The Hunchback of Notre Dame

Plot

In 15th century Paris, the deformed bell-ringer Quasimodo (Charles Laughton) lives in isolation within the towering Notre Dame Cathedral, finding solace only among his beloved bells. When the beautiful Romani dancer Esmeralda captures the attention of the city, Chief Justice Frollo (Cedric Hardwicke) becomes consumed by lust and obsession, believing her to be a witch who has cast a spell upon him. Frollo manipulates the loyal Quasimodo into participating in his sinister plans to possess Esmeralda, leading to a dramatic confrontation during the Festival of Fools where Quasimodo is publicly humiliated. As Esmeralda seeks refuge in the cathedral, claiming sanctuary, the story unfolds into a tragic tale of unrequited love, prejudice, and the conflict between religious duty and human desire. The film culminates in a dramatic siege of Notre Dame as the citizens of Paris, stirred by Frollo's accusations, attempt to capture Esmeralda, forcing Quasimodo to choose between his loyalty to his master and his growing compassion for the young woman.

Historical Background

Released at the end of 1939, often considered Hollywood's greatest year, 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame' emerged during a period of significant global turmoil. As Europe descended into World War II, Hollywood studios were producing increasingly sophisticated and ambitious films that offered audiences both escape and moral reflection. The film's themes of prejudice, social injustice, and the persecution of minorities resonated strongly with contemporary audiences aware of the growing persecution in Europe. The production also reflected Hollywood's shift toward more adult, complex narratives during this period, as studios competed for increasingly sophisticated audiences. The film's emphasis on Gothic horror and psychological complexity also mirrored the growing influence of European film traditions in Hollywood, particularly German Expressionism, which had been brought to America by directors fleeing the Nazi regime. The choice to adapt Victor Hugo's classic novel also reflected Hollywood's increasing interest in literary adaptations that could lend cultural prestige to their productions.

Making Of

The production of 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame' was one of RKO's most ambitious undertakings of 1939. The film faced numerous challenges, including the construction of the massive Notre Dame set, which required extensive research and architectural drawings to ensure historical accuracy. Charles Laughton's transformation into Quasimodo was a daily ordeal involving hours of makeup application, including a heavy rubber hump, facial prosthetics, and contact lenses that gave his eyes their distinctive appearance. The actor reportedly studied the novel extensively and worked closely with director William Dieterle to develop a portrayal that emphasized Quasimodo's humanity rather than just his physical deformity. The famous bell-ringing sequences were particularly challenging to film, requiring special rigging and safety measures. The production also faced censorship issues from the Hays Code, which required modifications to some of the novel's more controversial elements, particularly concerning Frollo's obsession and the film's religious themes. Despite these challenges, the film's production team managed to create what many consider one of the most visually impressive Gothic films of Hollywood's golden age.

Visual Style

The film's cinematography, handled by Joseph H. August, employed dramatic lighting and camera techniques to enhance the Gothic atmosphere. August used extensive low-key lighting and deep shadows to create a sense of mystery and foreboding, particularly in the cathedral sequences. The camera work emphasized the verticality of the cathedral setting, with many shots looking up from below or down from above to reinforce the power dynamics between characters. The film also made innovative use of crane shots to capture the scale of the sets and the dramatic bell-ringing sequences. August employed German Expressionist techniques, particularly in the use of distorted camera angles and dramatic lighting to reflect Quasimodo's psychological state. The black and white photography actually enhanced the Gothic mood, with the high contrast between light and shadow creating a more haunting atmosphere than color might have achieved. The cinematography was particularly praised for its ability to make the studio sets feel authentic and imposing.

Innovations

The film featured several notable technical achievements for its time, particularly in set construction and makeup effects. The Notre Dame cathedral set was one of the largest ever built at RKO, featuring working bells and detailed architectural elements that allowed for dynamic camera movement. The makeup effects created for Charles Laughton's transformation into Quasimodo were groundbreaking, using advanced prosthetic techniques that allowed for expressive facial movement despite the heavy appliances. The film also employed innovative sound recording techniques to capture the complex audio of the bell sequences, using multiple microphones to blend the diegetic bell sounds with the musical score. The production utilized special rigging systems for the bell-ringing scenes that allowed Laughton to perform his own stunts safely. The film's special effects, while modest by modern standards, were effective in creating the illusion of medieval Paris, using matte paintings and forced perspective to extend the sets beyond their physical boundaries.

Music

The musical score was composed by Alfred Newman, one of Hollywood's most prolific and respected composers. Newman created a sweeping, romantic score that incorporated elements of medieval and Renaissance music to enhance the film's historical setting. The score featured prominent use of church bells as both diegetic and non-diegetic elements, with the bells serving as a musical motif representing Quasimodo's connection to the cathedral. Newman's music emphasized the tragic elements of the story while providing emotional support for the romantic scenes. The score also included original songs that reflected the Romani culture of Esmeralda's character. Newman's work on the film was nominated for an Academy Award, reflecting the critical recognition of his contribution to the film's atmosphere. The soundtrack was particularly effective in the bell-ringing sequences, where Newman combined actual bell sounds with orchestral accompaniment to create powerful audio-visual moments.

Memorable Scenes

• The Festival of Fools scene where Quasimodo is crowned King of Fools and then brutally humiliated by the crowd, showcasing the cruelty of society toward those who are different.
• The bell-ringing sequences where Quasimodo finds joy and freedom among the massive cathedral bells, creating powerful visual and auditory moments.
• The climactic siege of Notre Dame where Quasimodo defends the cathedral and Esmeralda from the angry mob, demonstrating his transformation from outcast to hero.
• The opening sequence establishing the grandeur of medieval Paris and the imposing presence of Notre Dame Cathedral.

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised Charles Laughton's performance as Quasimodo, with many considering it one of his finest achievements. The New York Times hailed Laughton's portrayal as 'a triumph of acting genius' and praised the film's visual spectacle. Variety noted that the production values were 'second to none' and particularly commended the cathedral set's impressive scale. However, some critics felt the film's pacing was uneven and that the romantic elements were underdeveloped compared to the horror aspects. Modern critics have reassessed the film more favorably, with many considering it a high point of 1930s Gothic cinema and one of the best adaptations of Hugo's novel. The film is often cited for its atmospheric cinematography and Laughton's nuanced performance, which successfully balances pathos and horror. Recent retrospectives have highlighted the film's technical achievements and its influence on subsequent horror and period films.

What Audiences Thought

The film performed moderately well at the box office, though it was overshadowed by the massive success of other 1939 releases like 'Gone with the Wind' and 'The Wizard of Oz.' Audiences responded particularly strongly to Laughton's performance, which became one of the most discussed aspects of the film. Many viewers were reportedly moved by Quasimodo's tragic character, while others were impressed by the film's visual spectacle and dramatic intensity. The film developed a cult following over the years, particularly among horror film enthusiasts and fans of classic Hollywood cinema. Modern audiences have discovered the film through television broadcasts and home video releases, with many praising its atmospheric qualities and Laughton's iconic performance. The film has maintained a steady reputation among classic film fans as one of the definitive adaptations of Hugo's novel and a high point of 1930s Hollywood production values.

You Might Also Like