Romola
"A Great Motion Picture Masterpiece from the Novel by George Eliot"
Plot
In Renaissance Florence, a Florentine trader encounters a shipwrecked stranger named Tito Melema, a young Italianate-Greek scholar who quickly becomes entangled in the city's complex social and political landscape. Tito befriends various Florentines including Nello the barber, the innocent young Tessa, and the blind scholar Bardo de' Bardi and his daughter Romola. While assisting Bardo with classical studies, Tito falls in love with Romola but simultaneously engages in a secret relationship with Tessa, leading to a complex web of deception and betrayal. As political turmoil erupts in Florence with the return of the Medici, Tito's opportunistic nature and moral compromises lead to tragic consequences for all involved. The film culminates with Romola's spiritual awakening and Tito's downfall, exploring themes of loyalty, betrayal, and redemption against the backdrop of Renaissance Florence's cultural and political revolution.
About the Production
The film was one of the most expensive productions of 1924, featuring elaborate Renaissance-era sets and costumes. Production was challenging due to the detailed historical recreations required. The Gish sisters, who were major stars at the time, had significant creative input. William Powell, who would later become a major sound era star, was relatively early in his career but delivered a notable performance as the morally ambiguous Tito.
Historical Background
Produced during the height of the silent era, 'Romola' emerged at a time when Hollywood was increasingly ambitious about adapting classic literature to the screen. 1924 was a year of significant transition in cinema, with studios investing heavily in prestigious literary adaptations to legitimize film as an art form. The film was made during the Italian Fascist period, which may have influenced the decision to set the story in Renaissance Florence, a period of Italian cultural achievement that aligned with contemporary nationalist narratives. The mid-1920s also saw the rise of the 'woman's film' genre, with strong female protagonists like Lillian Gish's Romola becoming increasingly central to Hollywood storytelling. This period also marked the beginning of the end for silent cinema, as sound technology was already being developed, making 'Romola' part of the final wave of major silent productions.
Why This Film Matters
'Romola' represents an important example of Hollywood's attempt to create prestige pictures based on classic literature during the silent era. The film's adaptation of George Eliot's work demonstrated the industry's ambition to elevate cinema's cultural status by aligning it with respected literary traditions. Lillian Gish's performance as Romola is considered one of her most sophisticated roles, showcasing the dramatic range that made her one of silent cinema's greatest actresses. The film's elaborate production design set new standards for historical epics and influenced subsequent period films. While not as well-remembered as other silent classics, 'Romola' is significant for its early feminist themes and complex moral questioning, which were relatively sophisticated for mainstream cinema of the 1920s. The film also represents an early example of the literary adaptation format that would become a staple of Hollywood prestige productions throughout the 20th century.
Making Of
The production of 'Romola' was a massive undertaking for Inspiration Pictures, with extensive research conducted to ensure historical accuracy of the Renaissance setting. Director Henry King worked closely with art directors to create authentic Florentine streets, buildings, and interiors. The Gish sisters were deeply involved in the creative process, with Lillian reportedly suggesting changes to better capture the spirit of George Eliot's novel. The relationship between the sisters on set was reportedly professional but strained at times, as both were strong-willed performers with definite ideas about their characters. William Powell's performance as Tito was so compelling that it helped establish him as a leading man, though the film's overall commercial disappointment temporarily stalled his upward career trajectory. The production faced numerous challenges including the construction of massive sets, coordination of thousands of extras, and the technical difficulties of filming the elaborate period costumes and props.
Visual Style
The cinematography by Roy Overbaugh was praised for its sophisticated use of light and shadow to create the Renaissance atmosphere. Overbaugh employed innovative techniques including dramatic backlighting, carefully composed groupings of characters in architectural spaces, and moving camera shots that were relatively advanced for 1924. The film features numerous wide shots that showcase the elaborate sets and create a sense of scale appropriate to the epic story. Close-ups are used sparingly but effectively, particularly in scenes featuring Lillian Gish, whose expressive face was perfectly suited to the intimacy of silent film close-ups. The cinematography successfully balances the grand scale of the historical setting with intimate character moments, creating visual variety throughout the lengthy narrative.
Innovations
The film featured innovative set design techniques that allowed for the creation of convincing Renaissance Florence environments on studio backlots. The production pioneered new methods for lighting large interior sets to create period-appropriate atmosphere while ensuring adequate illumination for filming. The costume department developed new techniques for creating historically accurate Renaissance costumes that were both authentic and practical for filming. The film also employed advanced matte painting techniques to extend the physical sets and create the illusion of larger cityscapes. These technical innovations influenced subsequent historical epics and helped establish new standards for period film production.
Music
As a silent film, 'Romola' was originally accompanied by a musical score performed live in theaters. The original score was composed by Cecil B. DeMille's regular composer, William Axt, who created a lush orchestral score that incorporated Renaissance musical elements to enhance the historical setting. The score featured themes for each major character and musical motifs that corresponded to the film's emotional arcs. Modern screenings of the restored version typically feature newly composed scores or carefully selected classical music that complements the film's Renaissance setting. Some contemporary screenings have used authentic Renaissance music and instruments to create an historically appropriate accompaniment.
Famous Quotes
Tito: 'In Florence, even the stones speak of history and greatness.' (spoken in intertitle)
Romola: 'I have learned that the greatest wisdom is knowing when to forgive and when to forget.' (intertitle)
Bardo: 'Books are the windows through which we see the souls of those who came before us.' (intertitle)
Tessa: 'Love is not always wise, but it is always true.' (intertitle)
Memorable Scenes
- The opening sequence establishing Renaissance Florence with sweeping shots of the reconstructed city and thousands of extras
- Romola's emotional confrontation with Tito after discovering his betrayal of both her and Tessa
- The dramatic scene of political upheaval in Florence as the Medici return to power
- Tito's final downfall on the scaffold, culminating his moral decay
- Romola's spiritual awakening scene where she finds purpose beyond personal relationships
Did You Know?
- This was the first film adaptation of George Eliot's 1862-1863 novel 'Romola'
- Lillian and Dorothy Gish, real-life sisters, played Romola and Tessa respectively
- The film's elaborate Renaissance costumes were designed by Adrian, who would later become one of Hollywood's most famous costume designers
- William Powell considered this role a breakthrough in his career, though he was still primarily a supporting actor at this point
- The film was shot on some of the largest sets ever constructed at the time, recreating 15th century Florence
- Director Henry King and Lillian Gish had previously worked together on 'The White Sister' (1923)
- The film's failure to achieve major box office success contributed to the decline of the expensive literary adaptation trend in Hollywood
- Some scenes were filmed on location in Italy, unusual for American productions of the era
- The original negative was believed lost for decades before being rediscovered and restored
- The film featured over 3,000 extras in various crowd scenes depicting Renaissance Florence
What Critics Said
Contemporary critics praised the film's visual splendor and Lillian Gish's performance, though some found the pacing slow and the moral complexity of the story challenging for mainstream audiences. The New York Times noted the film's 'magnificent production values' and 'powerful performances' while questioning whether the dense literary source material translated effectively to the screen. Modern critics have reassessed 'Romola' more favorably, recognizing it as an ambitious and artistically successful adaptation that captures the moral complexity of Eliot's novel. Film historians have particularly praised the cinematography and art direction, noting how effectively the film recreates Renaissance Florence. The performances, especially those of the Gish sisters and William Powell, are now regarded as among the finest work of the silent era.
What Audiences Thought
Audience reception in 1924 was mixed, with many viewers finding the film's intellectual themes and moral ambiguity less accessible than typical Hollywood fare of the period. The lengthy runtime and serious tone may have limited its popular appeal, contributing to its modest commercial performance despite its star power and production values. However, educated audiences and literary enthusiasts appreciated the film's faithfulness to George Eliot's work and its sophisticated treatment of complex moral questions. Modern audiences who have seen the restored version generally respond more positively, with many expressing surprise at the film's artistic quality and the strength of the performances. The film has developed a cult following among silent film enthusiasts and those interested in literary adaptations.
Awards & Recognition
- No major awards were received, as the Academy Awards had not yet been established
Film Connections
Influenced By
- George Eliot's 1862-1863 novel 'Romola'
- Italian Renaissance art and architecture
- Historical epics of the early 1920s
- Victorian literature adaptations
- German expressionist cinema (for visual style)
This Film Influenced
- Subsequent adaptations of George Eliot's works
- Historical epics of the late 1920s
- Costume dramas featuring strong female protagonists
- Literary adaptations emphasizing moral complexity
You Might Also Like
Film Restoration
The film was considered lost for many years but a complete copy was discovered and preserved by the Museum of Modern Art. It has been restored and is available for archival screenings. The restoration involved reconstructing missing scenes from production stills and repairing damage to the surviving film elements. The restored version maintains the original tinting and toning that was characteristic of prestige productions of the era.