The Oath and the Man

Plot

Set against the backdrop of the French Revolution, 'The Oath and the Man' tells the story of a wealthy nobleman who abducts the wife of a perfume merchant. The merchant, who becomes a leader of the peasant uprising, is torn between his desire for revenge and a sacred oath he made to his priest to leave vengeance to God. As the revolution intensifies, the merchant struggles with his conscience while his wife remains captive. The film explores themes of faith, justice, and personal sacrifice during one of history's most tumultuous periods. Ultimately, the merchant must choose between his sworn oath and his natural human desire for retribution against the aristocrat who wronged him.

Historical Background

1910 was a pivotal year in early American cinema, marking the transition from simple novelty films to more sophisticated narrative storytelling. The nickelodeon boom was at its peak, with thousands of small theaters across the country showing short films continuously. D.W. Griffith was establishing himself as the most important director in American cinema, pioneering techniques that would become standard filmmaking practices. The film industry was still centered primarily in New York and New Jersey, with Hollywood not yet established as the film capital. This period saw the emergence of the star system, with actors like Mary Pickford (who also worked for Biograph) becoming the first movie stars. The French Revolution setting would have resonated with contemporary audiences who were familiar with the historical events through literature and education. 1910 also saw the beginning of the move toward longer films, though one-reelers like this still dominated the market.

Making Of

D.W. Griffith was under contract with Biograph and worked at an incredible pace, often completing multiple films in a single week. The cast and crew were essentially a repertory company, with actors like Henry B. Walthall and Florence Barker appearing in numerous Biograph productions. Griffith was already developing his reputation as a master of narrative storytelling, though he had not yet created the feature-length epics that would make him famous. The French Revolution setting would have required more elaborate costumes and sets than typical Biograph productions, though still modest by later standards. Griffith was known for his meticulous attention to detail and his ability to extract strong performances from his actors, even in these very short films. The production would have been completed in just a few days from start to finish, reflecting the factory-like efficiency of early film studios.

Visual Style

The cinematography would have been typical of Biograph productions in 1910, using stationary cameras with occasional pans or tracking shots. The film was shot by Biograph's regular cinematographers, likely including Billy Bitzer or G.W. Bitzer, who frequently worked with Griffith. Lighting would have been natural or simple artificial lighting, as sophisticated lighting techniques had not yet been developed. The camera work would have been functional rather than artistic by modern standards, but Griffith was already beginning to experiment with camera placement and movement to enhance storytelling. The French Revolution setting would have allowed for more visually interesting compositions than typical contemporary dramas.

Innovations

While 'The Oath and the Man' does not feature major technical innovations, it represents the state of the art in 1910 filmmaking. The film was shot on 35mm film at approximately 16 frames per second, standard for the era. Griffith was already experimenting with editing techniques like cross-cutting to build tension and parallel action. The film likely used some of Griffith's emerging techniques for creating emotional impact through performance and staging. The historical setting required more elaborate production design than typical contemporary dramas, showing the growing sophistication of film production. The film represents the gradual evolution from the primitive cinema of the 1900s toward the more sophisticated storytelling techniques that would dominate the 1910s.

Music

Like all films of 1910, 'The Oath and the Man' was a silent film that would have been accompanied by live music during theatrical presentations. The typical accompaniment might have included a pianist or small ensemble playing appropriate music to match the mood of each scene. For a dramatic historical film like this, the music would have included classical pieces, popular songs of the era, and improvised passages to enhance the emotional impact. No original score was composed specifically for the film, as was standard practice at the time. The music would have varied from theater to theater, with larger venues sometimes employing full orchestras for their presentations.

Memorable Scenes

• The nobleman's abduction of the perfume merchant's wife, establishing the central conflict
• The merchant's anguished prayer before the priest, swearing the oath that will haunt him
• The merchant addressing the revolutionary crowd, torn between personal vengeance and his sacred oath
• The climactic confrontation between the merchant and the nobleman as the revolution rages around them

What Critics Said

Contemporary reviews of individual Biograph shorts from 1910 are scarce, as trade publications of the era focused more on general industry news than specific film reviews. However, Griffith's work for Biograph was generally well-regarded by exhibitors and audiences. The Moving Picture World, a leading trade publication of the time, frequently praised Biograph productions for their quality and storytelling. Modern film historians recognize Griffith's Biograph period as crucial to his development as a filmmaker, though individual films like this are often overshadowed by his later, more famous works. Critics today view these early films as important artifacts showing the evolution of cinematic language and Griffith's growing mastery of the medium.

What Audiences Thought

Audiences in 1910 would have viewed 'The Oath and the Man' as part of a program of several short films shown continuously at nickelodeons. The dramatic story and historical setting would have provided variety from the comedies and simple chase films that dominated the era. Griffith's reputation for quality storytelling was growing, and his films were popular with exhibitors who knew they would draw audiences. The emotional story and moral themes would have appealed to the primarily working-class audiences who frequented nickelodeons. While specific audience reactions to this particular film are not recorded, the continuing demand for Griffith's Biograph films indicates they were well-received by contemporary moviegoers.

You Might Also Like