Sherlock Jr.

Plot

A young movie theater projectionist (Buster Keaton) dreams of becoming a great detective like Sherlock Holmes while courting his sweetheart (Kathryn McGuire). When a rival suitor known as 'The Local Sheik' frames the projectionist for stealing his girlfriend's father's pocketwatch, he is devastated and loses both his job and his relationship. While working at the theater, the dejected projectionist falls asleep during a screening and dreams himself into the movie as the brilliant detective Sherlock Jr., embarking on an elaborate adventure to solve a jewel theft case. In his dream world, he performs incredible feats of detection and physical comedy, tracking down criminals through a series of imaginative and dangerous situations. Upon waking, he discovers that his real-life situation has resolved itself in a manner remarkably similar to his dream, allowing him to clear his name and win back his girlfriend.

Historical Background

'Sherlock Jr.' was produced during the golden age of silent comedy in Hollywood, a period when physical comedians like Charlie Chaplin, Harold Lloyd, and Buster Keaton were at the height of their popularity and creative powers. The film was made just a few years before the transition to sound films would revolutionize the industry, making it part of the final flowering of pure visual comedy. In 1924, America was experiencing the Roaring Twenties, a period of economic prosperity and cultural change, and cinema was becoming the dominant form of popular entertainment. The film's meta-cinematic themes reflected a growing sophistication in movie audiences, who were becoming familiar with cinematic conventions and could appreciate jokes about the medium itself. The detective genre was extremely popular in the 1920s, with Sherlock Holmes remaining a cultural icon, making Keaton's parody timely and relevant to contemporary audiences.

Making Of

The production of 'Sherlock Jr.' was marked by Keaton's characteristic perfectionism and willingness to risk physical harm for the perfect shot. The film was shot at Keaton's own studio in Burbank, giving him complete creative control. The most technically challenging sequence was the dream sequence where Keaton enters the movie world, which required innovative matte photography techniques that were revolutionary for 1924. Keaton and his team spent weeks planning and rehearsing the pool hall scene, using real billiard balls and expert players to achieve the impossible-looking shots. The famous water tower stunt, where Keaton is knocked unconscious by falling water, resulted in a genuine neck injury that went undiagnosed for years. The film's production coincided with Keaton's peak creative period, when he had complete artistic freedom and the resources to execute his most ambitious ideas. The collaboration with cinematographer Elgin Lessley was particularly fruitful, as they developed new techniques for the surreal dream sequences that would influence filmmakers for decades.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Elgin Lessley and Byron Houck was revolutionary for its time, featuring innovative techniques that were years ahead of contemporary filmmaking. The film's most celebrated sequence involves Keaton jumping through a movie screen, accomplished through precise matte photography and multiple exposures that created the illusion of entering a film world. The pool hall sequence required intricate camera work to capture seemingly impossible billiard shots, using carefully planned angles and timing. Lessley employed groundbreaking perspective tricks and forced perspective shots throughout the dream sequence, creating surreal visual gags that played with cinematic reality. The chase sequence featured dynamic camera movement and innovative editing techniques that enhanced the physical comedy. The cinematography also included early examples of what would later be called 'match cuts,' particularly in the transitions between the real world and the dream world. The visual style balanced the gritty realism of the theater setting with the fantastical elements of the dream sequence, creating a distinctive visual language that supported the film's meta-cinematic themes.

Innovations

'Sherlock Jr.' pioneered numerous technical innovations that would influence cinema for decades. The film's most famous achievement is the seamless integration of live action with what appears to be a movie within a movie, accomplished through sophisticated matte photography and multiple exposure techniques that were revolutionary for 1924. The pool hall sequence featured impossible billiard shots achieved through clever editing, camera tricks, and wire work that created the illusion of balls changing direction and making impossible shots. The film also employed early examples of stop-motion photography and rapid-fire editing techniques that enhanced the comedic timing. The transformation sequence during the chase scene, where Keaton's vehicle changes from a motorcycle to other vehicles, was accomplished through carefully timed cuts and prop work. The film's use of perspective tricks and forced perspective in the dream sequence prefigured later developments in special effects. Additionally, the film demonstrated advanced understanding of continuity editing and spatial relationships, particularly in the complex chase sequences that maintained clear geography despite their frantic pace. These technical achievements were all accomplished in-camera or with simple optical effects, decades before computer-generated imagery would make such techniques commonplace.

Music

As a silent film, 'Sherlock Jr.' was originally accompanied by live musical performances in theaters, typically featuring a pianist, organist, or small orchestra. The original score has been lost to time, as was common with silent films where musical accompaniment was often improvised or adapted by local musicians. However, modern restorations have featured new scores composed specifically for the film. In 1995, the Alloy Orchestra created a contemporary score using percussion and electronic instruments to complement the film's dynamic action sequences. The Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra has also composed and performed authentic period-style scores for the film, using orchestrations from the 1920s. The musical accompaniment typically follows the film's emotional arc, with jaunty, upbeat music during the comedy sequences and more dramatic, mysterious themes during the detective portions. The lack of dialogue makes the musical score particularly important in conveying mood and enhancing the physical comedy, with syncopated rhythms often matching Keaton's precise movements and stunts.

Memorable Scenes

• The iconic scene where Keaton's projectionist character falls asleep and his dream self literally walks out of his body and into the movie screen, seamlessly transitioning from the theater to the film world.
• The elaborate pool hall sequence where Keaton performs impossible billiard shots, including balls that change direction mid-roll and jump over obstacles.
• The dangerous water tower stunt where Keaton is knocked unconscious by a torrent of water, resulting in his real-life neck injury.
• The chase sequence featuring Keaton on a motorcycle with sidecar that undergoes multiple transformations, including losing its wheels and becoming a handcar.
• The scene where Keaton as Sherlock Jr. performs incredible detective feats, including catching a thrown object with his eyes closed and tracking footprints that appear and disappear.

What Critics Said

Upon its initial release, 'Sherlock Jr.' received mixed reviews from contemporary critics, with some praising its technical innovations while others found the dream sequence confusing. The New York Times noted the film's 'clever photographic effects' but questioned whether audiences would follow the surreal premise. However, over the decades, critical opinion has shifted dramatically, and the film is now widely regarded as one of Keaton's masterpieces and one of the greatest films ever made. Modern critics consistently praise the film's technical brilliance, comedic timing, and pioneering use of meta-cinematic devices. Roger Ebert included it in his Great Movies collection, calling it 'a comedy of astonishing physical grace and visual wit.' The film currently holds a 100% rating on Rotten Tomatoes and is frequently cited in polls of the greatest films of all time by critics and filmmakers alike. The British Film Institute ranks it among the top 10 American films, and it's regularly featured in retrospectives of silent cinema and comedy classics.

What Audiences Thought

Initial audience reception in 1924 was somewhat lukewarm compared to Keaton's other films of the period, as some viewers found the surreal dream sequence difficult to follow. The film performed moderately well in urban areas but was less successful in smaller markets where audiences preferred more straightforward comedy. However, like many of Keaton's works, the film's reputation has grown substantially over time. Modern audiences have embraced the film's innovative techniques and timeless humor, with screenings at revival theaters and film festivals consistently drawing enthusiastic crowds. The film's availability on home video and streaming platforms has introduced it to new generations of viewers who appreciate its groundbreaking approach to comedy and cinema. Online forums and social media have helped create a renewed appreciation for the film's technical achievements, with many modern viewers expressing amazement at effects that were achieved nearly a century ago without computer technology.

You Might Also Like