The Student Prince in Old Heidelberg

Plot

Crown Prince Karl Heinrich of the fictional kingdom of Karlsburg is sent to study at the University of Heidelberg to experience life as a commoner before assuming his royal duties. There, he falls deeply in love with Kathi, a beautiful and spirited barmaid at the inn where he stays, leading to a passionate romance that transcends their different social classes. The Prince experiences the joys of ordinary life, friendship with fellow students, and the warmth of genuine human connection, all of which he has never known in the isolated royal court. However, their idyllic love is threatened when the Prince's grandfather, the King, summons him back to court to fulfill his royal duties and enter into a politically advantageous arranged marriage. The Prince must ultimately choose between his heart's desire and his duty to his country, leading to a bittersweet conclusion that explores the conflict between personal happiness and royal responsibility.

Historical Background

The film was produced during a pivotal moment in cinema history, as the industry was transitioning from silent films to 'talkies'. 1927 was the year of 'The Jazz Singer', the first feature film with synchronized dialogue, which would revolutionize the industry. 'The Student Prince in Old Heidelberg' represented the pinnacle of silent filmmaking artistry, showcasing what could be achieved without dialogue through visual storytelling, acting, and music. The film also reflected the 1920s fascination with European culture and romance, particularly German romanticism, which had been popular in America since the late 19th century. The post-World War I period saw a renewed interest in German culture, and Hollywood capitalized on this with films that presented a romanticized version of old Europe. Additionally, 1927 was a year of significant economic prosperity in America (the height of the Roaring Twenties), which allowed studios like MGM to invest heavily in lavish productions. The film's themes of duty versus personal freedom also resonated with contemporary audiences who were questioning traditional values in the modern era.

Making Of

The production of 'The Student Prince in Old Heidelberg' was a monumental undertaking for MGM, representing the studio's commitment to quality and prestige in the late silent era. Ernst Lubitsch, who had recently emigrated from Germany, brought his distinctive 'Lubitsch Touch' - a sophisticated blend of wit and sentimentality - to the project. The casting process was extensive, with MGM considering several actors for the lead role before settling on Ramon Novarro, who was one of the studio's biggest stars. Norma Shearer was cast as Kathi after impressing studio executives with her performance in 'The Merry Widow'. The production design was particularly ambitious, with Cedric Gibbons creating massive sets that recreated the University of Heidelberg and the surrounding town. The famous inn set was so elaborate that it remained standing on the MGM lot for years, being used in numerous subsequent films. The film was shot during a transitional period in Hollywood, as studios were experimenting with sound technology. While primarily a silent film, MGM added a synchronized musical score and sound effects, making it one of the first films to feature this technology. The score was adapted from Romberg's operetta, with additional original music composed by William Axt. The production faced challenges in maintaining authenticity while working in California, with Lubitsch insisting on German cultural accuracy in everything from the costumes to the actors' mannerisms.

Visual Style

The cinematography by John J. Mescall and Oliver T. Marsh was groundbreaking for its time, featuring innovative camera movements and lighting techniques that enhanced the film's emotional impact. The filmmakers employed soft focus techniques to create a dreamlike, romantic atmosphere, particularly in the love scenes between the Prince and Kathi. The cinematography made extensive use of natural-looking lighting to create authentic European atmospheres, with careful attention to how light filtered through windows and illuminated the famous German university settings. The film featured several technically complex shots, including the famous sequence where the Prince and his friends drink and sing in the beer garden, which was filmed using a moving camera to create a sense of participation and celebration. The cinematography also utilized depth of field to create rich, layered compositions that added visual complexity to the storytelling. The black and white photography was particularly effective in creating contrast between the rigid formality of the royal court and the warmth of life in Heidelberg.

Innovations

The film was a technical marvel of its time, featuring several innovations that would influence future filmmaking. It was one of the first films to use synchronized music and sound effects, employing the Vitaphone system to create a hybrid silent-sound experience. The production pioneered new techniques in creating authentic period atmosphere on studio sets, with art director Cedric Gibbons developing innovative methods for recreating 19th-century German architecture. The film's cinematography featured advanced lighting techniques, including the use of backlighting to create romantic silhouettes and the manipulation of shadows to enhance emotional scenes. The production also experimented with camera movement, using dollies and cranes to create dynamic shots that added visual interest to the storytelling. The film's editing was particularly sophisticated for the silent era, with smooth transitions between scenes and effective use of cross-cutting to build emotional tension. The makeup techniques used to age the actors were also innovative, particularly in the scenes showing the Prince's transformation from student to ruler. The film's preservation and restoration in later years also demonstrated advances in film restoration technology.

Music

The film featured an innovative synchronized musical score adapted from Sigmund Romberg's operetta 'The Student Prince', making it one of the first films to use pre-recorded music synchronized to the action. The score included the famous songs from the operetta such as 'Deep in My Heart, Dear' and 'Drinking Song', which were adapted for the film's emotional needs. The music was composed and conducted by William Axt, who worked closely with Lubitsch to ensure the score enhanced the film's emotional narrative. The synchronization process was cutting-edge for 1927, using the Vitaphone sound-on-disc system to align the music with the on-screen action. The film also included synchronized sound effects, such as the clinking of beer steins and the sounds of celebration in the university scenes. This musical approach represented a transitional technology between pure silent films and full talkies, showing how music and sound could enhance cinematic storytelling without dialogue. The score was so popular that it was released as a separate recording, becoming one of the first film soundtracks available for home listening.

Memorable Scenes

• The beer garden celebration scene where the Prince and his fellow students sing the famous drinking song, featuring innovative camera movement and synchronized sound effects
• The first meeting between the Prince and Kathi at the inn, where their instant chemistry is established through subtle glances and gestures
• The farewell scene between the Prince and Kathi by the river, one of the most emotionally powerful moments in silent cinema
• The Prince's return to the royal court, with stark visual contrast between the warmth of Heidelberg and the cold formality of the palace
• The final scene where the aged Prince returns to Heidelberg as a tourist, poignantly revisiting the places of his youth and lost love

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics overwhelmingly praised 'The Student Prince in Old Heidelberg' as a masterpiece of silent cinema. The New York Times called it 'a triumph of the motion picture art' and specifically praised Lubitsch's direction for its 'delicate touch and profound understanding of human emotion'. Variety described it as 'one of the most beautiful and touching pictures ever produced by MGM'. Critics particularly highlighted the performances of Novarro and Shearer, noting their chemistry and emotional authenticity. The film's visual beauty, cinematography, and art direction were also widely acclaimed. Modern critics continue to regard the film highly, with many considering it one of Lubitsch's finest American works. The film is often cited as a prime example of how silent films could convey complex emotions and sophisticated storytelling without dialogue. Contemporary film scholars praise its technical achievements and its role in the transition to sound cinema. The film maintains a 100% rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on critical reviews, and is frequently included in lists of the greatest silent films ever made.

What Audiences Thought

The film was a tremendous commercial success upon its release, becoming one of MGM's biggest hits of 1927. Audiences were captivated by the romantic story and the chemistry between the leads. The film's emotional power resonated strongly with viewers, with many reports of audiences being moved to tears during screenings. The synchronized musical score was particularly appreciated by audiences, who found it enhanced the emotional impact of the story. The film's success at the box office helped validate MGM's investment in expensive, high-quality productions. Moviegoers of the era especially praised the film's visual beauty and the authentic European atmosphere created on the MGM lot. The film's popularity extended beyond America, with successful releases in Europe despite being an American production of a European story. In the decades since its release, the film has maintained a devoted following among silent film enthusiasts and classic cinema lovers. It is frequently screened at film festivals and revival houses, where it continues to move audiences with its timeless story of love and duty.

You Might Also Like