The Idol Dancer

Plot

The Idol Dancer follows the story of a religious zealot, his nephew, and an alcoholic beachcomber who find themselves stranded on a remote South Seas island. There they encounter a beautiful native dancer who becomes the center of a cultural and moral conflict. The religious man attempts to 'civilize' the natives and convert them to Christianity, while the beachcomber embraces their way of life. As tensions rise between the Westerners and the islanders, a complex web of desire, manipulation, and cultural misunderstanding unfolds. The film explores themes of colonialism, cultural clash, and the hypocrisy of so-called civilized society when confronted with different value systems.

Historical Background

The Idol Dancer was produced during a transitional period in American cinema and society. The year 1920 marked the beginning of the Jazz Age and the height of the first Red Scare, while also seeing the ratification of the 19th Amendment granting women's suffrage. In cinema, this was the era when feature films were becoming the industry standard, and directors like Griffith were pushing the boundaries of what could be shown on screen. The film's colonial themes reflected America's growing imperial ambitions and the prevailing attitudes of white superiority that dominated Western thought. The early 1920s also saw the beginning of Hollywood's dominance in global cinema, with American films being exported worldwide. The film's exploration of cultural clash and missionary work resonated with contemporary American attitudes toward foreign cultures and the 'civilizing mission' that many believed was their destiny.

Making Of

The production of The Idol Dancer was part of D.W. Griffith's ambitious series of films exploring different cultures and settings. Griffith invested significant resources in creating authentic-looking native villages and costumes, though many elements were based on Western stereotypes rather than accurate cultural representations. The filming on location in Florida's tropical climate proved challenging for the cast and crew, who had to contend with heat, humidity, and insects. Richard Barthelmess, who had become a star after Griffith's 'Broken Blossoms,' was given significant creative input into his character development. The film's production coincided with Griffith's establishment of his own studio and his attempts to maintain artistic independence from major studios. Tragically, during post-production, star Clarine Seymour fell ill and passed away, casting a pall over the film's release and marketing.

Visual Style

The cinematography of The Idol Dancer was handled by G.W. Bitzer, Griffith's longtime collaborator. The film featured innovative location photography that captured the beauty of tropical settings, using natural light to create atmospheric effects. Bitzer employed techniques such as soft focus and backlighting to enhance the romantic and exotic elements of the story. The native dance sequences were particularly notable for their dynamic camera work and use of movement. The film's visual style combined Griffith's characteristic use of cross-cutting and close-ups with the emerging aesthetic of location-based realism. The contrast between the 'civilized' Western characters and the 'savage' islanders was emphasized through lighting and composition, with the island scenes often shot in warmer tones and more fluid camera movements.

Innovations

The Idol Dancer demonstrated several technical innovations for its time, particularly in location photography. The film's production in tropical locations required portable equipment and innovative solutions for lighting in outdoor settings. Griffith's team developed new methods for filming in bright sunlight, using reflectors and filters to control exposure. The film also featured elaborate set constructions that blended seamlessly with natural locations, creating a convincing illusion of a remote South Seas island. The native dance sequences utilized multiple camera setups and dynamic movement, pushing the boundaries of what was technically possible in 1920. The film's special effects, while modest by modern standards, included matte paintings and composite shots that enhanced the exotic atmosphere.

Music

As a silent film, The Idol Dancer would have been accompanied by live musical performance during its theatrical run. The original score was likely composed by Griffith's regular collaborator, Joseph Carl Breil, who had scored 'The Birth of a Nation' and 'Intolerance.' The music would have featured themes representing both Western civilization and native culture, using contrasting musical motifs to underscore the film's central conflict. Typical theater orchestras of the period would have included strings, woodwinds, brass, and percussion, with exotic instruments like gongs and rattles used for the native scenes. The score would have incorporated popular songs of the era as well as classical adaptations, following the common practice of silent film accompaniment.

Memorable Scenes

• The native ritual dance sequence where the islanders perform their traditional ceremony, contrasted with the Westerners' shocked reactions
• The climactic confrontation between the religious zealot and the beachcomber over the dancer's soul
• The storm sequence that strands the Western characters on the island, filmed with innovative special effects

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception to The Idol Dancer was mixed to negative. Many critics found the film's themes heavy-handed and its moralizing preachy, even for Griffith's standards. The New York Times criticized the film's melodramatic elements while acknowledging its visual beauty. Variety noted that the film lacked the emotional power of Griffith's earlier works like 'The Birth of a Nation' or 'Intolerance.' Modern critics and film historians generally view the film as a lesser work in Griffith's canon, though some appreciate its visual style and its attempt to address complex themes of cultural conflict. The film is often cited as an example of Griffith's declining artistic power in the 1920s and his struggle to adapt to changing audience tastes.

What Audiences Thought

Audience reception to The Idol Dancer was disappointing, contributing to its status as a commercial failure. The film failed to generate the excitement and box office returns that Griffith's earlier works had enjoyed. Contemporary audiences found the story slow-moving and the moralizing tone off-putting. The film's themes of religious hypocrisy and cultural clash did not resonate with post-World War I audiences who were seeking more escapist entertainment. The tragic death of Clarine Seymour shortly before the film's release may have also affected audience interest, as she was an emerging star with a growing following. The film's poor performance was part of a pattern of commercial disappointments that would eventually lead Griffith to seek financing from major studios rather than maintaining his independence.

You Might Also Like