The Inner Circle

Plot

The Inner Circle tells the story of a lonely Italian widower living in the city's Italian quarter who has been grieving the death of his wife and finds solace only in his young child. His life takes a dark turn when he is reluctantly recruited into a secret society operating among his fellow countrymen. The society members, envious of a successful wealthy Italian businessman, demand $5,000 from him under the pretense of funding their organization. When the wealthy man defiantly refuses their extortion, the society decides he must be killed and chooses the widower as their newest member to carry out the assassination, forcing him to choose between his moral values and his loyalty to the criminal organization.

Historical Background

The Inner Circle was released in 1912, a pivotal year in cinema history. This was during the transitional period when films were evolving from simple novelty attractions to sophisticated storytelling mediums. The film industry was rapidly consolidating, with companies like Biograph dominating production. Socially, 1912 America was experiencing massive immigration, particularly from Southern and Eastern Europe, leading to the formation of ethnic enclaves in major cities. The film's depiction of Italian-American communities and secret societies reflected real social tensions and the public's fascination with immigrant cultures. This was also the year before Griffith would leave Biograph to make his feature-length masterpieces, making this film part of his final period of short-form experimentation.

Making Of

The Inner Circle was produced during Griffith's most innovative period at Biograph, where he was experimenting with narrative techniques, camera work, and editing that would become standard in cinema. The film was likely shot in just a few days, as was common for Biograph productions of this era. Griffith was known for his meticulous attention to detail and his ability to extract strong performances from his actors, even in these rapidly produced shorts. The casting of Jack Pickford, brother of the famous Mary Pickford, may have been intended to add star power to the production. The film's focus on Italian-American communities reflects Griffith's interest in the melting pot of immigrant life in New York City, a theme he would return to in later works like 'The Birth of a Nation' and 'Intolerance'.

Visual Style

The cinematography in The Inner Circle would have been typical of Biograph productions in 1912, using stationary camera positions with occasional pans or tilts. The film was likely shot by Billy Bitzer, Griffith's regular cinematographer, who was pioneering many camera techniques during this period. The visual style would have featured the high contrast lighting common in early cinema, with dramatic use of shadows to enhance the film's crime elements. Interior scenes would have been shot on studio sets with artificial lighting, while any exterior scenes would utilize natural light, creating the characteristic look of films from this transitional period in cinematography.

Innovations

While not among Griffith's most technically innovative films, The Inner Circle would have incorporated the cross-cutting techniques that Griffith was developing during this period. The film likely used parallel editing to build suspense between different storylines, a technique Griffith was pioneering. The production would have utilized the standard 35mm film format with the Biograph studio's preferred aspect ratio. The film represents the refinement of continuity editing that Griffith and his team were perfecting, creating a more seamless narrative experience for audiences compared to earlier, more primitive filmmaking techniques.

Music

As a silent film, The Inner Circle would have been accompanied by live musical performance during theatrical exhibition. The score would typically have been provided by a pianist or small theater orchestra, often improvising or using cue sheets provided by the studio. The music would have emphasized the film's dramatic moments, particularly during scenes involving the secret society meetings and the widower's moral conflict. No original score or cue sheets are known to survive for this specific film.

Memorable Scenes

• The scene where the widower is initiated into the secret society, likely featuring ritualistic elements and dramatic lighting
• The confrontation where the wealthy Italian refuses to pay the extortion demand
• The emotional moment when the widower must choose between his child's safety and his moral values

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception of The Inner Circle is difficult to ascertain due to the limited survival of film trade publications from 1912. However, Griffith's work during this Biograph period was generally well-regarded by industry publications like The Moving Picture World and Variety. Modern film historians view the film as a typical example of Griffith's Biograph output - competently made and thematically interesting, but not among his most innovative works. The film is primarily studied today by scholars interested in Griffith's development and early depictions of Italian-Americans in cinema.

What Audiences Thought

Audience reception in 1912 is difficult to document precisely, but Biograph films featuring social themes and moral dilemmas were generally popular with nickelodeon audiences. The film's dramatic elements involving a child in danger and a father's moral crisis would have resonated with early cinema patrons. The 17-minute runtime was ideal for the typical program of multiple shorts shown at nickelodeons of the era. As with most films of this period, word-of-mouth and the reputation of the Biograph brand and Griffith's name would have been primary factors in attracting audiences.

You Might Also Like