The Avenging Conscience

Plot

A young man, deeply in love with his cousin, finds his romance thwarted by his tyrannical uncle who forbids their relationship. Consumed by dark thoughts influenced by Edgar Allan Poe's writings, the nephew becomes convinced that murder is a natural solution to his problems. He kills his uncle and buries the body beneath the floorboards of their home, but his conscience immediately begins to torment him. As paranoia sets in, he experiences vivid hallucinations and nightmarish visions, including ghostly appearances and the sound of his uncle's beating heart growing louder. The psychological torment becomes unbearable, driving him to the brink of madness as police investigation closes in, ultimately leading to his confession and mental breakdown.

Historical Background

1914 was a pivotal year in world history and cinema. World War I began in Europe, though the United States would not enter until 1917. In the film world, 1914 marked the transition from short films to feature-length pictures as the industry standard. D.W. Griffith was at the forefront of this evolution, having already established himself as America's most innovative director. The film industry was rapidly consolidating in Hollywood, with California becoming the center of American film production. This period saw the emergence of more sophisticated storytelling techniques, moving away from the simple theatrical presentations of earlier cinema. 'The Avenging Conscience' was part of Griffith's experimentation with longer narratives and more complex psychological themes, paving the way for his later masterpieces like 'The Birth of a Nation' (1915) and 'Intolerance' (1916). The film also reflected the growing influence of literature on cinema, with adaptations of classic works becoming increasingly common as filmmakers sought to legitimize the new medium.

Making Of

The production of 'The Avenging Conscience' represented a significant artistic leap for D.W. Griffith as he moved from the short films that dominated the era to more complex feature-length storytelling. Griffith was deeply influenced by European art films and sought to elevate American cinema beyond simple melodramas. The film's psychological horror elements required innovative visual techniques, including sophisticated use of double exposure to create the ghostly visions that haunt the protagonist. Griffith worked closely with cinematographer Billy Bitzer to develop these effects, pushing the technical boundaries of what was possible in 1914. The casting of Henry B. Walthall was particularly inspired, as his expressive face could convey the mounting psychological torment without dialogue. The production faced challenges from studio executives who were concerned that the dark subject matter might alienate audiences, but Griffith persisted, believing in the artistic merit of exploring psychological themes. The film's score, though not recorded, was carefully planned with detailed musical cues for live accompaniment during screenings, including specific instructions for the famous beating heart sequence.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Billy Bitzer was groundbreaking for its time, featuring innovative techniques that would influence cinema for decades. Bitzer employed sophisticated double exposure methods to create the ghostly hallucinations that haunt the protagonist, a technique that was still experimental in 1914. The film uses dramatic lighting contrasts to emphasize the psychological states of the characters, with deep shadows representing the protagonist's descent into madness. Camera movement was more dynamic than typical of the period, with Bitzer using subtle tracking shots to follow characters through their psychological journey. The burial scene beneath the floorboards featured innovative low-angle shots that created a sense of claustrophobia and guilt. Bitzer also experimented with focus changes to represent shifts in consciousness, blurring and sharpening the image to reflect the protagonist's mental state. The film's visual style influenced the later German Expressionist movement with its emphasis on psychological states through visual means. The cinematography helped establish many visual conventions that would become standard in psychological horror films.

Innovations

The film featured several technical innovations that were ahead of their time. The double exposure techniques used to create the ghostly visions were particularly sophisticated, requiring precise timing and multiple exposures on the same film strip. Griffith and his team developed new methods for creating convincing hallucination sequences that would influence visual effects in cinema for decades. The film's editing was more complex than typical of the period, using cross-cutting between reality and hallucination to represent the protagonist's psychological state. The production also experimented with camera angles and movement to create psychological impact, including unusual low angles for the burial scene. The film's pacing was innovative, building tension gradually through visual means rather than relying on intertitles. Special effects were used to create supernatural elements, including floating objects and ghostly apparitions. The production design was carefully planned to reflect the psychological themes, with sets becoming increasingly distorted as the protagonist's madness progresses. These technical achievements helped establish new possibilities for psychological storytelling in cinema.

Music

As a silent film, 'The Avenging Conscience' was originally accompanied by live musical performance during screenings. Griffith provided detailed musical cues in the film's documentation, specifying particular pieces for different scenes to enhance the psychological impact. The most famous musical element was the use of increasingly loud percussion to represent the beating heart that haunts the protagonist, a technique that required skilled musicians to execute effectively. Many theaters used classical pieces, particularly works by composers known for their dramatic intensity, such as Wagner and Liszt. Some larger theaters commissioned original scores from resident composers. The musical accompaniment was crucial to the film's horror elements, with sudden changes in tempo and volume used to create jump scares and psychological tension. Modern restorations have been scored by contemporary composers who attempt to recreate the intended emotional impact while using modern musical resources. The original musical approach demonstrated how early filmmakers used sound to enhance psychological horror, a tradition that would continue into the sound era.

Memorable Scenes

• The murder sequence where the nephew kills his uncle, shot with dramatic shadows and minimal violence but maximum psychological impact
• The burial beneath the floorboards scene, using innovative camera angles to create claustrophobia and guilt
• The hallucination sequences featuring ghostly apparitions created through double exposure techniques
• The famous beating heart scene where the protagonist hears increasingly loud heartbeats driving him to madness
• The final confession scene where the psychological torment becomes unbearable and the protagonist breaks down completely

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised the film's artistic ambitions and technical innovations. The New York Dramatic Mirror called it 'a masterpiece of psychological drama' and noted Griffith's 'remarkable ability to visualize mental states.' Variety praised the performances, particularly Henry B. Walthall's portrayal of mounting madness. Some critics, however, found the film's intensity disturbing, with The Moving Picture World suggesting it was 'perhaps too morbid for general audiences.' Modern critics have reevaluated the film as an important precursor to psychological horror cinema. Film historian Kevin Brownlow has called it 'remarkably ahead of its time in its exploration of guilt and madness.' The film is now recognized as a significant step in Griffith's artistic development and an important early example of American horror cinema. Many contemporary scholars note how the film's visual techniques and psychological depth influenced later generations of horror filmmakers, from German Expressionism to modern psychological thrillers.

What Audiences Thought

Initial audience reactions to 'The Avenging Conscience' were mixed but generally positive, with many viewers impressed by the film's psychological intensity and visual innovations. The film performed well in major urban markets where audiences were more accustomed to sophisticated entertainment. Some viewers found the subject matter disturbing, particularly the murder and subsequent psychological torment, which was unusual for the period. The film's success helped demonstrate that audiences were ready for more complex, adult themes in motion pictures. In smaller towns and more conservative markets, the film sometimes faced resistance from local censors who objected to its dark themes. Despite these challenges, the film developed a reputation as a 'thinking person's picture' and attracted audiences interested in more artistic cinema. Over time, it gained a cult following among early cinema enthusiasts who appreciated its psychological depth and technical achievements. Modern audiences viewing restored versions often express surprise at how sophisticated and psychologically complex a 1914 film could be.

You Might Also Like