So Near, Yet So Far

Plot

A young man experiences love at first sight when he encounters a beautiful young woman, but his overwhelming shyness prevents him from approaching her directly. Complicating matters further, several other suitors boldly pursue the young woman, creating additional obstacles for the timid protagonist. Through a fortunate coincidence, both the young man and the woman of his dreams unknowingly find themselves staying at the same house, which belongs to mutual friends. As fate brings them into close proximity, the young man struggles to overcome his inhibitions while rival suitors continue their aggressive courtship. The romantic tension reaches its climax when dangerous robbers infiltrate the property outside the house, threatening the safety of everyone within. In the chaos that ensues, the young man must finally find his courage to protect the woman he loves and declare his feelings before it's too late.

Historical Background

1912 was a pivotal year in American cinema, marking the transition from short novelty films to more sophisticated storytelling. The film industry was still centered in the New York area, particularly Fort Lee, New Jersey, where Biograph maintained its primary studio. This period saw the rise of the star system, with actors like Mary Pickford becoming household names and major draws for audiences. The year also witnessed significant technological advancements in film equipment, though the basic grammar of cinema was still being established by pioneering directors like Griffith. Socially, 1912 America was experiencing rapid industrialization and urbanization, and films like this provided escapist entertainment for working-class audiences. The film industry was also facing legal challenges, as Thomas Edison's Motion Picture Patents Company attempted to control film production through patent enforcement, though independent producers like Biograph were increasingly resisting this monopoly.

Making Of

The production of 'So Near, Yet So Far' exemplified the rapid-fire efficiency of Biograph's output during Griffith's tenure. Griffith was known for his meticulous planning, often creating detailed storyboards and shot lists before filming began. The cast, particularly Mary Pickford, had developed an intuitive understanding of Griffith's directing style, requiring minimal verbal instruction on set. Pickford's natural acting style contrasted with the more theatrical approach common in earlier films, and Griffith encouraged this realism in his performers. The film was likely shot in just one or two days, with the cast and crew working long hours to complete multiple films simultaneously. The robber scenes would have required careful coordination and timing, as action sequences were still relatively new to cinema in 1912. Griffith was already experimenting with camera techniques that would later become his signature, including close-ups and cross-cutting to build tension.

Visual Style

The cinematography in this film reflects the Biograph Company's style during this period, characterized by static camera positions and careful composition within the frame. Billy Bitzer, Griffith's regular cinematographer, likely handled the camera work, bringing his characteristic attention to lighting and composition. The film would have utilized natural lighting when possible, supplemented by artificial lighting for interior scenes. Camera movements were minimal, as mobile camera shots were still technically challenging and rarely used in 1912. The visual storytelling relied heavily on composition and actor placement within the frame to convey relationships and emotions. Griffith was already experimenting with close-ups for emotional emphasis, though these were used sparingly compared to his later works. The film's visual style would have included careful attention to period details in costumes and set design, reflecting the Biograph Company's commitment to production values despite their rapid production schedule.

Innovations

While not among Griffith's most technically innovative works, this film demonstrates several important technical practices of the era. The use of cross-cutting between the romantic storyline and the approaching robbers shows Griffith's mastery of parallel editing to build suspense. The film's single-reel format required efficient storytelling within approximately 12 minutes, influencing the development of concise narrative techniques. The production likely utilized Biograph's patented camera equipment, which was among the most advanced of its time. The film's editing techniques, while simple by modern standards, represented the cutting edge of cinematic grammar in 1912. The lighting techniques used for interior scenes were becoming increasingly sophisticated, allowing for more naturalistic performances. The film's preservation on 35mm nitrate stock, while dangerous for long-term storage, provided excellent image quality for contemporary audiences.

Music

As a silent film, 'So Near, Yet So Far' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during theatrical exhibition. The specific musical score was not recorded or standardized, as theaters typically employed musicians who would improvise or select appropriate pieces to accompany the film. Larger theaters might have had a small orchestra or organist, while smaller venues might have used just a pianist. The music would have followed the dramatic structure of the film, with romantic themes for the love scenes and more suspenseful music during the robbery sequence. Popular songs of the era, classical pieces, or specially composed mood music might have been used depending on the resources of each theater. The lack of synchronized sound meant that musical accompaniment varied significantly between different exhibition venues, making each viewing experience unique. The film's emotional content would have been heavily dependent on the skill and interpretation of the accompanying musicians.

Memorable Scenes

• The climactic sequence where the shy protagonist must finally overcome his fear to protect his beloved from the robbers, representing both physical and emotional courage in the face of danger.

What Critics Said

Contemporary critical reception for individual Biograph shorts in 1912 is difficult to document, as film criticism was still in its infancy and most publications focused on the industry rather than specific films. However, trade publications like The Moving Picture World generally praised Griffith's work at Biograph for its sophistication and emotional depth. Modern film historians and critics recognize films like this as important steps in Griffith's development as a filmmaker and in the evolution of American cinema. The film is often cited in scholarly works examining Griffith's early career and his development of cinematic techniques. Critics particularly note how Griffith used the short format to experiment with narrative structure and character development, practices that would influence his later, more famous works. The film is generally regarded as a solid example of Griffith's romantic shorts from this period, though not among his most groundbreaking or innovative works of the era.

What Audiences Thought

Audience reception for Biograph shorts in 1912 was generally positive, particularly for films featuring popular stars like Mary Pickford. Contemporary accounts suggest that Pickford's films were especially popular with female audiences, who identified with her natural acting style and the relatable romantic situations she portrayed. The combination of romance and danger in this film would have appealed to the broad audience base that nickelodeons and early movie theaters attracted during this period. The theme of shy lovers overcoming obstacles resonated with working-class audiences who often faced similar social challenges in their own lives. While specific audience reactions to this particular film are not documented, the continued demand for similar romantic shorts throughout 1912 indicates their popularity. The film's success can be inferred from Biograph's continued production of similar romantic dramas throughout this period, suggesting strong audience demand for this type of content.

You Might Also Like