The Battle

Plot

The Battle (1911) follows Union soldiers as they march off to war amid enthusiastic crowds and patriotic fervor. When the tide of battle turns against the Union forces, one young soldier succumbs to fear and deserts, seeking refuge at his sweetheart's home. Tormented by his cowardice and the shame of his actions, he watches from hiding as his comrades face certain death. In a moment of redemption, the deserter finds his courage and undertakes a perilous journey behind enemy lines to summon reinforcements for his trapped regiment. The film culminates in a dramatic rescue as Union forces arrive to save the surrounded soldiers, with the once-cowardly hero having proven his valor through selfless action.

Historical Background

The Battle was produced in 1911, during a period of significant transformation in American cinema and society. The film industry was transitioning from novelty to art form, with directors like D.W. Griffith establishing narrative techniques that would define classical Hollywood cinema. The Civil War, having ended only 46 years earlier, remained a living memory for many Americans, and films about the conflict were popular for their combination of recent historical relevance and dramatic potential. 1911 was also a year of increasing tensions in American race relations, with Jim Crow laws firmly established in the South and growing debate about Civil War memory and interpretation. The film's production coincided with the 50th anniversary commemorations of the war's beginning, creating renewed public interest in Civil War narratives. Biograph Company, where Griffith worked, was one of the leading American film studios, competing with European filmmakers who were already producing more sophisticated narrative films.

Making Of

The Battle was produced during a pivotal period in Griffith's career when he was developing his cinematic language and pioneering narrative techniques. Working with limited resources and tight schedules typical of Biograph productions, Griffith managed to create surprisingly sophisticated battle sequences using a combination of carefully staged action, strategic camera placement, and editing techniques that were innovative for the time. The production faced challenges including unpredictable weather during outdoor filming and the need to coordinate large groups of extras for the battle scenes. Griffith's meticulous attention to detail extended to researching Civil War tactics and uniforms, often consulting historical texts and occasionally actual veterans of the conflict who were still alive in 1911. The film's desertion and redemption storyline reflected Griffith's interest in moral complexity and character development, themes that would become central to his later, more ambitious works.

Visual Style

The cinematography of The Battle, credited to Biograph's regular cameraman G.W. Bitzer, employed several innovative techniques for its time. The film utilized location shooting to create a sense of authenticity, with the battle scenes filmed in natural light to enhance their realism. Bitzer employed moving camera shots during the marching sequences, following the soldiers as they advanced, which created a sense of immersion unusual for the period. The battle sequences used multiple camera angles and distances, alternating between wide shots to establish the scale of the conflict and closer shots to highlight individual actions and emotions. The film's visual style emphasized contrast between the bright, optimistic scenes of departure and the darker, more chaotic battle sequences. Bitzer's work demonstrated an understanding of visual storytelling through composition and movement, contributing significantly to the film's dramatic impact.

Innovations

The Battle demonstrated several technical innovations that were advancing cinema in 1911. Griffith's use of cross-cutting between the deserter's hiding place and the trapped soldiers created suspense and narrative complexity that was sophisticated for the period. The film's battle sequences employed techniques for simulating explosions and gunfire that were relatively realistic for the time, using practical effects and careful editing to create the illusion of large-scale conflict. The production also utilized location shooting to an unusual degree for the period, taking advantage of natural landscapes to enhance the film's visual scope and authenticity. The film's editing, particularly in the climactic rescue sequence, showed an understanding of rhythm and pacing that helped build dramatic tension. These technical achievements, while modest compared to later films, contributed to the ongoing development of cinematic language during this crucial period in film history.

Music

As a silent film, The Battle was originally accompanied by live musical performance in theaters. The score would typically have been provided by the theater's house musician or orchestra, using compiled music appropriate to the film's dramatic needs. Common selections might have included patriotic songs like 'Battle Hymn of the Republic' for the departure scenes, dramatic classical pieces for the battle sequences, and tender romantic themes for the scenes between the soldier and his sweetheart. The musical accompaniment was crucial to the film's emotional impact, with musicians instructed to emphasize key moments through their performance. While no specific musical scores for The Battle survive, contemporary accounts suggest that Biograph provided general musical guidelines to theaters to ensure consistent dramatic emphasis across different venues.

Memorable Scenes

• The opening sequence of Union soldiers marching through cheering crowds, capturing the patriotic fervor of the period; The tense hiding scene where the deserter watches the battle unfold from his sweetheart's home; The climactic rescue sequence where the redeemed hero leads Union forces to save his trapped comrades; The emotional confrontation between the soldier and his sweetheart as he struggles with his shame

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews praised The Battle for its exciting action sequences and emotional power, with trade publications like The Moving Picture World commending its 'realistic battle scenes' and 'thrilling climax.' Critics noted Griffith's skill in building suspense through parallel editing and his ability to elicit emotional responses from audiences. The film was particularly appreciated for its ambitious scale and attention to historical detail, which set it apart from many other shorts of the period. Modern film historians view The Battle as an important transitional work in Griffith's career, demonstrating his developing mastery of cinematic techniques that would reach full fruition in his later features. While not as celebrated as some of Griffith's other Biograph shorts, it is recognized for its contribution to the evolution of American war cinema and its role in establishing narrative conventions that would become standard in the genre.

What Audiences Thought

The Battle was well-received by audiences of 1911, who appreciated its combination of patriotic themes, exciting action, and emotional drama. Contemporary theater owners reported strong attendance for the film, particularly in venues where it was paired with other popular Biograph releases. The Civil War setting resonated with audiences who had personal or family connections to the conflict, making the story's themes of courage and redemption particularly meaningful. The film's dramatic rescue sequence proved especially popular with viewers, becoming a talking point among filmgoers of the time. While specific box office figures are not available, the film's success contributed to Biograph's continued investment in historical and war-themed subjects, recognizing their commercial appeal to early 20th century audiences.

You Might Also Like