The Fighting Coward

Plot

Tom Rumford, a young Southern man sent to live with Quaker relatives in Pennsylvania during his childhood, returns to his Kentucky home as a pacifist completely out of step with the local culture of honor and violence. His peaceful demeanor and refusal to engage in duels or fights earns him the nickname 'The Fighting Coward' and makes him the subject of ridicule among the Southern gentlemen who value courage above all else. When his family's honor is challenged and his beloved Mary faces danger from the villainous Blue, Tom must find a way to reconcile his Quaker upbringing with his Southern heritage. The film follows his journey as he navigates between two conflicting value systems while trying to win respect and protect those he loves, ultimately discovering that true courage comes from conviction rather than violence. In a climactic confrontation, Tom proves that his pacifist beliefs don't make him a coward, but rather a man of principle willing to stand up for what's right.

Historical Background

The Fighting Coward was produced in 1924, during a period of significant social and cultural transformation in America. The 1920s, known as the Roaring Twenties, saw the nation grappling with its identity after World War I, with tensions between traditional values and modern sensibilities. The film's exploration of North-South cultural differences resonated with audiences still living with the legacy of the Civil War, which had ended only 59 years earlier. This was also the height of the silent film era, with Hollywood establishing itself as the global center of cinema production. The film's themes of pacifism versus honor were particularly relevant in the post-war period, when many were questioning traditional notions of masculinity and courage. The year 1924 also saw the rise of the second Ku Klux Klan, making the film's nuanced portrayal of Southern culture particularly significant.

Making Of

Director James Cruze was known for his meticulous attention to detail and his ability to extract nuanced performances from his actors. For 'The Fighting Coward,' he worked closely with the cast to develop the cultural contrasts between the Quaker and Southern lifestyles. Ernest Torrence, who stood at 6'4" and had an imposing presence, was cast against type as a character who initially appears threatening but ultimately reveals depth. The production faced challenges in creating authentic period settings, with the art department working extensively to ensure both the Pennsylvania Quaker community and Kentucky plantation settings were historically accurate. Mary Astor, still early in her career, received guidance from Cruze on how to portray a Southern belle with both charm and strength. The film's action sequences were carefully choreographed to highlight the contrast between violence and non-violence, a theme that Cruze emphasized throughout the production.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Karl Brown utilized the visual language of silent cinema to emphasize the cultural contrasts at the heart of the story. The Quaker scenes were shot with softer lighting and more static compositions to convey the peaceful, orderly nature of that community, while the Southern sequences featured more dynamic camera movement and dramatic lighting to reflect the passionate, volatile atmosphere. Brown employed careful framing to highlight the physical presence of Ernest Torrence and the delicate features of Mary Astor, creating visual contrasts that reinforced their character dynamics. The film made effective use of location shooting for outdoor scenes, particularly in sequences depicting the Kentucky landscape, which added authenticity to the production. Interior scenes were carefully lit to create the appropriate mood for each setting, with the Quaker meeting house scenes featuring natural light effects while the plantation interiors used more dramatic chiaroscuro.

Innovations

The Fighting Coward utilized several technical innovations common to mid-1920s Paramount productions. The film employed the latest in lighting technology, including the use of artificial sunlight effects for outdoor scenes shot on studio sets. The production made extensive use of multiple camera setups, allowing for more dynamic editing and visual variety than earlier silent films. The costume department created historically accurate period clothing using advanced dyeing and fabric treatment techniques available in the 1920s. The film's special effects, while minimal, included carefully orchestrated stunt sequences that required precise timing and coordination between performers and camera operators. The movie was shot on standard 35mm film with an aspect ratio of 1.33:1, which was typical for the era, but the cinematography made creative use of this format through careful composition and movement.

Music

As a silent film, The Fighting Coward would have been accompanied by live musical performance during its original theatrical run. The score would have been compiled from various classical pieces and popular songs of the era, selected to match the mood of each scene. The Quaker sequences would likely have featured more subdued, religious-themed music, while the Southern scenes would have incorporated more lively, romantic compositions. Theaters often employed full orchestras for major productions like this Paramount release, with the music carefully synchronized to the on-screen action. The film's climactic scenes would have been accompanied by increasingly dramatic musical selections to heighten the emotional impact. Unfortunately, no original cue sheets or specific musical selections for this film have survived, which was common for many silent productions.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence showing young Tom Rumford being sent away from his Southern home to live with Quaker relatives, establishing the cultural divide that drives the narrative.
• The scene where Tom first returns to his Southern home and is mocked for his pacifist beliefs, highlighting the cultural clash.
• The climactic confrontation where Tom must choose between his Quaker principles and protecting his family's honor, demonstrating his growth as a character.

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised James Cruze's direction and the performances of the lead cast, particularly Ernest Torrence's nuanced portrayal of a character struggling between two value systems. The film was noted for its effective blend of comedy and drama, with reviewers highlighting how it managed to address serious themes while maintaining entertainment value. The New York Times praised the film's 'sincere treatment of a difficult subject' and commended Torrence's performance as 'both powerful and restrained.' Variety noted the film's 'unusual depth for a comedy' and predicted it would find favor with audiences seeking more than simple entertainment. Modern film historians have recognized The Fighting Coward as an example of Cruze's sophisticated approach to genre filmmaking, with some scholars pointing to its subtle critique of Southern honor culture as ahead of its time.

What Audiences Thought

The Fighting Coward performed moderately well at the box office upon its release, appealing to audiences who appreciated James Cruze's reputation for quality filmmaking. Viewers responded positively to the film's humor while also engaging with its more serious themes about courage and conviction. The contrast between Northern and Southern cultures resonated with audiences in both regions, though some Southern viewers found the critique of honor culture somewhat pointed. The film's blend of comedy with thoughtful drama was seen as a refreshing change from more straightforward genre pictures of the era. Mary Astor's performance was particularly popular with male audiences, while Ernest Torrence's character arc was praised by viewers who appreciated stories of personal growth and moral courage.

You Might Also Like