The Red Lantern

Plot

Mahlee, the daughter of an Englishman and his Chinese mistress, grows up alongside her half-sister Blanche, who is the legitimate daughter of the Englishman and his English wife. Despite being raised together, Mahlee faces constant discrimination due to her mixed heritage and Chinese features. Determined to escape her marginalized status, Mahlee attempts to pass as European and integrate into white society, but finds the racial barriers insurmountable. Heartbroken and rejected, she returns to her Chinese roots and embraces her heritage, eventually leading her people in a rebellion against their oppressors. The film explores themes of racial identity, cultural belonging, and the tragic consequences of societal prejudice through its melodramatic narrative of divided loyalties and impossible choices.

Historical Background

The Red Lantern was produced during a period of significant racial tension in America, following World War I and during the height of the 'Yellow Peril' hysteria. The film's release coincided with increased Chinese immigration restrictions and growing anti-Asian sentiment in the United States. Despite this social climate, the film presented a surprisingly progressive view of racial identity and challenged prevailing stereotypes. The post-war era also saw a surge in films dealing with social issues, as audiences sought more sophisticated narratives. Hollywood was transitioning from short films to feature-length productions, and The Red Lantern exemplified this shift with its complex themes and ambitious scope.

Making Of

The production of The Red Lantern was marked by Nazimova's intense involvement in every aspect of filmmaking. She insisted on authentic representation of Chinese culture, hiring actual Chinese actors for supporting roles and consulting with cultural experts. The film's elaborate sets included a full-scale replica of a Chinese village and temple complex. Nazimova's method acting approach was revolutionary for the time, as she remained in character as Mahlee throughout the entire shoot, even when cameras weren't rolling. The film's controversial themes caused tension with studio executives, who feared public backlash, but Nazimova's star power ensured the project moved forward.

Visual Style

The film's cinematography, overseen by Lucien Andriot, was praised for its innovative use of lighting and composition. The Red Lantern employed dramatic chiaroscuro effects to emphasize the contrast between Mahlee's two worlds. The Chinese sequences featured warm, amber tones that suggested exoticism and tradition, while the Western scenes used cooler, more clinical lighting. The film made extensive use of tinting, particularly red tones during emotional moments and rebellion scenes. The camera work was more dynamic than typical of the period, with moving shots during the action sequences and carefully composed close-ups that highlighted Nazimova's expressive performance.

Innovations

The Red Lantern featured several technical innovations for its time, including sophisticated matte painting techniques to create the illusion of expansive Chinese landscapes. The film pioneered the use of color tinting to enhance emotional storytelling, with different colors used to signify different emotional states and cultural contexts. The production also developed new makeup techniques to create convincing racial transformations, a significant challenge in early cinema. The film's elaborate set designs incorporated moving elements and forced perspective to create depth and scale. The rebellion sequences featured innovative camera techniques including tracking shots and multiple camera coverage, relatively rare in 1919.

Music

As a silent film, The Red Lantern was accompanied by live musical scores during its theatrical run. The original score was composed by Victor Schertzinger, who incorporated both Western and Chinese musical elements to reflect the film's dual cultural themes. The music featured traditional Chinese instruments alongside Western orchestral arrangements, creating a unique soundscape that enhanced the film's emotional impact. The score was particularly noted for its use of pentatonic scales during Chinese scenes and more conventional Western melodies during the European sequences. The film's title theme, 'The Red Lantern,' became popular and was published as sheet music for home performance.

Memorable Scenes

• The heartbreaking scene where Mahlee tries to pass as European at a high society ball, only to be cruelly rejected when her true heritage is discovered.
• The powerful climax where Mahlee, having embraced her Chinese identity, leads the rebellion carrying the symbolic red lantern that gives the film its title.
• The emotional confrontation between the two sisters, where Blanche's privilege and Mahlee's marginalization are laid bare.
• The opening sequence showing the two sisters as children, establishing their bond and the seeds of future division.

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised The Red Lantern for its bold themes and Nazimova's powerful performance. The New York Times called it 'a daring and important film that tackles the difficult subject of racial prejudice with uncommon sensitivity.' Variety noted that 'Miss Nazimova gives perhaps the performance of her career, bringing depth and humanity to a role that could easily have descended into stereotype.' Modern critics have reevaluated the film as a pioneering work in racial representation, though some note that it still reflects the limitations of its era's understanding of race. The film is now recognized as an important artifact of early Hollywood's attempts to address social issues.

What Audiences Thought

The Red Lantern was a commercial success upon its release, drawing large audiences curious about its controversial themes. Many viewers were moved by Mahlee's tragic story and the film's emotional power. However, the film also faced some backlash from conservative audiences who objected to its interracial themes. Despite this controversy, the film's strong word-of-mouth and Nazimova's popularity ensured healthy box office returns. The film particularly resonated with immigrant audiences who identified with themes of cultural displacement and identity struggle. Its success demonstrated that American audiences were ready for more complex, socially conscious narratives in cinema.

You Might Also Like