Three Women

Plot

In Ernst Lubitsch's sophisticated silent drama, a frivolous middle-aged socialite named Mrs. Hanney (Pauline Frederick) lives a carefree life of luxury and romance until her daughter Jean (May McAvoy) unexpectedly comes to live with her. The daughter's arrival disrupts the mother's lifestyle, particularly when Mrs. Hanney's conniving paramour (Lew Cody) abandons her to pursue the younger, more innocent Jean. Meanwhile, Jean's earnest young boyfriend (Conrad Nagel) is left heartbroken by this betrayal. The film explores the complex dynamics between the three women as they navigate love, jealousy, and maternal responsibility in a society that judges them harshly for their romantic choices.

Historical Background

Three Women was produced during a transformative period in Hollywood history when European directors were bringing new techniques and sensibilities to American cinema. 1924 was the height of the silent film era, just before the transition to sound would revolutionize the industry. The film emerged during the Jazz Age, a time of changing social mores and increasing frankness about sexuality and relationships in popular culture. The movie reflected contemporary anxieties about the changing roles of women in society and the generational conflicts that arose as younger women embraced more modern attitudes toward love and independence. Ernst Lubitsch's work during this period helped establish Warner Bros. as a major competitor to established studios like MGM and Paramount.

Making Of

Ernst Lubitsch brought his distinctive European sensibility to this American production, carefully crafting the performances to achieve his characteristic blend of sophistication and emotional depth. The director worked closely with his three leading actresses to create believable mother-daughter dynamics, with Pauline Frederick drawing on her own life experience to portray the aging socialite. May McAvoy, who was at the height of her career in 1924, underwent extensive preparation to play the innocent daughter caught in a romantic triangle. The production faced challenges in depicting the controversial themes without offending the moral standards of the time, requiring Lubitsch to use subtle visual storytelling rather than explicit content. The film's elaborate costumes and sets were designed to emphasize the contrast between the characters' social status and their emotional vulnerability.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Charles Van Enger employed the soft focus techniques popular in 1924 to create a romantic, dreamlike atmosphere. The film used sophisticated lighting to emphasize the emotional states of the characters, with warmer tones for romantic scenes and cooler lighting for moments of conflict. Van Enger's camera work included subtle tracking shots that followed the characters through elaborate sets, creating a sense of fluid motion that enhanced the film's sophisticated tone. The visual style incorporated elements of German Expressionism that Lubitsch brought from his European career, particularly in the use of shadows and dramatic compositions.

Innovations

The film demonstrated advanced editing techniques for its time, using cross-cutting effectively to build tension between the competing romantic storylines. The production utilized Warner Bros.' improved lighting equipment to create more nuanced visual effects than were common in 1924. The movie's intertitles were particularly sophisticated, incorporating subtle humor and psychological insight that complemented the visual storytelling. The film's makeup techniques, especially in aging Pauline Frederick appropriately for her role, were considered innovative for the period.

Music

As a silent film, Three Women would have been accompanied by live musical performances in theaters. The original score was likely composed by a studio musician at Warner Bros. and would have included popular songs of the era along with classical pieces adapted to fit the film's emotional tone. The music would have emphasized the film's dramatic moments and romantic themes, with different leitmotifs for each of the three main characters. Modern screenings of the film typically feature newly composed scores or carefully selected period music.

Memorable Scenes

• The dramatic confrontation scene where the mother discovers her lover's betrayal with her daughter
• The elegant society ball sequence showcasing the film's elaborate production design
• The emotional climax where the three women must confront the consequences of their choices

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised Three Women for its sophisticated handling of delicate subject matter and Lubitsch's directorial skill. The New York Times noted the film's 'unusual depth and psychological interest' while Variety appreciated its 'adult treatment of adult problems.' Critics particularly praised Pauline Frederick's performance as the aging socialite, with many considering it one of her finest roles. Modern film historians view the movie as an important example of Lubitsch's early American work, demonstrating his developing mastery of visual storytelling and character development. The film is often cited as a precursor to the more famous Lubitsch touch comedies of the 1930s.

What Audiences Thought

The film received moderate commercial success upon its release, appealing primarily to adult audiences who appreciated its sophisticated themes. Contemporary viewers were drawn to the film's glamorous depiction of high society life and its dramatic exploration of romantic entanglements. The movie's controversial subject matter generated discussion among moviegoers, with some finding it refreshingly honest while others considered it daring. The performances of the three leading actresses were particularly well-received by audiences, with May McAvoy's portrayal of the innocent daughter earning special praise for its sincerity and emotional depth.

You Might Also Like