The Miser's Heart

Plot

An elderly miser lives alone in his building, hoarding his wealth in a locked safe while showing little compassion for his neighbors. When a group of thieves learns of his hidden fortune, they break into his home demanding access to the safe. The miser stubbornly refuses to open it, even when the criminals threaten his own life. In a desperate attempt to force his cooperation, the thieves seize a young girl who lives in the same building and threaten to kill her if he doesn't reveal his combination. The miser faces an impossible choice between his lifelong obsession with wealth and the innocent life of a child, ultimately leading to a dramatic confrontation that tests the limits of his greed and humanity.

Historical Background

1911 was a pivotal year in American cinema, marking the transition from novelty to narrative art form. The film industry was consolidating around the Motion Picture Patents Company (the 'Edison Trust'), which Biograph was a member of. This period saw the establishment of Hollywood as a production center, though this film was made in New York. Social issues of the time, including growing wealth inequality and urban poverty, were reflected in the film's themes. The year also saw the rise of film censorship movements, leading to increased scrutiny of content involving children in peril. Cinema was transitioning from vaudeville accompaniment to standalone attractions, with theaters specifically built for film exhibition becoming more common.

Making Of

D.W. Griffith was in his most productive phase during 1911, often directing multiple films per week. 'The Miser's Heart' was typical of his Biograph period - quickly produced but technically innovative. Griffith was already developing his signature techniques of parallel editing and close-ups, which would later revolutionize cinema. The cast was drawn from Biograph's stock company of actors who appeared regularly in Griffith's films. Adolph Lestina, who played the miser, was a character actor specialized in playing elderly roles despite being in his 40s. The production faced the typical challenges of early cinema filming - unpredictable weather for exterior shots, the limitations of early film stock sensitivity, and the need to shoot scenes in sequence due to the lack of sophisticated editing capabilities.

Visual Style

The film was photographed by Billy Bitzer, Griffith's frequent collaborator and one of the era's most innovative cinematographers. The visual style includes the use of deep focus to show multiple planes of action, and careful composition to emphasize the emotional dynamics between characters. Bitzer employed natural lighting for interior scenes, creating a realistic atmosphere that enhanced the film's dramatic impact. The camera work includes some movement, which was still relatively uncommon in 1911, and the use of medium close-ups to highlight emotional moments, a technique Griffith was pioneering at the time.

Innovations

The film demonstrates Griffith's early mastery of parallel editing to build suspense, cutting between the thieves, the miser, and the threatened child. This technique was still innovative in 1911 and represents an important step in the development of cinematic language. The film also shows sophisticated use of screen space and actor positioning to convey power dynamics and emotional states. The pacing and rhythm of the editing create a dramatic arc that builds to its climax, showing Griffith's understanding of how to manipulate audience emotions through timing and cuts.

Music

As a silent film, 'The Miser's Heart' would have been accompanied by live musical performance during theatrical exhibition. The score would typically have been provided by the theater's pianist or organist, often using compiled classical pieces or popular melodies appropriate to the mood of each scene. No specific musical score was composed for the film, as was standard practice for Biograph productions of this era. The music would have emphasized the tension during the confrontation scenes and provided emotional underscoring for the moral dilemma at the film's core.

Memorable Scenes

• The climactic confrontation where the miser must choose between his wealth and the child's life, demonstrating Griffith's early mastery of suspense through parallel editing and close-ups

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews in trade publications like The Moving Picture World praised the film's emotional power and Griffith's direction. Critics noted the effectiveness of the suspense build-up and the strong performances, particularly from Adolph Lestina as the miser. The film was recognized as an example of the growing sophistication of American narrative films. Modern film historians view it as a solid example of Griffith's early period, showing his developing skills in creating dramatic tension and moral complexity. While not considered a masterpiece like his later works, it's valued for its place in the development of American cinema and its demonstration of Griffith's evolving directorial style.

What Audiences Thought

The film was well-received by audiences of 1911, who were drawn to its emotional story and suspenseful climax. The theme of a child in danger was particularly effective in eliciting audience response, a technique Griffith would continue to refine throughout his career. The moral resolution satisfied contemporary audiences' expectations for clear moral lessons in entertainment. As part of Biograph's regular output, it helped build audience loyalty to both the company and Griffith's developing reputation as a director who could deliver emotionally engaging stories.

You Might Also Like