The Renunciation

Plot

In a rugged mining camp, two prospectors develop a bitter rivalry over the affections of a local woman. The tension escalates to the point where one miner, consumed by jealousy, decides to murder his rival while he sleeps. Armed with a weapon, he creeps toward the sleeping man's tent, but at the crucial moment, the woman intervenes by revealing she is engaged to a sophisticated city man who has just arrived. The would-be murderer, realizing his romantic hopes were futile from the beginning, abandons his violent intentions in a moment of emotional defeat and moral clarity.

Historical Background

1909 was a pivotal year in American cinema, marking the transition from short novelty films to more sophisticated narrative storytelling. D.W. Griffith, then a relatively unknown director at Biograph, was in the process of revolutionizing film language through innovations in cross-cutting, close-ups, and narrative structure. The film industry was centered in New York and New Jersey, with Hollywood still years away from becoming the capital of cinema. This period saw the rise of the star system, though actors were still not credited by name in most films. The Western genre was already popular, reflecting America's ongoing fascination with frontier mythology and the recent closing of the frontier. Film censorship was minimal but becoming a concern as movies grew more popular and sophisticated.

Making Of

The production of 'The Renunciation' followed the efficient Biograph system of the era, where films were shot quickly on minimal budgets. Griffith was developing his directorial style during this period, experimenting with camera placement, editing rhythms, and actor performance. Mary Pickford, though young, was already showing the naturalistic acting style that would make her famous. The mining camp setting was typical of Griffith's early work, which often explored themes of civilization versus wilderness. The film was likely shot in one or two days with a small crew, using natural lighting and simple sets. Griffith was known for his meticulous attention to detail even in these early shorts, often rehearsing scenes multiple times to achieve the desired emotional impact.

Visual Style

The cinematography of 'The Renunciation' reflects the technical limitations and emerging techniques of 1909. Shot by Biograph's regular cinematographers, likely G.W. Bitzer or Arthur Marvin, the film uses static camera positions typical of the period, with the camera positioned to capture the entire action in a wide shot. The lighting would have been natural or basic studio lighting, creating high contrast images characteristic of early film. The composition follows theatrical conventions, with actors arranged across the frame for maximum clarity. The film may include some camera movement, as Griffith was beginning to experiment with techniques like panning to follow action. The visual style emphasizes clarity and narrative comprehension over artistic flourish, reflecting the primary goal of early narrative cinema to tell stories clearly to audiences still learning to read the language of film.

Innovations

While 'The Renunciation' does not represent a major technical breakthrough, it was part of Griffith's rapid development of film language during his Biograph period. The film likely demonstrates Griffith's growing mastery of continuity editing, ensuring clear spatial and temporal relationships between shots. The use of parallel action, showing the would-be murderer approaching while the victim sleeps, reflects Griffith's experiments with building suspense through editing. The film was shot on Biograph's proprietary film stock and processed in their laboratories, representing the vertically integrated production system of the era. At 6 minutes, the film represents the increasing length of narrative films as audiences became more sophisticated in their understanding of cinematic storytelling. The lighting and exposure techniques used would have been advanced for the period, demonstrating Biograph's technical leadership in the early film industry.

Music

As a silent film, 'The Renunciation' would have been accompanied by live music during theatrical presentations. The specific musical score is not documented, as was typical for films of this era. The accompaniment would have been provided by whatever musicians were available at each venue, ranging from a single pianist in small theaters to full orchestras in larger venues. The music would likely have included popular songs of the period, classical pieces, and improvised accompaniment timed to match the on-screen action. For dramatic moments like the attempted murder scene, the music would have become more intense and suspenseful, while the resolution would have been accompanied by more peaceful, romantic themes. The quality and style of musical accompaniment varied widely depending on the venue and the skill of the musicians.

Memorable Scenes

• The tense sequence where the jealous miner approaches his sleeping rival with weapon in hand, creating suspense through the looming threat of violence that is ultimately averted by the woman's timely intervention

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception for 'The Renunciation' is difficult to trace, as film criticism was still in its infancy in 1909 and most reviews focused on the novelty of moving pictures rather than artistic merit. The film was likely reviewed briefly in trade publications like The Moving Picture World, which covered Biograph releases regularly. Modern critics and film historians view the film primarily as a historical artifact, valuable for what it reveals about Griffith's early development and the state of American cinema in 1909. It is generally considered a competent but unremarkable example of Griffith's Biograph period, lacking the technical innovations and emotional depth of his more celebrated works from the same era like 'A Corner in Wheat' or 'The Lonely Villa'.

What Audiences Thought

Audience reception in 1909 would have been positive for most Biograph releases, as the novelty of cinema itself was still a major draw. The simple moral tale of jealousy and renunciation would have been easily understood and appreciated by contemporary audiences. The presence of Mary Pickford, though not yet a star, would have been noted by regular filmgoers who were beginning to recognize favorite actors despite the lack of screen credits. The Western setting and dramatic conflict would have provided the excitement and entertainment value that early cinema audiences sought. Like most films of this era, it would have been shown as part of a varied program, with its impact measured by the overall quality of the presentation rather than as an individual work.

You Might Also Like