classic horror film 'Dracula' (1931)
- The film was released just months before the stock market crash of 1929, making it one of the last films of the prosperous Jazz Age
- William Janney, who played the younger brother, was a real-life military academy graduate, adding authenticity to his performance
- The production was granted unprecedented access to West Point facilities, a privilege rarely given to film crews at the time
- The film's soundtrack included early Fox Movietone technology, which was cutting-edge for 1929
- Despite being a sound film, approximately 30% of the movie was shot as a silent film with musical accompaniment
- The football sequences were filmed during an actual Army-Navy game, with real cadets serving as extras
What Critics Said
Contemporary reviews in 1929 were generally positive, with critics praising John Ford's successful transition to sound and the film's authentic military atmosphere. The New York Times noted that 'Ford has managed to retain his visual storytelling prowess while embracing the new medium of sound.' Variety appreciated the on-location shooting at West Point, calling it 'a remarkable achievement in cinematic realism.' Some critics, however, found the plot formulaic and the dialogue occasionally stilted, which was common in early sound films. Modern film historians view 'Salute' as an interesting but minor work in Ford's canon, valuable primarily for its historical significance as his first sound film and for demonstrating his adaptability during a crucial period of cinematic change. The film is often cited in scholarly works about the transition from silent to sound cinema as an example of how established directors managed this technological shift.
What Audiences Thought
Contemporary audiences in 1929 responded positively to 'Salute,' particularly appreciating the authentic military settings and the popular theme of brother rivalry. The film's release during the football season helped attract sports fans, while the romantic elements appealed to the typical movie-going demographic of the time. The combination of military drama, sports action, and romance made it a commercial success, though it didn't achieve the blockbuster status of some other 1929 releases. Modern audiences have had limited exposure to the film due to its rarity, but those who have seen it through film society screenings or archival presentations often note its historical interest and the charming performances of the lead actors. The film's depiction of West Point life has been praised by military historians for its accuracy and attention to detail.
Awards & Recognition
- No major awards were recorded for this film
Film Connections
Influenced By
- John Ford's earlier silent films about military life
- Popular 1920s sports films
- Contemporary military academy dramas
- Stage plays about brother rivalry
This Film Influenced
- Later West Point films
- Military academy dramas of the 1930s
- Sports films with romantic subplots
- John Ford's later films about brother relationships
You Might Also Like
Film Restoration
The film survives in complete form and has been preserved by major film archives, though it remains relatively rare with limited home video availability. A restored version exists in the Fox Film Collection and is occasionally screened at film festivals and archival presentations.