Lonesome

Plot

Jim and Mary are two lonely, working-class people living in New York City who feel isolated despite being surrounded by millions. After a chance encounter on a crowded streetcar, they decide to spend a day together at Coney Island amusement park, where they experience the joy and excitement of each other's company. As they ride roller coasters, dance, and share intimate moments, they fall deeply in love and plan to meet again. However, tragedy strikes when they become separated in the massive crowds after a fire drill at the park. Both return to their lonely lives, devastated by the loss, until fate intervenes in an unexpected way that tests whether their brief connection can overcome the overwhelming anonymity of the big city.

Historical Background

Lonesome was produced during a pivotal moment in American cultural and cinematic history. 1928 marked the height of the Roaring Twenties, a period of unprecedented prosperity, urbanization, and social change. The film captured the essence of modern urban life, reflecting the growing anonymity and alienation experienced by many Americans who had migrated to cities. This was also the year when the film industry was undergoing its most dramatic technological revolution - the transition to sound. The stock market crash of 1929 would occur just a year after the film's release, ending the era of prosperity depicted in the movie. The film's focus on working-class characters and their struggles reflected the growing awareness of social issues that would characterize the Depression era. The amusement park setting was particularly significant, as Coney Island represented both the excitement and the fleeting nature of modern entertainment and pleasure.

Making Of

The production of Lonesome occurred during one of the most turbulent periods in Hollywood history - the transition from silent films to talkies. Universal Pictures initially greenlit the project as a silent film, but as production progressed, the success of The Jazz Singer (1927) caused studio executives to panic and demand sound elements. This led to the unique hybrid nature of the film, with most of the story told silently but three key sequences featuring synchronized dialogue and sound effects. Director Pál Fejös, who had extensive experience in European cinema, fought to maintain his artistic vision while accommodating the new technology. The amusement park sequences were particularly challenging, requiring the coordination of hundreds of extras, operating rides, and camera movement. The film's famous split-screen sequence, showing Jim and Mary separately preparing for their date, required careful timing and multiple camera setups. The cast had to undergo voice tests for the sound sequences, and some performers were nearly replaced when their voices didn't match their silent screen personas.

Visual Style

The cinematography of Lonesome, primarily by Gilbert Warrenton, was revolutionary for its time and remains impressive today. The film employs innovative techniques including split screens to show simultaneous action, superimpositions to convey psychological states, and dynamic camera movements that enhance the emotional impact of scenes. The Coney Island sequences feature spectacular tracking shots and crane movements that capture the excitement and chaos of the amusement park. The visual contrast between the lonely, cramped apartments of the protagonists and the expansive, overwhelming cityscape effectively communicates the film's themes of isolation in urban environments. The lighting design uses shadow and light to create mood and emphasize emotional moments, particularly in the intimate scenes between the leads. The film's visual style combines German Expressionist influences with American realism, creating a unique aesthetic that serves the story perfectly.

Innovations

Lonesome showcased several significant technical achievements that were ahead of their time. The film's innovative use of split screens to show simultaneous action was groundbreaking, requiring precise timing and multiple camera setups. The superimposition effects used to convey the characters' thoughts and emotions were technically sophisticated for 1928. The film successfully integrated sound elements while maintaining the visual storytelling techniques of silent cinema, demonstrating how the two mediums could coexist. The camera work in the Coney Island sequences, including complex tracking shots and crane movements, pushed the boundaries of what was technically possible at the time. The film's editing, particularly in the montage sequences, was innovative in its use of rhythm and visual storytelling. The preservation of the film's visual quality during the restoration process also represents a technical achievement, allowing modern audiences to appreciate the film's original artistic vision.

Music

Lonesome featured an innovative soundtrack that combined traditional silent film accompaniment with new synchronized sound elements. The film included a synchronized musical score by Joseph Cherniavsky, along with three sequences featuring synchronized dialogue and sound effects. The sound sequences were carefully integrated into the narrative, appearing at key emotional moments in the story. The musical score incorporated popular songs of the era as well as original compositions that enhanced the film's emotional impact. The transition between silent and sound sequences was handled skillfully, maintaining the film's artistic coherence. The soundtrack elements were recorded using the Movietone sound-on-film system, which Universal Pictures had adopted for its sound productions. The limited use of dialogue in the sound sequences demonstrated early awareness of how to use sound artistically rather than merely as a novelty.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence showing Jim and Mary's separate morning routines in split screen
• The magical moment on the roller coaster where they first truly connect
• The dance sequence at Coney Island with its swirling camera movements
• The devastating separation scene during the fire drill chaos
• The final reunion sequence with its emotional resolution and visual poetry

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised Lonesome for its visual beauty and emotional sincerity. The New York Times called it 'a tender and beautiful picture of modern life,' while Variety noted its 'artistic merit and human appeal.' Critics particularly praised the performances of Glenn Tryon and Barbara Kent, as well as Fejös' sensitive direction. The film's technical innovations, especially the split-screen sequences, were widely admired. In retrospect, modern critics have elevated the film's status even further. The Village Voice called it 'one of the great American films of the silent era,' and the Criterion Collection described it as 'a visually dazzling and emotionally resonant masterpiece.' Film scholars now consider it one of the most important films of the late silent period, noting its sophisticated narrative techniques and its successful navigation of the silent-to-sound transition.

What Audiences Thought

Original audiences responded positively to Lonesome, particularly to its relatable story of lonely urban dwellers finding love. The film's emotional core resonated with viewers who had experienced similar feelings of isolation in big cities. The Coney Island sequences were especially popular, offering audiences spectacular entertainment while advancing the story. When the film was rediscovered and restored in the 1970s, it found new appreciation among cinephiles and film students who recognized its artistic merits. Modern audiences at revival screenings have responded enthusiastically to the film's visual poetry and emotional power, often expressing surprise at its sophistication and contemporary relevance. The film's availability on home video and streaming platforms has introduced it to new generations, maintaining its status as a beloved classic of silent cinema.

You Might Also Like