The Singing Fool

Plot

Al Stone is a struggling waiter and aspiring songwriter who performs his compositions for appreciative diners at a Broadway café. After years of hardship, he finally gets his big break when his song catches the attention of producer Louis Marcus and beautiful showgirl Molly. Al achieves overnight success on Broadway, marries Molly, and becomes a star performer, but their happiness is threatened when Molly's gold-digging nature emerges and she leaves him for a wealthier man. Heartbroken and professionally devastated, Al falls into despair until he reconnects with his true love, the faithful chorus girl Grace, and finds redemption through his music and their enduring love.

Historical Background

The Singing Fool was produced during the pivotal transition from silent to sound cinema in 1928, a period of massive technological and artistic upheaval in Hollywood. The film was released just one year after The Jazz Singer had revolutionized the industry, and studios were scrambling to convert their facilities and personnel to sound production. This era saw the rapid obsolescence of silent film stars who couldn't adapt to talking pictures, while stage actors like Jolson became overnight sensations. The film's production coincided with the final months of the Roaring Twenties, just before the 1929 stock market crash would dramatically impact the film industry and American society as a whole.

Making Of

The production of The Singing Fool was marked by the technical challenges of early sound recording. Director Lloyd Bacon had to work within the severe limitations of the Vitaphone system, which required actors to stand still near hidden microphones. The sound stage had to be completely silent during takes, with air conditioning turned off to avoid noise. Al Jolson, accustomed to the freedom of stage performance, found the technical constraints frustrating but adapted quickly. The film's musical numbers were recorded live during filming, a practice that would soon be replaced by pre-recording. The success of the film led to Jolson receiving an unprecedented $100,000 per film contract from Warner Bros., making him the highest-paid actor in Hollywood at the time.

Visual Style

The cinematography by Devereux Jennings and Sol Polito was constrained by the technical limitations of early sound recording. The cameras had to be housed in large soundproof booths, limiting mobility and creating a static visual style typical of early talkies. Despite these restrictions, the film used lighting techniques to create dramatic contrast between the glamorous Broadway sequences and the more intimate emotional scenes. The musical numbers featured more elaborate lighting and camera movements, taking advantage of the pre-recorded sound to allow greater visual freedom.

Innovations

The Singing Fool represented significant advances in sound film technology, building on the foundation laid by The Jazz Singer. The film featured a higher percentage of synchronized dialogue and music than previous sound films, demonstrating the commercial viability of predominantly talking pictures. The production team developed innovative techniques for hiding microphones in set pieces and costumes, allowing for more natural actor movement. The film's success helped accelerate the development of more sophisticated sound recording equipment and techniques that would soon make the Vitaphone system obsolete in favor of sound-on-film technology.

Music

The film's soundtrack was recorded using the Vitaphone sound-on-disc system and featured several popular songs composed specifically for the film. 'Sonny Boy' became the breakout hit, selling over 3 million records and becoming one of the best-selling songs of the 1920s. Other notable songs included 'There's a Rainbow 'Round My Shoulder,' 'I'm Sittin' on Top of the World,' and 'The Spaniard That Blighted My Life.' The musical numbers were performed live during filming by Al Jolson, accompanied by the Vitaphone Orchestra. The film's soundtrack was later released as one of the first movie soundtrack albums on 78-rpm records.

Memorable Scenes

• Al Jolson singing 'Sonny Boy' to his dying son, one of the most emotional scenes in early sound cinema that reportedly caused audiences to weep openly in theaters
• The opening sequence where Jolson performs for café patrons while working as a waiter, showcasing his natural performing talent
• The Broadway debut sequence where Al Stone achieves his breakthrough moment
• The heartbreaking scene where Al discovers Molly's betrayal and true motives
• The final reconciliation scene where Al and Grace reunite through their shared love of music

What Critics Said

Contemporary critics praised The Singing Fool as an impressive follow-up to The Jazz Singer, with particular acclaim for Jolson's emotional performance and the film's technical achievements in sound. The New York Times hailed it as 'a triumph of the talking picture art,' while Variety noted that 'Jolson proves his success in The Jazz Singer was no fluke.' Modern critics recognize the film as historically significant but sometimes criticize its melodramatic plot and primitive sound recording techniques. The film is now viewed as an important transitional work that helped establish conventions of the musical film genre that would persist for decades.

What Audiences Thought

The Singing Fool was an enormous popular success, becoming one of the highest-grossing films of 1928 and 1929. Audiences were particularly moved by the emotional scenes between Jolson and his on-screen son, which often provoked tears and standing ovations in theaters. The film's theme song 'Sonny Boy' resonated deeply with audiences, many of whom had lost sons in World War I, contributing to the song's massive record sales. The film's success led to sold-out showings for months in major cities, with some theaters running it continuously for over a year. Audience response was so enthusiastic that it convinced remaining skeptical studio executives to fully commit to sound production.

You Might Also Like