Sherlock Holmes

Plot

When young Alice Faulkner comes into possession of compromising letters that could cause a scandal involving the royal family, she becomes the target of unscrupulous criminals who hold her against her will in an attempt to retrieve the documents. Sherlock Holmes, aided by his faithful companion Dr. Watson, takes on the case and must navigate a complex web of deception, blackmail, and murder to protect Alice and prevent the scandal from erupting. As Holmes investigates, he discovers that the criminals are part of a larger conspiracy and must use his legendary deductive reasoning to outsmart his adversaries. The case takes Holmes through the dark underbelly of London society, culminating in a dramatic confrontation where he must save Alice and recover the letters before they can be used to destroy reputations. Holmes ultimately succeeds in his mission, bringing the criminals to justice while maintaining his characteristic cool demeanor and intellectual superiority.

Historical Background

The year 1916 was a pivotal time in cinema history, occurring during the transition from short films to feature-length productions. World War I was raging in Europe, though the United States had not yet entered the conflict. This period saw the rise of the star system in Hollywood, with actors like William Gillette bringing their established stage personas to the new medium of film. The film industry was consolidating, with studios like Essanay competing for audiences with increasingly sophisticated productions. The mystery genre was gaining popularity in both literature and film, with Sherlock Holmes being one of the most recognizable fictional characters of the era. The film's production occurred during a time when cinema was establishing itself as a legitimate art form, moving away from its origins as a novelty attraction. The fact that a literary adaptation was given feature-length treatment demonstrates the growing cultural significance of film in American society.

Making Of

The production of 'Sherlock Holmes' was a significant undertaking for the Essanay Film Manufacturing Company, which was one of the major studios of the silent era. William Gillette, who had essentially created the modern image of Sherlock Holmes through his stage performances, was brought in specifically to recreate his famous role for the camera. The adaptation process involved condensing Gillette's successful stage play into a feature film format, which required careful consideration of how to translate theatrical techniques to the cinematic medium. Director Arthur Berthelet worked closely with Gillette to ensure that the actor's distinctive interpretation of Holmes was preserved on film. The production utilized the relatively new technology of feature-length filmmaking, which was still evolving in 1916. The cast and crew faced the challenge of creating a convincing mystery without the benefit of sound, relying entirely on visual storytelling techniques. The film's rediscovery revealed that it was remarkably well-preserved, with clear images that allowed modern audiences to appreciate the sophisticated cinematography and production values of the era.

Visual Style

The cinematography of 'Sherlock Holmes' was handled by George W. Hill and demonstrates the sophisticated visual techniques emerging in feature films of the mid-1910s. The film employs dramatic lighting to create atmosphere, particularly in scenes involving the criminal elements and the mystery aspects of the plot. Camera movement is used sparingly but effectively, with careful composition of shots to convey character relationships and plot developments. The film makes good use of location shooting in Chicago, creating a convincing Victorian London atmosphere through set design and framing. Close-ups are used strategically to emphasize Holmes's deductive process and to highlight key emotional moments. The cinematography successfully translates the theatrical elements of Gillette's stage play into cinematic language, using visual techniques to convey what dialogue would communicate in later sound films. The restored print reveals a high level of technical craftsmanship, with clear images that showcase the film's visual sophistication.

Innovations

While 'Sherlock Holmes' does not feature revolutionary technical innovations, it demonstrates the sophisticated filmmaking techniques that had evolved by the mid-1910s. The film's use of feature-length storytelling was still relatively new in 1916, requiring careful pacing and narrative structure to maintain audience engagement over its 116-minute runtime. The production employed advanced lighting techniques for the period, creating atmospheric effects that enhanced the mystery elements of the story. The film's editing shows a mature understanding of cinematic continuity, with smooth transitions between scenes and effective use of cross-cutting to build suspense. The set design and art direction successfully created convincing Victorian London environments despite being filmed in Chicago. The preservation and restoration of the film using modern digital techniques has itself become a technical achievement, allowing contemporary audiences to experience the film with a clarity that would have been impossible in 1916.

Music

As a silent film, 'Sherlock Holmes' was originally accompanied by live musical performances during theatrical screenings. The specific musical scores used in 1916 are not documented, but it was common for theaters to provide appropriate musical accompaniment that matched the mood and action of the film. For the 2015 restoration premiere, the San Francisco Silent Film Festival commissioned a new score from composer Stephen Horne, which was performed live by the Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra. The modern score incorporates period-appropriate musical styles while enhancing the film's mystery elements and dramatic moments. The restoration has also been screened with various other musical accompaniments, demonstrating how silent films can be reinterpreted through different musical approaches. The absence of recorded sound means that each screening can offer a unique experience depending on the musical interpretation.

Memorable Scenes

• The dramatic confrontation between Holmes and the criminal mastermind in the climactic scene, where Holmes reveals how he deduced the entire conspiracy through careful observation and logical reasoning
• The moment when Holmes first examines the mysterious letters that form the crux of the plot, using his magnifying glass and keen observational skills to uncover hidden clues
• The tense sequence where Holmes and Watson rescue Alice Faulkner from her captors, showcasing Holmes's physical courage as well as his intellectual prowess

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews of the 1916 'Sherlock Holmes' were generally positive, with critics praising William Gillette's authoritative performance and the film's faithful adaptation of his successful stage play. The Moving Picture World noted that 'Gillette's Holmes is every bit as impressive on screen as on stage,' while Variety commented on the film's 'suspenseful atmosphere and clever plot construction.' Modern critics, after the film's restoration, have hailed it as a significant discovery in film history. The New York Times called it 'a fascinating time capsule of early detective cinema,' and film historian Jeffrey Vance described it as 'a crucial missing piece in the history of Sherlock Holmes on screen.' Critics have particularly noted the film's sophisticated cinematography and Gillette's nuanced performance, which avoids the exaggerated acting common in many silent films. The restoration has allowed contemporary viewers to appreciate the film's artistic merits and historical importance.

What Audiences Thought

The 1916 'Sherlock Holmes' was reportedly successful with audiences of its time, particularly those who were already fans of Gillette's stage performances. Contemporary accounts suggest that theaters showing the film attracted large crowds of mystery enthusiasts and Holmes devotees. The film's rediscovery and restoration have generated significant excitement among modern audiences, with screenings at film festivals selling out quickly. Modern viewers have expressed surprise at the film's sophistication and entertainment value, with many noting that it holds up remarkably well for a century-old film. The combination of Gillette's charismatic performance and the engaging mystery has proven appealing to contemporary audiences, demonstrating the timeless appeal of both the character and the story. Online discussions among classic film enthusiasts have been overwhelmingly positive, with many calling for wider distribution of the restored version.

You Might Also Like